On a certain block in Pittsburgh’s Uptown neighborhood, which is mostly one big missed opportunity between the hubs of Downtown and Oakland, there are two very similar parcels of land with very different realities — and tax burdens.

On one parcel is a beautifully restored townhome, the kind of place that hearkens back to the neighborhood’s history as “Soho.” It has modern environmental upgrades and is occupied by taxpaying residents contributing their money and presence to this transitional neighborhood.

Farther down the block is a parcel of vacant land, the kind of place that makes Uptown look unstable and unfinished. There’s a sign warning about “Private Property” but no other improvements. The parcel is owned by a real estate developer.

I’m not naming the street or the owners because there may be stories behind them that would make it unfair to single them out. But they are representative of the experience of thousands of Pittsburghers in dozens of neighborhoods: productive and unproductive (or even counterproductive) land uses adjacent to one another.

Advertise with us

Here’s the problem: The productive parcel is valued by Allegheny County at over $220,000, while the unproductive parcel is valued at around $30,000. That means the homeowners who spent their own resources to improve their property are paying more of those resources — seven times more — in property taxes than the developer down the street.

In other words, a city with an abundance of vacant land has a tax system that actively discourages improving that land. But there is a way to fix it. In fact, it’s one Pittsburgh used for the vast majority of its modern history, for nearly 90 years until 2001: The land value tax.

Location, location

First, a quick primer on what’s probably the most hated tax (and it’s a competitive field): the property tax.

Economists generally favor the property tax because it’s hard to evade and discourages economic activity less than the alternatives. Property owners hate it because it feels like paying rent to the government on something that’s supposed to be yours.

It’s better to think of it as your share of the cost of the services that enhance your property’s value. But I digress.

Advertise with us

The value of the property on which you’re taxed is made up of two components: the land and the improvements constructed on it. These values are just whatever people are willing to pay for them.

The building value, therefore, is related to the nature of the improvements. Bigger, nicer building means higher value. Easy.

The land value, however, is related almost exclusively to location. If there were nothing on this parcel, how desirable would it be? This depends on the qualities of the land itself, its proximity to attractive features and services, strong surrounding communities and so on.

Most property tax regimes treat these the same. But what if they didn’t?

Encouraging improvements

In a split-value property tax system, land is taxed at a much higher rate than improvements. (Pittsburgh’s multiple topped out at 7-to-1 in the depths of the steel crisis.) This is because it’s impossible to discourage land construction through taxation, but it’s very possible to discourage building construction through taxation.

Advertise with us

Take a plot of vacant land in a marginal Pittsburgh neighborhood that needs investment. A frugal developer might be able to build a modest rental duplex for $500,000.

But let’s say that increases the value of the parcel by $600,000. This, in turn, increases the tax burden by $16,000 per year. Over 30 years, those taxes essentially double the original construction cost, punishing the act of improving not just the land but the neighborhood.

If anything is built at all, furthermore, those costs get passed on to renters.

In a split-tax system, the taxes on the undeveloped land would have been much higher to begin with, and the increase in taxes lower. This encourages construction by both increasing the carrying costs on vacant land and reducing the long-term costs of building, which reduces the burden on tenants.

Opportunity for creativity

Pittsburgh’s long and successful history of split-value taxation ended during the acrimonious tax-and-assessment battle of 2000-2001. A jump in land values led property owners to believe they were getting hosed by the higher land tax, making the system politically toxic.

Advertise with us

Those who remember that episode are understandably leery of bringing back the split-value system. In particular, there are concerns that land values are easier to manipulate for political purposes, since they’re less tied to the visible, inspectable reality of physical structures.

Against that, land-tax supporters argue that all assessments are imprecise and that land values are actually more reliable and less contestable because they transition slowly and smoothly across neighborhoods. Adjacent properties should rarely have very different land assessments per square foot.

And then there are the winners and losers. A split-value system shifts the tax burden onto not just owners of vacant land but homeowners in the most desirable neighborhoods. Winners include renters, middle-class homeowners and commercial property owners, especially Downtown. This scrambles the usual political categories of class and ideology, leaving the proposal without a clear base of support.

Yet, with overlapping fiscal crises and a major reassessment on the horizon, this is a unique opportunity for Pittsburgh to consider more creative policies than simply adding or raising taxes.