Dan Rubino and Lisa Passeri found seats in the second row, prepared their notebooks, and began to swap expectations.

This will be the worst-case scenario, Mr. Rubino said. The program, called “A Petrochemical Plant for Our Neighbor? The Rest of the Story” was organized by citizen and environmental groups as a counterpoint to what they feel has been a study in apathy and propaganda.

PG graphic: Potter Township

(Click image for larger version)

Advertise with us

Mr. Rubino had already been to a handful of meetings about the giant complex that Shell Chemical Appalachia plans to build across the river from Vanport in Beaver County. Some earlier meetings had been hosted by Shell — those presented the best-case scenario, he said, adding that he expects to find truth somewhere in the middle.

The empty seat between them was reserved for Mr. Rubino’s wife, Gina, who had never been to a cracker-related meeting and only recently starting paying attention to the issue.

In a few hours, she would tell her husband that she’s scared, that maybe they should move.

He responded by serving as the calming force that his neighbor, Ms. Passeri, has grown to appreciate.

The Rubinos’ house is up a small, steep hill from the Passeris’ on the banks of the Ohio River. The young couple moved in the day after their wedding three years ago, but it wasn’t until this fall that the neighbors met — when Ms. Passeri was going door to door to mobilize Vanport residents to pay more attention to what's happening across the water.

Advertise with us

Worst-case scenario

On Dec. 1, inside the Beaver Station Cultural & Events Center, three speakers arranged themselves behind a table. Ms. Passeri took out her phone and hit record.

Iris Carter, whose childhood home in Louisiana was wedged between a Shell cracker and a refinery, connected with Ms. Passeri’s pressure point almost right away. “Your house value is gonna go down,” she warned in her presentation.

Ms. Passeri shot a look at her neighbor and nodded.

The plan had always been for the Passeris to sell and move to Florida when Mr. Passeri retires in three years. Now, Ms. Passeri fears her house is worthless. Who would want a view of a giant rail yard, she wondered.

Advertise with us

She kept the phone camera steady as Ms. Carter began to break down.

The Louisiana woman, who’s been traveling across the country speaking out against Shell, blamed the company’s plant for the sicknesses and early deaths of her mother and sister. She warned that all the townships around the Beaver County cracker would be known by their funky smell and that people will get sick. Really sick.

"Ya'll don't let them bring all this up in here," she pleaded.

The typically measured Mr. Rubino felt a swell of worry. What if his 1-year-old daughter, Maria, grows up and develops some strange disease or really severe asthma, he thought.

Workers prepare the site of a multibillion dollar petrochemical complex that Shell is building in Potter and Center townships, Beaver County on November 14, 2016. The site spans about 400 acres. (Andrew Rush / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

An engineer at a metal company in Aliquippa, Mr. Rubino came prepared with technical questions. What will be the exact concentration of particulates that the plant will emit, and over what distance and period of time, he wanted to know.

Advertise with us

He wasn't counting on the emotional impact.

"If they build this plant, this town will be ruined," said Anne Rolfes, founder of an activist group called the Louisiana Bucket Brigade, who followed Ms. Carter’s emotional testimony with a call to arms.

The women from Louisiana had no use for negotiation. There is no good way to build a chemical cracker in a residential area, they said. "Get in their way and stop them," Ms. Rolfes said.

The call carried echoes of Standing Rock in North Dakota, where a protest by Native Americans and pipeline opponents recently won a concession from the U.S. government to reroute a major oil pipeline.

Many in the crowd at Beaver Station that night wanted to believe that, despite the hundreds of millions of dollars Shell has spent and the half mile of earth that it has already moved at the site, the cracker can still be stopped.

Advertise with us

Mr. Rubino went home to comfort his wife.

Assessing the risk

The next day, Mr. Rubino read in the Beaver County Times newspaper that Shell spokesperson Michael Marr called the Louisiana women "professional protesters."

The statement threw a shadow over his experience, Mr. Rubino said. He allowed that Ms. Rolfes might fit that definition.

"I wonder about Iris though," he said. "I believe in her emotion. It had me more concerned than I ever had been at that point."

Advertise with us

Here's what concerns Mr. Rubino. After all the meetings, he still doesn't know how to assess the risk to his family.

"I think we feel helpless to really know what's safe and what's not safe, because by the time we figure it out, it's too late," he said.

Mr. Rubino acknowledged that everything has its risks, that “probably the most dangerous thing we do with our daughter is we drive her places.”

Even if he knew that there's a one in a thousand chance of something — anything — bad coming from the plant, would that be worth the financial and logistical effort of moving?

A dozen area residents interviewed over the past week said they felt concerned they weren't being provided adequate information about Shell's plans and the expected impact.

Advertise with us

Months ago, Shell submitted a voluminous application to Potter Township for a conditional use permit that will be the subject of a public meeting Tuesday afternoon. To get a copy, residents had to go to the township office.

Rumors swirled about what Shell had offered one township versus another. Many suggested that the company was paying off supporters and public officials, but offered no evidence.

Mr. Rubino found some of the comments unfair or misinformed.

"Everyone's got a motive or at least a perception that they're trying to put forward," he said.

Unlike some Beaver Countians who feel the cracker will be an unambiguous sore for the area, Mr. Rubino and Ms. Passeri aren't looking to stop the project.

Advertise with us

There will be an economic boost from the jobs and the spinoff plants that will follow the cracker, Mr. Rubino predicted.

"If it's going to bring a lot of industry into our dead economy," Ms. Passeri said, "if it's going do that, I can't even say anything because at least our people will be getting a job."

The view from Dan and Gina Rubino's back porch of their Vanport home. The couple's house overlooks the Ohio River and the site of Shell's planned ethane cracker plant. (Andrew Rush / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Still, she has her doubts that the $1.6 billion tax credit that Pennsylvania made available to Shell and the 15 years minimum of not paying local taxes that Shell gets by locating in a Keystone Opportunity Expansion Zone is worth the 600 jobs the cracker will create when it is operational.

And get this, she says. Beaver County plans to raise property taxes by 17 percent to plug its budget hole — on property she believes is now worth less because of the cracker.

"If they think for one minute they're gonna raise my taxes ...," she said.

Advertise with us

Not convinced either way

Although Ms. Passeri’s log cabin house is one of the closest to the cracker plant, the whole thing only hit her a few months ago when someone from the Clean Air Council, an environmental nonprofit, knocked on her door and started asking questions about things like flaring and fenceline air monitors.

She’d been busy with other things. Her husband recently had a triple bypass.

“I knew that somebody wanted to put a plant there, but we had Horsehead there,” she said. After all these years of living across the river from a zinc smelter, how bad could it be?

“When I found out it was the largest chemical plant in the United States — in the United States,” she said slowly, for emphasis, “in a residential neighborhood — that’s when I freaked.”

Advertise with us

As many others in the community have, Ms. Passeri has seized on the Clean Air Council’s demands that Shell install fenceline monitors — sensors placed along the perimeter of the facility that would measure the concentration of pollutants in the air and send alerts if they exceed safe limits.

The organization has appealed a permit that the state Department of Environmental Protection issued to Shell without fenceline monitoring requirements, along with several other objections.

Shell’s stance has been confusing, at best, on the issue, saying it might be amenable to the idea but refusing to commit.

"What I want to know is: can I call you people and get a test result of my water for free? Can I get a test result of the air I'm breathing, for free?" Ms. Passeri said, as if she was talking to Shell.

She is quick to add, “The Shell people couldn’t be nicer.”

Advertise with us

After she woke up one night from the noise of her windows rattling, convinced it was from the construction across the river, two of Shell's community relations officials were in her living room the next day.

They sat with her for two hours, answering questions and showing poise in the face of her husband’s wrath. He doesn’t hold his tongue the way she does, Ms. Passeri said.

She appears torn between trusting the people at Shell and being skeptical of the whole enterprise.

For Mr. Rubino, there is at least one clear smell test to gauge Shell’s credibility.

In public meetings and in the company’s application to Potter Township, Shell has said that residents would not smell any odors other than the occasional musty smell from the wastewater treatment process. None of the notorious rotten egg smell that some have reported around such plants.

Advertise with us

“If I catch of whiff of something, then they weren’t being honest,” Mr. Rubino said.

Last week, the Rubinos started breaking down their options.

Scenario 1: Sell the house and move in the next year or two, before construction on the cracker plant is finished.

Scenario 2: Time the move to coincide with the opening of the facility, some five years from now.

Scenario 3: Live in the Vanport home until the family outgrows it, which might take seven years or more.

Advertise with us

“I’m not super sold that we’re going to look to move right away,” Mr. Rubino said. “I still haven’t been convinced that the risk is excessive, but I haven’t been convinced that there’s nothing to worry about.”

“I’m on the fenceline and on the fence,” he said.

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.