A surgeon who operates on children whose faces have been ravaged by dogs has co-authored a study that states pit bulls “have the highest risk of biting and cause the most damage per bite.”

The research was conducted by medical doctors at Ohio State University College of Medicine and Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center.

No. 2 on the bite list is mixed breed dogs followed by German shepherds.

This study is bad news for people in the dog rescue community — especially lovers of pit bulls and other “power breeds” — who have spent 25 years advocating for people to “judge the deed, not the breed.” I voiced my concerns to the co-author of the study.

Advertise with us

“As a surgeon, my primary responsibility is to the patients,” said Dr. Charles Elmaraghy in a telephone interview. “We see four to 10 children per week” at Nationwide Children’s Hospital in Columbus. They are dog bite victims with “everything from simple lacerations to injuries in which there’s significant tissue loss that needs grafting or other reconstructive surgery.”

He and lead author Dr. Garth Essig are both otolaryngologists, which means they are ear, nose and throat specialists.

Dr. Elmaraghy does reconstructive plastic surgery on the faces of dog bite victims. He’s chief of otolaryngology at Nationwide, which is the pediatric teaching hospital for the OSU College of Medicine. He’s also an associate professor at OSU’s College of Medicine.

“We present the information, and people can do what they want,”  Dr. Elmaraghy said. He suggests the study could be used by parents to make an informed decision about what kind of dog to bring into a house that is inhabited by children.

“It’s not for me to say what breed anyone should own.”

Advertise with us

Every year, 4.7 million people in the United States are bitten by dogs, according to the OSU study, drawing those figures from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

“Twenty percent of those victims require medical care. ... Those who require treatment after dog bites are predominately children ages 5 to 9.”

“There’s an estimated 83 million owned dogs in the United States, and that number continues to climb,” Dr. Essig said in the news release.

“The OSU research highlights a significant public health issue,” said Dr. K. Craig Kent, dean of the Ohio State University College of Medicine

OSU researchers looked at “dog bite papers” across the country dating back as far as 1970 and reviewed 15 years of dog-related facial trauma cases at Nationwide Children’s Hospital and the University of Virginia Health System.

Advertise with us

The study does not report numbers of pit bulls that inflicted  serious bites.

Dr. Essig notes that “mixed breed dogs account for a significant  portion of dog bites,” and it’s often impossible to figure out what breeds are involved in the mixes.

So researchers looked at other factors, and suggest that a high risk of serious bite damage comes from dogs that weigh 66-100 pounds and have “a head shape that is wider than it is long.”

Personally, I wish the doctors would have led with that information rather than profiling biting dogs by breed. And here’s another factoid: The press release says that “in about 60 percent of dog bite cases, the breed was unknown.”

Ironically OSU has a very good College of Veterinary Medicine. Many vets in the Pittsburgh area trained there. I don’t see veterinary input in the study, but the news release has some bite prevention tips from Dr. Meghan Herron, associate professor of veterinary clinical services at OSU’s vet school.

Advertise with us

The oft-repeated tips include keep children away from a dog’s crate and bed because  “most bites to children occur from a family dog when the dog is resting and the child approaches.”

Other tips include always supervise dogs and children, keep children away from dogs that are eating, and teach children to never try to take a toy or food away from a dog.

The study has been published in the International Journal of Pediatric Otorhinolaryngology.

Linda Wilson Fuoco: lfuoco@post-gazette.com.