Did you know you can shop for the source of your electricity?
You can browse dozens of supply companies to find the best offer — whether that be the cheapest rate, the most convenient term length or the greenest source, including wind farms in Somerset County.
Yet despite the best efforts of state regulators and retail supply companies to persuade them into the competitive market, Western Pennsylvania customers have by and large stuck with the supply rates from their utility.
But an unusual one-two punch on monthly power bills this summer could provide regulators and companies with their most convincing argument yet to lure residential customers to the competitive market: West Penn Power, which serves 720,000 customers in southwestern Pennsylvania, has increased the rates for both supply and distribution, charges that comprise almost the entire customer bill.
The distribution rate increase, the first in at least 20 years, was approved by regulators for FirstEnergy Corp.’s four Pennsylvania utilities. This meant a 13.1 percent rise for West Penn Power, or a monthly bill of $104.62 instead of $92.47 for a typical customer.
That increase is coupled with another rise in the supply rate from 5.3 to 7.3 cents per kilowatt-hour, or about a 37 percent increase, that will affect customer bills through September 1, when the Akron, Ohio-based FirstEnergy is scheduled to file another supply rate.
Read More
After the increases, West Penn customers face bills roughly 29 percent higher than they were just a few months ago. For a customer using 1,000 kilowatt-hours a month, that could mean hundreds of dollars more annually.
Suppliers losing customers
Pennsylvania and several other states deregulated ownership of electric generation in the late 1990s. Customers have the option of signing up for plans sold by so-called retail energy supply companies that are licensed by the state to compete for customers.
But shopping requires a certain amount of work, and customers easily could stick with the rate their utility charges for buying power on the open market. After some initial success in attracting customers, supply companies saw their customer base statewide stay largely flat and, this spring, begin to trickle away.
As of last month, about 2.02 million Pennsylvania customers had bought a plan from electric supplier, representing 36 percent of utility customers and 66 percent of the total electric load. That’s down nearly 10 percent from its peak of about 2.23 million customers in February 2014, according to data from the Public Utility Commission.
In particular, West Penn Power customers returned to the utility, with supply companies in West Penn’s territory losing nearly 20 percent of their residential customers since last November.
Many of those, regulators suspect, are former customers of FirstEnergy Solutions, the electric supply company owned by FirstEnergy that last year ended residential sales and pushed customers to either shop again or go with West Penn.
Observers also point out that relatively low electricity prices in Western Pennsylvania have often beat those offered by retailers.
A competitive edge?
But the FirstEnergy rate increases have provided a competitive edge retailers have been waiting for, analysts and companies said. In June, West Penn’s supply rate pulled even with the average retail supply plan listed on Choose Energy, an online platform based in San Francisco that allows consumers to compare prices and choose plans from electric suppliers.
“Given how behind the utility zone is in competitive shopping versus the rest of the state utility zones, it’s likely the first time in a few years that customers will be considering transitioning their supply charges away from FirstEnergy to a lower, locked-in supply rate,” said John Tough, vice president of business development and operations at Choose Energy.
As of July 1, at least 29 different supply companies were offering 56 residential rate plans available for West Penn customers, according to PAPowerSwitch.com, the state’s online electric market clearinghouse managed by the PUC. Rates ranged from 4.9 cents to 11.9 cents per kilowatt-hour, and 21 featured rates that were below West Penn’s.
Any time a utility raises rates is a good time for suppliers to draw attention to their offers, said Bryan Lee, spokesman for the Retail Energy Supply Association, which represents electric and natural gas suppliers operating in the 15 states and the District of Columbia that have deregulated energy retail markets.
“There’s an opportunity for customers to examine their options in the marketplace,” Mr. Lee said. Considering the low shopping numbers in the area, he added, “clearly, the first thing that needs to be done is to get the customer shopping.”
A utility arrives at a supply rate after blending together its various power purchasing contracts that vary by start date, term length and amount of energy bought. FirstEnergy utilities hold auctions every three months to buy power, explained company spokesman Scott Surgeoner. At that time, it adjusts its supply rate for all its classes of customers.
“It’s all supply and demand … We have no control over that,” Mr. Surgeoner said. “One of the reasons we do it four times a year, we try to minimize the wild price swings that could occur in the market.”
AEP Energy, the supply business owned by Columbus, Ohio-based American Electric Power, monitors utility supply rates, said AEP spokeswoman Tammy Ridout.
“We’ve found that when there are increases, customers naturally begin to look for opportunities to save money and explore other price options from suppliers,” Ms. Ridout said. “Summer electricity usage is higher for many people, so an increase in summer rates can prompt an even bigger response from customers to look at alternatives.”
The customer response remains to be seen, however, and competitive market advocates have guessed wrong before.
Last June, for example, West Penn filed for an even larger supply rate increase of 50 percent — from 4.96 to 7.51 cents per kilowatt-hour — after the polar vortex disrupted the power market. But competitive market prices were still not low enough to encourage switching, and the 4,000 or so West Penn customers retail suppliers gained during the summer were erased by the end of the year.
Other retail supply companies stressed that price is only one part of an offer. NRG Home has tested a variety of rewards programs that cater to customers, including a pilot program with Comcast in the Pittsburgh area last year.
“We’re looking at a lot of different factors that influence how we structure those offers,” said Heather Farber, managing director of NRG Home. “We’re really trying to look more broadly, whether it’s price or other services we offer.”
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.