Morgan O’Brien calls his vision an “obvious strategy” for water customers in Pittsburgh and beyond.

“When you put everything down and people understand it, there’s no other solution,” he said.

Kicking off a public information campaign Monday, the Peoples Natural Gas CEO unveiled a plan for a new entity to replace the Pittsburgh Water and Sewer Authority as the water utility for Pittsburgh residents and, possibly, for those in neighboring communities.

The partnership, as Peoples refers to it, would have a board equally split between public representatives and officials from Peoples Water, a new subsidiary being formed to carry the Peoples’ name and interest into its first foray into water utility service.

Advertise with us

The water mains and distribution pipes currently in the ground would stay with PWSA, as would all sewer and stormwater infrastructure. But the new entity would begin replacing PWSA pipelines at the same time as Peoples Natural Gas replaces its aging system, a move that Mr. O’Brien said would cut the cost of replacement by half.

The partnership would own the new water pipelines put into the ground, and eventually the entire system would be rebuilt and belong to the partnership.

The centerpiece of the plan, which Mr. O’Brien will present at a hearing Tuesday evening in O’Hara, is a new $350 million water treatment plant in that township.

“Amazon or the next big company — this will get them excited,” Mr. O’Brien said, gesturing toward a rendering of the proposed facility in a conference room at Peoples headquarters on the North Shore.

Peoples Natural Gas rendering of proposed plant

The energy for the plant would come from a proposed hydroelectric project and roof-top solar panels, he said, and its water would be 10 times cleaner than what is currently available from the PWSA. He envisioned engineering students from local universities studying in its classroom, school kids taking tours, even weddings hosted on the large green space planned for the roof.

Advertise with us

As for who would own it, Mr. O’Brien said it could be the partnership or it could be Peoples Water, which would then lease it to the new water utility.

The details are still being hatched out, he said, and will be guided by feedback Peoples receives during public hearings and open houses planned for July and August.

PWSA, a publicly owned utility with nearly $1 billion in debt and large infrastructure needs, has been courted by many suitors over the past year. Pennsylvania American Water Co. said Monday that it is interested in acquiring the whole PWSA system, or outright privatizing it, a concept that Mayor Bill Peduto and PWSA officials have said is unacceptable.

It’s unclear how People’s proposal, which isn’t a full privatization but doesn’t maintain 100 percent public control either, will land.

“One hundred percent public means the residents of the city go it alone and have to bear the full cost of that,” said Kevin Acklin, vice president and general counsel at Peoples Natural Gas and former chief of staff to Mr. Peduto.

Advertise with us

Mr. O’Brien expects strong public support, in part because the pitch also includes a number of sweeteners. It proposes no rate increases for three years, using the building trades to construct the water treatment plant, committing that one out of every three new hires for the new utility be African-Americans, and supporting low-income customer assistance programs that tackle needs such as housing and medical care, not just utility bills.

“I can’t imagine a scenario where the city says no to us,” Mr. O’Brien said.

Public assets

Peoples Natural Gas is owned by SteelRiver Infrastructure Partners, whose investors are mainly pension and insurance funds. They gravitate toward long-term investments with predictable returns, which makes utilities a great fit.

For Deb Gross, a Pittsburgh city councilwoman and PWSA board member, that dynamic dims the luster of Mr. O’Brien’s proposal.

Advertise with us

“I appreciate his painting this pretty picture,” Ms. Gross said. “But I think what the public really needs to understand are what are the details.”

She said she’s unswayed by arguments of private industry efficiency and added that her constituents distrust the profit motive of a private company.

“The call to action is to keep it public,” Ms. Gross said. “These are not assets of investment that are meant to serve shareholders somewhere else.”

PWSA Chairman Paul Leger was similarly unimpressed.

“The [partnership] is a front that is Peoples Gas,” Mr. Leger said.

Advertise with us

And the proposed equal split of the board -- with half of its members coming from Peoples and the other half from public entities — is unacceptable, he said, explaining, “You can’t have an even number of people on a board. And why it would be a non-profit is beyond me.”

He thought Peoples would want to sell the new water treatment plant and the replaced pipelines back to the city at some point, rather than co-managing them with Pittsburgh.

Mr. Acklin said that while that’s possible, it isn’t a requirement. Peoples Water would be just as happy to be a permanent partner in the utility, he said.

Mayor Bill Peduto was unavailable for comment on Monday. His spokesman, Timothy McNulty, said the mayor previously indicated he is waiting until the PWSA presents its long-term strategic plan. Once that’s introduced, "he would welcome interest from any firm seeking to assist the authority's efforts.”

“Opportunity to repurpose”

Advertise with us

In order for Peoples to build a water treatment plant at the site it has selected in O’Hara, beneath the Highland Park Bridge, the company would either need to be certified as a public utility or seek a variance from the zoning code, said O’Hara Township manager Julie Jakubec. Mr. Acklin said Peoples intends to pursue the utility route. It will present its plan to O’Hara council members at 7 p.m. Tuesday.

Peoples Natural Gas CEO Morgan O'Brien

O’Hara gets its water from three different utilities, Ms. Jakubec said, so the township could end up being a customer of the new plant if it’s built.

At twice the capacity of the current PWSA treatment plant, Peoples Water’s proposed facility would make obsolete not just PWSA’s current treatment plant nearby but also the city’s two large reservoirs and a number of small municipal treatment plants in surrounding municipalities.

“The city has the opportunity to repurpose all of that space,” Mr. O’Brien said. To that end, Peoples has been confidentially meeting with land developers and has included in its presentation material a schematic of something called “Waterworks Village,” a housing development on the site of the current PWSA water treatment plant.

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.