In the 20 years that veterinarian Brad Gordon has been monitoring circus animals, he’s never seen anything like what happened at the Shrine Circus in Pittsburgh last Sunday.
During intermission, three dromedary camels and three Asian elephants were giving rides to children and adults. I was there on assignment in PPG Paints Arena, watching children ride seven pretty ponies. Dr. Gordon was at the other end of the arena, watching the elephants. When I heard a collective “Oh!’ from the audience, I looked right and saw a camel bucking, repeatedly kicking up its long hind legs.
I saw a child fall to the ground. Atop the camel’s one-humped back, a woman was thrown around like a rag doll. Although the camel continued to buck, the woman never lost her hold on the saddle. Then the camel ran out of view.
There were dozens of children on the floor of the arena; I feared some would be trampled. But the camel was caught and calmed in just 11 seconds, circus officials said.
Dr. Gordon said he saw what I saw. Neither of us saw what startled the camel. Nor did Paul A. Leavy, chairman since 1993 of the Shrine Circus in Pittsburgh. A circus announcer told the audience, “A child threw a shovel at the camel’s feet.” But no one has come forward with video showing that happened.
Dr. Gordon, a veterinarian for 35 years, said, “This doesn’t make sense to me because those camels were experienced show animals. Something had to be really abnormal for the animal to be so spooked.”
Read More
He noted that the animals were “calm and quiet” from Friday through Sunday.
At the five circus performances in Pittsburgh, all of the animals performed “flawlessly” and “willingly,” Dr. Gordon said. He said he saw no whips or bullhooks used on the animals, which included camels, elephants, horses, tigers and a lion. All animals received “stellar” care from trainers and handlers, who seem to genuinely care about them, he said.
Dr. Gordon’s resume includes decades treating horses and other large animals. In 1979, when he was a veterinary student at Ohio State University, he was a student volunteer at the Columbus Zoo, where he worked with celebrity zookeeper Jack Hanna. He now lives in Altoona, Iowa.
For the past 20 years Dr. Gordon has traveled the country, monitoring the care and treatment of circus animals. He says he’s called out four to eight times a year. In most cases people are being proactive, wanting to make sure the animals receive good care, he said.
For the circus in Pittsburgh, Dr. Gordon and Paul Reed, a Westmoreland County humane officer, were court appointed to monitor the care and treatment of circus animals.
That happened after the Shriners filed a lawsuit objecting to the city’s ban on the use of bullhooks, whips and other instruments used in the control of “wild or exotic animals.” That ban was proposed by Humane Action Pittsburgh, a local animal rights group.
By the way, camels are neither wild nor exotic. They’ve been domesticated animals for over 3,000 years. The other camels, three elephants and seven ponies were not stressed by Sunday’s incident, Dr. Gordon said.
“I am an animal advocate. I am cautious and concerned about their care. And they do not have to work very hard.”
In 20 years he said he has seen only minor concerns — a number of small abrasions on animals. An elephant in Nebraska had an abscess caused when a piece of wood chip bedding entered its skin.
Circus operators have been receptive to advice he offers for better care, Dr. Gordon said. He thinks care and training methods have improved over the years.
Last weekend may have been the last hurrah for the Shrine Circus in Pittsburgh. The future depends on the outcome of the court battle, Mr. Leavy said. The circus is the biggest fundraiser for the Syria Shrine. Shriners across the country support pediatric hospitals in 22 cities.
Many animal rights groups — including PETA, Humane Society of the United States and Humane Action Pittsburgh — are opposed to animals performing in circuses. They think it is cruel, unnatural and undignified for the animals.
That’s their opinion, and many people agree with them. I was surprised that no protesters showed up for the Sunday show.
Circus opponents weaken their position, in my opinion, when they insist that all circus animals are whipped, beaten and abused. That’s just not true. Many opponents insist that the mere fact that they perform in the circus is “animal cruelty.”
Opponents have had a lot of impact. Other circuses have shut down after bowing to pressure and removing animals from the lineup.
Of course there are still people who enjoy circuses with animals. About 30,000 people bought tickets to the Pittsburgh shows.
I like to see animals perform in the circus but only if they are treated well and humanely. I thank powerful, well-funded groups like PETA and HSUS for raising the level of scrutiny that results in better care for the animals.
Linda Wilson Fuoco: lfuoco@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3064 or on Facebook.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.