Pennsylvania’s motley crew of underworked but overpaid legislators will be the first to admit they’re not a very evolved bunch. To be evolved requires playing footsies with Charles Darwin, but in a state where the Legislature unanimously declared 2014 “The Year of the Bible” in a nonbinding proclamation, that’s not going to happen.
As an institution, the Pennsylvania Legislature avoided the Sturm und Drang of the fight to force science teachers in Dover, Pa., to read a statement to students declaring “intelligent design” a viable alternative theory to evolution, but they’re making up for lost time in the dash to ban the teaching of critical race theory in the commonwealth’s public schools.
With the exception of U.S. Sen. Rick Santorum, who was sticking his nose into every controversy at the time, the 2004 fight to impose a veneer of religion on science education was considered too fringy and nakedly partisan to draw the state’s Republican caucus into the battle to make intelligent design just another elective.
There would be no such reluctance nearly two decades later now that the nostalgia for a sanitized — and sanctified — version of American history devoid of the complications of race, slavery and systemic injustice is the heart of the Republican brand.
In a way, the GOP’s mania to redeem this country from the sin-soaked reality of its past is weirdly utopian. Treating racism and systemic injustice like some hastily deleted tweet isn’t going to work anymore. Too many Americans have screen shots of what actually happened in this country. The testimonies of those who’ve experienced a version of America that can never be whitewashed is too numerous to discount.
Earlier this month, Republican lawmakers introduced House Bill 1532, a hysterical and unconstitutional attempt to muzzle history and scholarship by prohibiting the teaching of anything that lawmakers believe can be used as a Trojan horse for critical race theory.
Read More
The bill would also prohibit postsecondary institutions from providing platforms to any scholar or speaker “who espouses, advocates or promotes any racist or sexist concept.”
A bomb-throwing apologist for racists like Candace Owens would be welcome, but antiracist academics like Ibram X. Kendi and Robin DeAngelo would be persona non grata under this law.
The state’s GOP caucus considers any theory that suggests that the commonwealth of Pennsylvania has treated whole categories of people unfairly for centuries is, by definition, detrimental to the esteem of (white) students.
HB 1532 is an attempt to persuade a significant part of the population to enter into a conspiracy of ignorance “for the sake of the kids” who would be led astray by an honest — i.e., fuller — accounting of history.
“These kids can’t handle the truth,” the Republicans seem to be saying by insisting that there are parts of American history that aren’t fit for classroom consumption. They don’t want formerly oblivious young people to learn about systemic racism or injustice when there is so much propaganda about American possibilities to absorb and regurgitate.
Of course it is an indictment of our entire education system that most Americans’ first encounter with the century-old Tulsa, Okla., massacre came via the opening scene of HBO’s superhero drama “Watchmen” last year. Most Americans have never heard of the massacres that preceded and followed it across the country during a particularly bloody 40-year span.
If we’re honest, we know that exposing young minds to the realities of American history inevitably dredges up what is least flattering about our national narrative. This, in turn, forces those who deny our brokenness the most to recast the past in a mythic, gauzy light.
Whitewashing the past is how Republican legislators in Pennsylvania prefer to deal with the inconveniences of our brutal history. How can America be the “shining city on the hill” if the streets of that city are slick with blood?
Ironically, those who oppose the removal of Confederate monuments and statues on the grounds they are part of some sacred memory are the same people who oppose critical race theory as “divisive.”
They’re all for the veneration of traitorous generals who initiated the bloodiest war in our history, but they don’t want to have to also explain to young people why statues of those insurrectionists dot the American landscape in the North and the South.
Imagine that Gov. Tom Wolf, who will veto HB 1532 if it ever reaches his desk, was a Republican bent on historical revisionism with his party and not a Democrat.
If Mr. Wolf were to sign that legislation into law, how would teachers in the state explain to their students what happened in Tulsa, Okla., without touching upon the legacy of systemic racism and the forces of hatred and exclusion? How would they explain the destruction of a prosperous Black neighborhood and the massacre of hundreds of ordinary Black people by mobs of white Oklahomans two decades into the 20th century?
How would the teachers explain why no white people were arrested or tried for murder while hundreds of Blacks were arrested and detained for defending themselves?
How would teachers explain the Trail of Tears or Reconstruction or Jim Crow or the civil rights movement or women’s suffrage or the gay liberation movement or anti-war protests without the benefit of a critical lens that takes into account systemic justice?
Lest we forget, this intellectually draconian piece of legislation called HB 1532 is being pushed by the same politicians and the same political party that voted to throw out the ballots of millions of Pennsylvanians during the election dispute last year.
Let that sink in. Here, in Pennsylvania, a political party that can’t bring itself to acknowledge the integrity of the last election or the bitter reality of the Jan. 6 insurrection wants to be the arbiter of what is and isn’t history for teachers across the commonwealth.
If we can’t trust these goobers to give a correct account of events that happened between six and eight months ago, how could we possibly trust them to be honest brokers of our complicated and vexing history?
We learned all the wrong lessons from the single disastrous term of former President Donald Trump. From that miserable, seditious man, we learned that acknowledging one’s mistakes or saying “I’m sorry” was a sign of weakness and an invitation to be branded “a loser.”
Politicians fell in line and aped his denial of responsibility for things that happened on his watch, taking it to even more absurd lengths when they could.
Pols like the deplorable crew we have here in Pennsylvania backed Mr. Trump’s big election lies, resulting in disruptive state recounts and dozens of nuisance lawsuits across the country. The fact that such intellectually mediocre men have anointed themselves education reformers is not a good thing for our democracy.
These men like to gaze nostalgically across time in the general direction of Thomas Jefferson’s Monticello. They imagine they are defending the finest intellects this country has ever produced when they excoriate critical race theory. It was bad enough God was taken out of the schools. Now the liberals want to take their “white gods,” the Founding Fathers, from them, too.
Because they aren’t historically literate or particularly sophisticated, they are alarmed that protests to remove Confederate statues from public spaces will eventually claim the slave-owning founders. When they look toward Monticello, they see a beautiful plantation estate that reflects the beautiful mind that drafted the Declaration of Independence. They don’t see Monticello’s slave quarters or any of this country’s contradictions.
As far as they’re concerned, there is no history in those slave quarters that they or millions of students should be concerned about. Slaves are an unfortunate factoid. The deeper history is embodied in the white man whose noble visage was sculpted in fine alabaster to mark his time on Earth.
Remember when scholars began openly discussing Jefferson’s sexual liaisons with Sally Hemming, his slave, and whether that revelation, if proven true, would “besmirch” his legacy? Scholars have come a long way since those days, but politicians and many in the public keep dawdling because truth in any form except tiny bite-sized portions is terrifying and dispiriting.
An America that refuses to acknowledge its past is a country facing the most haunted of futures bound, gagged and blindfolded. An America without tears and honest reflection is an America without justice.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @Tony_NormanPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.