Jackie Armour combs through dozens of adoption applications at her foster-based animal rescue every December.
Amid an annual spike in interest during the holidays, applications for Christmas puppies always pour in.
Without fail each year, more than 20 applicants write that they intend to gift their new pet to someone else, she said. Those applications immediately raise red flags.
The trend puts shelters on alert as they grapple with other challenges during the winter months. And as they try to weed out applicants who seek animals to give away, shelter coordinators say all applications are subject to added scrutiny.
“We want to make sure that people are prepared if they’re adopting a puppy,” said Ms. Armour, president of the Tarentum-based Paws Across Pittsburgh. “It can’t be a surprise.”
Vetting applications
The puppy present problem stems from shelters not knowing whether the person receiving the animal is actually committed to its care, Ms. Armour said, and that’s why the potential owner must be the one applying.
That makes the vetting process around the holidays all the more strenuous. All adults living in the house need to be on board, she said.
Kierah Hanna, a volunteer at Animal Advocates in the West End, said every family member is required to be present during a meet-and-greet as part of the application process. Spoiling the surprise for the kids is a small price to pay when ensuring animals are placed in the right home.
“It’s important that we ensure that this is a good match for the animal,” Ms. Hanna said.

At Animal Protectors in New Kensington, applicants are asked about the purpose and intentions for adoption and are screened on social media, said shelter administrator Danielle Baughman.
“We’re more mindful with our adoptions in the Christmas season,” she said. “We’re really screening the situation, asking a little bit more questions.”
The added hoops come as application numbers increase during the holiday season.
Animal Protectors received 155 applications in December, compared to just 72 the month before, Ms. Baughman said.
But despite shelters’ best efforts, some applications can still slip through the cracks.
Post-holiday pet returns
Even with their own bans on gifting, shelters are bracing for post-holiday owner surrender numbers to soar.
Each year, people return their gifted pets that were acquired elsewhere, Ms. Armour said, or realize they took on too much by inviting a new animal into their home.
But the phenomenon doesn’t happen everywhere. Dan Cody, executive director of the Humane Animal Rescue Pittsburgh, said his return rates after the holidays tend to be low.
Still, Ms. Armour said that each week, she usually gets about 20 owner-surrender requests, which increase to about 25 after the holidays. In the first four months of last year, 10 animals were returned to Animal Protectors.
“It’s a stressful time of year for a lot of people,” Ms. Armour said. “A good chunk of our owner-surrender requests say that they just don’t have time.”
Ms. Armour said the requests tend to pile up starting Jan. 1.
Heading into the new year, some Pittsburgh-area rescue groups host adoption events at the tail end of the holiday season.
Bridge to Home Animal Rescue in Washington, Pa., hosts an event where dogs are taken in as part of their annual New Year’s Eve Save event, according to the nonprofit rescue group. This year, 46 dogs were recovered.
Pet food pantry demand grows
As shelters work through an influx of adoption applications, pet food pantry services are in high demand.
Mr. Cody said HARP’s pantry gave out more than 80,000 pounds of pet food in 2025, up from 72,000 the year before. The initiative aims to help people feed their pets in times of economic hardship.
In the wake of SNAP benefit cuts in November, there was an uptick in applications for the pantry, he said.
“Any time of uncertainty certainly adds to the need for programs like this,” he said.
Ms. Baughman said Animal Protector’s pet food pantry has been running low on supplies this winter. The no-kill shelter offers donated pet food, litter, treats and toys for pet owners in need.
There was an uptick in pantry visits during the holiday season, she said, from 35 in November to 51 in December.
Ms. Baughman said the surplus of demand could be due to more people adopting animals this time of year, as well as a trickle-down effect from managing other expenses.
“Where there was money for pet food, it had to go to human food,” she said. “Therefore increases the need from us.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.