A Post-Gazette analysis of DEP records provides a detailed look at the Marcellus Shale industry and its regulation, showing the serious problems in spotting well-site incidents, record keeping, and hiring adequate numbers of inspectors; it also shows how the industry has responded to accidents and surrounding publicity. This is the first of three parts.

***

Six years into the Marcellus Shale natural gas boom, the state Department of Environmental Protection’s online data on Pennsylvania well sites is a study in incomplete data and inaccurate information.

The DEP acknowledges that the online Compliance Report, which was supposed to provide clear and accessible information on everything from spills to driller performance, is so error-ridden that it is virtually impossible to get an accurate picture of how drilling is being regulated.

Advertise with us

The Post-Gazette analyzed every paper record for every Marcellus well incident that resulted in fines through June 1, 2014, and compared those to the information on the online Compliance Report.

It found vast discrepancies between the field reports of the incidents and the electronic accounting of them. Among the findings:

• Of the 568 incidents at a Marcellus well that resulted in a fine, only 380 are listed online.

• Of those 380 listed incidents, a comparison with paper records showed that in 48 cases at least one violation was obscured because a generic code was used, in 44 cases an incorrect code was used, and in 102 cases at least one violation was completely dropped.

• In all, 256 violations were dropped. For example, in a Washington County case, Rice Energy was fined $85,000 for 10 violations, but the online record showed only one violation.

Advertise with us

• Of the 188 fines not found online, 172 were for less serious administrative violations of filing late well records (149) and failing to obtain a state permit (23). Sixteen were for spills, sediment-laden water running off a site, or other potentially serious incidents that could directly impact the environment.

PG graphic: Problems with DEP’s data

(Click image for larger version)

Scott Perry, a DEP deputy secretary in charge of the oil and gas management office, said the problems are evidence of a fact that the state concedes: “We recognize we’re not transparent enough. We have to do better.”

The Post-Gazette analysis provides detail on issues discussed in a scathing state auditor general review of the Department of Environmental Protection’s oversight, issued July 22. The audit described the agency’s shortcomings, including lack of enforcement and data problems.

Advertise with us

The Post-Gazette found that the core problem with the violation discrepancies is that the system for entering data electronically doesn’t include all of the state violation codes, so inspectors can’t accurately transfer data from paper records to the online system. The result has been that sometimes inspectors don’t enter violations, sometimes they enter under a code that is not an accurate reflection of the violation, and sometimes they enter a generic code that doesn’t give a specific idea of what the violation was.

The data problems can obscure specific cases.

For example, only two of four violations issued in one of the worst incidents in the Marcellus era — a March 2010 fire and spill at an Atlas Resources well site in Washington County that resulted in an $80,000 fine — appear in the DEP database, making it look like a less serious event.

The incident occurred after more than a year of complaints from the landowner and neighbors about the well site in Hopewell.

A drill pit filled with thousands of gallons of hydraulic fracturing flowback fluid, mixed with condensate gas, ignited when a nearby generator backfired, creating a massive fireball that burned the drill pit and a holding tank. The fire also resulted in a fluid spill when it burned the pit’s plastic liner.

Advertise with us

State officials issued the fine based on four violations issued the day of the incident: failure to maintain 2 feet of “freeboard,” or space between the top of the fluid in the pit and the sides of the pit where it might overflow; failure to properly implement the Preparedness, Prevention and Contingency Plan; and two separate violations for improper disposal of fluids.

Only the failure to maintain required freeboard and failure to implement the PPC plan were listed online; the two most important violations — for improper disposal of fluids — were not. The state inspector noted in the comments section found in the Compliance Report, “78.57a and 78.54 not in efacts.” Those were codes for the two citations for improper disposal of fluids.

Similarly, only two out of four violations are listed for a Somerset County spill that resulted in Chief Oil & Gas being fined $180,000 — one of the largest fines in the state’s history. The two most significant violations were the two that were not entered online.

That incident began on June 10, 2010, when a state inspector found an oily substance on a corner of a well pad on a family dairy farm in the Laurel Hill Creek special protection watershed.

It took Chief five months, with repeated prodding by the state, to properly clean up the site.

Advertise with us

The paper inspection report shows that the inspector initially cited Chief for failure to maintain 2 feet of freeboard in a drill pit; discharge and improper disposal of industrial fluids; failure to dispose of residual waste properly; and failure to properly report a release.

The only violations listed online are the freeboard violation – which could be issued in a non-spill case where the pit was merely too full – and a version of the violation for failure to report a release.

Detailed spreadsheet:  All Marcellus shale well fines in Pennsylvania

No way to document industry record

Drillers, industry trade groups and DEP officials all say they are convinced that drillers are running more environmentally safe operations now than they were at the beginning of the Marcellus era.

Advertise with us

“I truly believe in the last three years there have been dramatic strides in the industry,” said Matt Pitzarella, spokesman for Range Resources, the driller with the second-highest number of Marcellus wells in the state.

But such improvement can’t be verified using the state’s database because it is riddled with errors and alterations, and many fines and violations don’t appear online.

The Post-Gazette filed Right-to-Know requests to review and compare the paper files for each incident with the online version of those incidents.

The DEP began using its internal data collection system, called eFACTS, in 1994 and created a public version in 2002. In January 2012, the DEP added the Oil and Gas Compliance report, which is more accessible but based on the same flawed data.

The Post-Gazette analyzed incidents that led to fines, but since there are thousands of violations that do not lead to fines, the high percentage of unrecorded violations — more than a quarter of fined incidents had violations dropped — translates into a vast number of unrecorded violations in the DEP data. Even if the percentage of unrecorded violations among all those the state has levied is lower, the data issue means there is no way to accurately assess the regulation of the industry.

Advertise with us

In addition, at least 600 more violations in the incidents analyzed are obscured because inspectors used generic codes when they entered the data, instead of a specific violation.

And hundreds of additional violations are altered by the time they are entered online, sometimes to the point that the incident they describe is dramatically different from what actually happened according to the paper files.

All three problems are because inspectors have never had all of the state violation codes to choose from in the eFACTS “dropdown box” when they enter violations online.

Inspectors frequently have to choose one of three “work-arounds” to enter the violations: drop it altogether, use a generic code, or enter a different violation code as similar as possible to the one that was intended.

The Post-Gazette found a dozen occasions when an inspector or compliance officer for the DEP typed into the “notes” or “comments” section of the Compliance database what the actual violations were and added “could not find in eFACTS” or something similar.

Advertise with us

Industry officials have been aware of the problem for years.

“I’d try to go into DEP’s database and it was difficult to reconcile the notice of violations I’d gotten with what I was seeing online,” said Scott Blauvelt, regulator manager for East Resources, a driller that sold all of its Marcellus wells to Shell in 2011 but is now exploring additional drilling.

Carl Carlson, Range Resource’s director of government affairs and a geologist by training, told the Post-Gazette in 2012 that Range so distrusts DEP data that it keeps its own record of well-related statistics. Range continues to gather its own data, though spokesman Matt Pitzarella said it appreciates the state’s efforts to improve data collection.

“The industry and the state, both the DEP and the PUC, have gone through great lengths to continue to capture timely and accurate information since Act 13 was signed into law. It’s important and something that we take very seriously,” he said.

In addition, Mr. Pitzarella said, "I wouldn’t classify our position as ‘distrust’ of the [DEP] data."

Advertise with us

But it took DEP several years to begin making the obvious fix: Put all the violation codes into the eFACTS’ dropdown box.

The Post-Gazette began asking questions about data problems in early 2013. DEP officials said 69 new violation codes were added in November to the system’s existing 102 codes.

The DEP plans to add about 450 more to replace the “older antiquated eFACTS codes that were written prior to unconventional drilling,” DEP spokeswoman Lisa Kasianowitz wrote in an email Wednesday. Inspectors know about the 69 added codes and will get additional training when the other codes are added, Ms. Kasianowitz wrote.

“The codes are being written to truly reflect the actual regulatory language so there will be no ambiguity of the violations being displayed in public eFACTS to exactly what the violation is and what statute is being cited,” she added. “The department remains committed to reviewing and implementing new measures to ensure the Oil and Gas Program is operating consistently and efficiently.”

Inconsistency

Advertise with us

Another problem that the industry has long complained about is the inconsistency in how inspectors do their job — something the DEP acknowledges. It is working on creating a field manual for its oil and gas division employees to standardize how, for example, well sites are inspected and violations issued.

“Incredibly,” Mr. Perry said, there has never been an oil and gas field manual before, just occasionally issued “standard operating procedures” for some routines staff performed.

John Ryder, a former state oil and gas inspector who is now the DEP’s district oil and gas operations director overseeing field operations, has long been aware of that problem.

“I started in this program. I lived that frustration,” he said. “I thought there should be something like that, and there wasn’t.”

The result of that system was that DEP staff developed sometimes widely divergent, regional methods to handle the same dilemma.

Advertise with us

In the DEP’s Northcentral and Northeast districts, the work-around when the appropriate code is not available is to use generic codes. Those districts use the generic code so often it is the second-most-cited violation against drillers statewide among online violations.

In the Southwest, the work-around is to drop the violation. Three-quarters of the dropped violations in the Post-Gazette analysis were in the Southwest.

In the Rice Energy case in Washington County, for example, paper records show 10 violations: one for not having an erosion and sedimentation plan on site; another for not obtaining permits; a third for failure to prevent runoff; a fourth for failure to notify the state of a pollution event; and six more for erosion and sedimentation controls.

But online, this incident has only one violation — for the failures with the erosion and sedimentation controls — and there is no explanation why the other violations were dropped.

Another regional difference was brought to light two years ago when drillers complained about disparities in how inspectors in the two busiest drilling areas — the Southwest region and the Northcentral and Northeast regions — handled erosion and sediment violations on well pads. A driller in the Northcentral region might receive the same violation in connection with every well that had been drilled on the pad, while a driller in the Southwest region would receive only one violation no matter how many wells had been drilled.

Advertise with us

The state has tried to stop that disparity by issuing just one violation, no matter how many wells were drilled, Mr. Ryder said.

“We absolutely knew that how people entered their information into eFACTS” differed by region, Mr. Perry said. He said the DEP is considering completely changing the way violations are issued.

“What we need to do is have that one violation and have everyone understand [for example] that when they overtop a pit, this is the code that you’re going to use. And in the comments section you can list out all of the other violations,” he said.

The state likes inspectors to cite multiple violations for the same offense from different sections of the state code – from the Clean Streams Law and the Oil & Gas Act, for example – because if the case becomes difficult and deserves a bigger fine, the state can combine potential penalties.

Such a change would mean there would be no way to compare the enforcement of the early years of the Marcellus era to future years. But Mr. Perry said the existing system is so flawed, he doesn’t think it’s possible to go back and correct the past inconsistencies and problems.

Advertise with us

He wants to end the practice whereby the only way to fully understand what is happening at a well site is to read the paper permit file at one of DEP’s six regional offices.

The state began scanning well records and eventually will require electronic filing of well records to a searchable database. That system went live in December and for now features a searchable mapping system for wells that will pull up a copy of the well permit if it has been uploaded to the system.

Mr. Perry said the goal is to make the information completely searchable: “You want to know how many Chesapeake wells are 6,000 feet deep? Well, you can run a query and get that. But we’re not there yet.”

“These are public records. Let’s get them out there for the public.”

But how long will it be before trips to the various DEP regional offices will be replaced by a few keystrokes on a computer to see complete records?

Advertise with us

“All in all, it’s going to take years,” he said. “But that is the direction we’re headed in.”

Check out PG’s interactive map of Marcellus Shales wells around Pennsylvania