Inspectors are the front line of the state’s effort to ensure development in the Marcellus is done right and with the least environmental impact possible.
The Post-Gazette’s analysis of every fine the state levied against Marcellus drillers from 2005 through June 1 this year shows that a third of spills (59 of 179) were first spotted by a state inspector. Inspectors also caught runoff problems, stream and wetland encroachment, and many other violations.
A former Department of Environmental Protection bureau chief says that points to the need for more inspectors.
“I think the numbers [of spills found by inspectors] raise a legitimate question that needs to be answered,” said George Jugovic, a former Southwest DEP bureau chief who now works as chief counsel for PennFuture, a statewide environmental organization. “If the identification of spills 30 percent of the time is dependent on DEP inspectors being on-site, how many spills are we missing?”
In addition, because of the significant data problems the DEP has with oil and gas information, the agency is that much more dependent on its inspectors, said Scott Perry, the DEP assistant secretary who oversees oil and gas.
Currently, DEP’s oil and gas management section has funding for 202 employees; about 83 of them have some kind of field inspection responsibilities, Mr. Perry said. They are either oil and gas inspectors, water quality specialists, solid waste inspectors, environmental trainees, or supervisors for all these categories. Oil and Gas Management had 45 employees in 2008 at the beginning of the Marcellus era.
Read More
In 2008, there were 1,262 inspections of 377 active, unconventional, Marcellus well sites, in addition to 10,058 inspections of 7,143 conventional, shallow wells in Pennsylvania.
By 2013, those figures had grown to 12,391 inspections of 5,559 active, unconventional wells — nearly 15 times the number of wells in 2008 — and 11,713 inspections of 7,808 conventional, shallow wells.
Inspectors also have to try to monitor the 330,000 other oil and gas wells — some active, many abandoned and dry — that have been drilled around the state over the last century and a half.
Asked if he thinks the state has enough inspectors, Gov. Tom Corbett said: “My feeling is that we do. We can always continue to monitor where we are” with the number of inspectors.
DEP has already done that and believes it needs more inspectors.
Earlier this year DEP increased natural gas well fees to raise about $4.7 million annually. Part of those funds was intended to pay for 30 full-time positions in oil and gas management. About half of those positions would be for those with inspection-related duties, Mr. Perry said, but DEP has yet to hire anyone with the additional budgeted revenue.
But former DEP secretary John Hanger said he thinks DEP needs to more than double its field staff by 105 new positions.
“This industry doesn’t self-police and it never will,” he said. “And the state doesn’t have enough staff to properly monitor what is going on out there.” He said the number of employees went from 88 to 202 by the time he left in January 2011, and should have continued increasing.
Not everyone agrees.
“Every once in a while there’s an undercurrent that we don’t have enough inspectors in the field, and I’ve got to tell you, I just don’t believe that’s true,” said Drew Crompton, spokesman for Senate President Pro Tem Joe Scarnati, R-Jefferson. “Everyone I talk to assures me there’s a sufficient number of inspectors in the field.”
Robert Watson, an associate professor emeritus of petroleum and natural gas engineering at Penn State University, has worked with the industry as a consultant. He agrees more inspectors are needed: “Certainly the more cops you have the better you are. There’s no question about that.”
Even if the state did agree to hire even more inspectors, it still hasn’t figured out how to stem the loss of some of its best employees to industry. State inspectors typically make from about $35,000 to $65,000 annually — but easily double that going to work for natural gas industry companies such as Range Resources or Chevron.
“We may have three former inspectors working for us,” said Range Resources spokesman Matt Pitzarella. “They do the same thing for us that they did for the state. They’re inspecting the well site and they know the regulations as well as anyone. And we think we’re hiring the best and the brightest people.”
Several Pennsylvania politicians say they have been told by DEP officials that they have lost 30 to 40 oil and gas employees in the past five years to industry.
Mr. Perry did not dispute the number.
That range would represent a significant portion of the DEP’s 202 employees — and a much higher percentage of the people who inspect the wells.
It’s good for the drilling companies, who get experienced inspectors, said Lou D’Amico, president and executive director of the Pennsylvania Independent Oil and Gas Association, which represents many of the companies that work in the Marcellus basin.
“But I don’t like it because what happens is you’re depleting the number of experienced people at the state level, and that leaves the state with employees who don’t have the experience in the field to review a well,” he said. “It always makes me nervous.”
Some environmental groups believe the state should try to slow down the flow of employees to industry through either regulation or by increasing state employees’ salaries.
“I think there needs to be a restriction on preventing [state regulators like inspectors] from working for industry for a year” after they leave state employment, said Nadia Steinzor, the Marcellus Regional Organizer for Earthworks, an environmental advocacy organization.
Such a regulation would also alleviate the concern of some that a state employee “might bend to the needs of industry because they might be your future employer,” she said.
Patrick Henderson, Mr. Corbett’s energy executive, does not think such a proposal makes sense.
“I don’t think that’s something that the state could do, prohibit somebody from seeking out and obtaining private-sector employment,” he said.
The revolving door makes it hard for the state, which faces challenges in finding experienced people and competing with industry salaries. Drilling in the Marcellus brought in national and international companies with billion-dollar pockets, who have increased the salary expectations. But the state can’t just up the salaries of one group of workers, said John Ryder, who oversees DEP’s oil and gas management’s field operations, including inspectors..
State inspectors are all unionized, he pointed out. “And there are biologists who work on the same kind of permits for other [non-oil and gas] programs. So how are we to say this guy is worth $40 an hour instead of $31?”
Mr. Perry believes the state will just have to live with the turnover.
“It hasn’t affected our ability to do our work at a very high level,” he said. “The folks who are staying are here for all the right reasons. It is their care and concern for our state and our citizens and Pennsylvania’s environment.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.