Kathleen Treschow just wanted the phone calls to stop.
Her small business contract with FirstEnergy Solutions, a competitive energy supplier and subsidiary of Akron, Ohio-based FirstEnergy Corp., was set to expire this May. After the announcement last year the supplier would end new sales to residential and small business customers, Ms. Treschow was inundated with offers from competing suppliers hoping to sell electricity to her Canonsburg civil engineering firm, HMT & Associates, Inc.
So she went to PA Power Switch, the state’s online clearinghouse for electricity shopping, and found a six-month, fixed-rate plan with AEP Energy Inc., a Columbus, Ohio-based electric supplier. During the online enrollment process, she was never prompted to provide the exact date of the switch or the fact that she was still under contract.
“I knew I had two months to go,” she said. “You just assume it switches when your first contract ends and the next one begins. You assume whatever parties hold this information would exchange it ... I was trying to be a proactive customer.”
To Ms. Treschow’s surprise, her utility, West Penn Power Co., switched her account within days — and FirstEnergy Solutions slapped on a termination fee of $1,000 for leaving the contract early.
After she filed an informal complaint with the state Public Utility Commission and after she explained her situation to both suppliers and her utility, FirstEnergy Solutions rescinded the fee.
Ms. Treschow’s switching hassle highlights the confusion some customers can experience when shopping for an electric supplier in Pennsylvania, especially when they have the ability to switch faster than ever and as suppliers become more aggressive with recruiting customers.
Switching is a maneuver involving coordination between suppliers, which sell the electricity, and the default utility, which delivers the electricity and issues the monthly bill. While a utility regularly communicates with a supplier on billing rates, it knows nothing about the terms of an individual supply contract.
“The contract is between the supplier and the customer,” said Diane Francis, spokeswoman for FirstEnergy Solutions. “So we would recommend that before a customer makes any changes to their contract, they contact the supplier and ask questions.”
Accelerated switching, unasked questions
When the PUC issued rules last year requiring utilities to switch customers between suppliers within three business days, competitive suppliers applauded. The commission was responding to the variable electric rate spikes of early 2014 by granting unhappy customers a way to move on quickly.
But suppliers also predicted “significant customer dissatisfaction over the imposition of early termination fees,” as described by the Retail Energy Supply Association, an industry group representing electric suppliers.
When a customer signs up with a chosen supplier, that supplier sends a switch request to the customer’s utility, which processes the switch. As it stands, “There’s no way for a supplier to request a date for the switch,” explained Ritchie Hudson, the group’s Pennsylvania chairman.
“If you had this operational capability, the supplier could build their enrollment process to ask the customer their expiration date” for their current contract, Mr. Hudson said.
While it is technically possible for suppliers to ask customers to specify an effective start date, that requires an internal workaround on the supplier’s part.
When FirstEnergy Solutions was still accepting new customers, it allowed small- and medium-sized business customers to provide the end date of their current contract, Ms. Francis said. But to do so, FirstEnergy Solutions had to hold the official enrollment request it sends to the utility until four days prior to the specified date.
This is a fix that would have been too burdensome for the company to provide for residential customers, she added.
Given these operational hurdles, Mr. Hudson said, the problem is best solved on the utility’s side by improving utilities communication systems to process a start date beginning in the future.
In a response last November to the FirstEnergy utilities’ plans to comply with the accelerated switching rule, the retail supply group specifically asked that the utilities take into account a customer’s future enrollment date.
The PUC could not comment on the supplier group’s proposal because it is under consideration, said spokeswoman Robin Tilley in an email. But she said the commission expects all suppliers to ask customers for a preferred start date and to hold the transaction request until their contract ends.
Growing pains
Customers’ concerns about early cancellation fees are valid, said John Tough, vice president of business development and operations of Choose Energy, an online platform based in San Francisco that allows consumers to compare prices and choose plans from electric suppliers.
Choose Energy — which Ms. Treschow used to select AEP Energy — does not ask Pennsylvanians for a start date. In more established deregulated markets such as in Texas, customers can choose the exact date in the next 60 days that they want their electricity provider to switch, Mr. Tough said.
“When a deregulated market is newer to the switching process, like Pennsylvania, this process of switching a customer to [a competitive supplier] is more fuzzy,” he said.
Mr. Tough said Choose Energy will roll out a new feature later this month that submits the customer's enrollment application to the supplier at the right time.
“That is intelligence we now have for being at the center of the market,” he said. “We consider ourselves becoming the customer-friendly utility switching destination since the utilities are taking too long to get there.”
Mr. Hudson called the issue a “growing pain” for the competitive energy market.
Most suppliers offer a range of enrollment options, including online, over the phone and through a third party, but most suppliers and customers prefer the convenience of the online option, he said.
While the PUC approved the first phase of accelerated switching plans in December with no change to the utility’s communication protocol, suppliers are hopeful that by the end of the second phase slated for this summer, utilities will have built in a mechanism that asks for a switch date.
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.