HARRISBURG — The Pittsburgh region is a step closer to being rid of a unique requirement to use a less-polluting, more-expensive blend of summer gasoline after a state air quality advisory board voted to move forward with the repeal last week.
A state law passed in May 2014 directed the Department of Environmental Protection to eliminate the summer blend mandate for seven southwestern Pennsylvania counties with a history of air pollution problems once the region shows it can comply with federal air quality standards.
The special gasoline requirement was adopted more than 15 years ago to address ozone pollution, which generally forms in the sunny summer from a combination of other pollutants emitted by cars and industry, and is associated with a suite of respiratory and heart problems.
Pittsburgh-area summer gasoline has to have a lower Reid vapor pressure than conventional gasoline — up to 7.8 pounds per square inch instead of up to 10 psi for regular gasoline blended with ethanol.
The relative rarity of the blend increases costs and creates headaches for distributors and gas stations switching over to the blend every May. Lawmakers who advocated the repeal say the program pushes gasoline prices 10 to 15 cents per gallon higher in the seven-county region than in neighboring areas, although DEP said it does not know where those figures come from and it does not have current studies that show that difference in price.
The three most recent years of air monitoring data suggest the region will meet ozone standards that were set by federal regulators in 2008, which will allow DEP to begin the process of taking the summer blend program off the books.
State regulators also have to show that repealing the special summer blend won’t lead to worse air quality in the region, so DEP plans to take credit for existing, uncounted programs that reduce emissions from solvents and diesel marine engines to offset the pollution benefits that will be erased once the region switches to regular gas.
“Pennsylvania is not the only state in the nation that is repealing the low-RVP programs because of the minimal benefits,” DEP’s air quality bureau director Joyce Epps said at the advisory board meeting. Several other jurisdictions have gotten approval from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency to remove or relax the programs, including areas of Colorado, Louisiana, Florida, North Carolina and Alabama.
DEP officials say federal standards for cleaner cars and cleaner fuels have narrowed the emissions benefits of the Pittsburgh-specific gas program. In a decade, their analysis shows, the benefits will diminish to near zero.
Environmental and public health groups have questions about those numbers, which federal environmental regulators have asked DEP to revise to reflect the maximum possible emissions benefit that will be lost if the program is repealed. Still, DEP officials say the revised figures are likely to show that maintaining the summer blend would have only minor, if any, future benefits and other emissions reductions are more than enough to offset any increase.
“It’s a terrible idea,” said Joe Osborne, legal director of the regional environmental organization Group Against Smog and Pollution. “We continue to have an ozone problem in southwestern Pennsylvania and this is a very cost-effective, very focused control strategy to reduce those ozone emissions.”
Plus new federal ozone standards established in October are about to make it harder for the Pittsburgh region to meet air quality limits. The EPA lowered the threshold of permissible ozone concentrations to protect public health from 75 parts per billion to 70 parts per billion. DEP said that two air quality monitors in the seven-county region — in Allegheny and Armstrong counties — would fail to meet those new limits if they were in effect today, based on measured levels over the last three years.
Still, all sides in the debate said timing and other factors make it doubtful the EPA would reject Pennsylvania’s plan to get rid of the summer blend because stricter ozone mandates are on the horizon.
“I’m hoping that the repeal would still survive the stronger ozone standards that are being announced by EPA,” said John Kulik, executive vice president of the Pennsylvania Petroleum Association, which supports the switch.
The air quality advisory board vote last week to move forward with the repeal is really just a first step, Mr. Kulik said, “but I would say it is a critical step because they are actually moving on the process.”
“Although many of our folks had really wanted to get this requirement repealed much earlier, I think this process is a responsible approach,” he said.
The repeal probably won’t be finished in time for next summer, he said, so distributors and drivers should expect at least another year of the special gasoline.
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.