The Pennsylvania Supreme Court on Tuesday handed EQT Corp. a procedural victory in a case over the way environmental regulators calculate fines for ongoing pollution.
In a majority opinion by Chief Justice Thomas Saylor, the Supreme Court said the Downtown-based natural gas company (EQT) deserves a direct answer from the Commonwealth Court about whether the state Department of Environmental Protection is properly interpreting the Clean Streams Law when it tallies violations and penalties.
DEP is seeking to fine EQT at least $4.5 million for allowing waste fluids from shale gas operations to leak through the liner in a Tioga County wastewater pond. DEP argues that fines continue to mount every day that residual contamination in the soil keeps spreading into state waters after a spill. The company argues penalties should only be calculated until a leak is stopped.
In the 3-1 decision, the justices reversed an earlier Commonwealth Court decision that would have required EQT to exhaust its case in a lower environmental tribunal before seeking a review from the state’s higher courts. The Supreme Court’s decision returns the case to the Commonwealth Court to consider the correct reading of the law.
In his dissent, Justice Max Baer worried that the court was eroding the requirement that administrative tribunals should review cases first.
“I am concerned that the Majority has created an exception to the requirement of exhaustion of administrative remedies that will swallow the rule,” he wrote.
EQT General Counsel Lewis B. Gardner said in a statement that the company is pleased with the decision.
“We look forward to a hearing before the Commonwealth Court on the PADEP’s erroneous legal interpretation of the Clean Streams Law,” he said.
A DEP spokesman declined to comment.
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.