Pennsylvania’s motley crew of underworked but overpaid legislators will be the first to admit they’re not a very evolved bunch. To be evolved requires playing footsies with Charles Darwin, but in a state where the Legislature unanimously declared 2014 “The Year of the Bible” in a nonbinding proclamation, that’s not going to happen.

As an in­sti­tu­tion, the Penn­syl­va­nia Leg­is­la­ture avoided the Sturm und Drang of the fight to force sci­ence teach­ers in Dover, Pa., to read a state­ment to stu­dents de­clar­ing “in­tel­li­gent de­sign” a vi­a­ble al­ter­na­tive the­ory to evo­lu­tion, but they’re mak­ing up for lost time in the dash to ban the teach­ing of crit­i­cal race the­ory in the com­mon­wealth’s pub­lic schools.

With the ex­cep­tion of U.S. Sen. Rick San­to­rum, who was stick­ing his nose into ev­ery con­tro­versy at the time, the 2004 fight to im­pose a ve­neer of re­li­gion on sci­ence ed­u­ca­tion was con­sid­ered too fringy and na­kedly par­ti­san to draw the state’s Re­pub­li­can cau­cus into the bat­tle to make in­tel­li­gent de­sign just an­other elec­tive.

There would be no such re­luc­tance nearly two de­cades later now that the nos­tal­gia for a san­i­tized — and sanc­ti­fied — ver­sion of Amer­i­can his­tory de­void of the com­pli­ca­tions of race, slav­ery and sys­temic in­justice is the heart of the Re­pub­li­can brand.

Advertise with us

In a way, the GOP’s ma­nia to re­deem this coun­try from the sin-soaked re­al­ity of its past is weirdly uto­pian. Treat­ing rac­ism and sys­temic in­justice like some hast­ily de­leted tweet isn’t go­ing to work any­more. Too many Amer­i­cans have screen shots of what ac­tu­ally hap­pened in this coun­try. The tes­ti­mo­nies of those who’ve ex­pe­ri­enced a ver­sion of Amer­ica that can never be white­washed is too nu­mer­ous to dis­count.

Ear­lier this month, Re­pub­li­can law­mak­ers in­tro­duced House Bill 1532, a hys­ter­i­cal and un­con­sti­tu­tional at­tempt to muz­zle his­tory and schol­ar­ship by pro­hib­it­ing the teach­ing of any­thing that law­mak­ers be­lieve can be used as a Tro­jan horse for crit­i­cal race the­ory.

The bill would also pro­hibit post­sec­ond­ary in­sti­tu­tions from pro­vid­ing plat­forms to any scholar or speaker “who es­pouses, ad­vo­cates or pro­motes any rac­ist or sex­ist con­cept.”

A bomb-throw­ing apol­o­gist for rac­ists like Can­dace Owens would be wel­come, but an­ti­ra­c­ist ac­a­dem­ics like Ibram X. Kendi and Robin DeAn­gelo would be per­sona non grata un­der this law.

The state’s GOP cau­cus con­sid­ers any the­ory that sug­gests that the com­mon­wealth of Penn­syl­va­nia has treated whole cat­e­go­ries of peo­ple un­fairly for cen­tu­ries is, by def­i­ni­tion, det­ri­men­tal to the es­teem of (white) stu­dents.

Advertise with us

HB 1532 is an at­tempt to per­suade a sig­nifi­cant part of the pop­u­la­tion to en­ter into a con­spir­acy of ig­no­rance “for the sake of the kids” who would be led astray by an hon­est — i.e., fuller — ac­count­ing of his­tory.

“These kids can’t han­dle the truth,” the Re­pub­li­cans seem to be say­ing by in­sist­ing that there are parts of Amer­i­can his­tory that aren’t fit for class­room con­sump­tion. They don’t want for­merly obliv­i­ous young peo­ple to learn about sys­temic rac­ism or in­justice when there is so much pro­pa­ganda about Amer­i­can pos­si­bil­i­ties to ab­sorb and re­gur­gi­tate.

Of course it is an in­dict­ment of our en­tire ed­u­ca­tion sys­tem that most Amer­i­cans’ first en­coun­ter with the cen­tury-old Tulsa, Okla., mas­sa­cre came via the open­ing scene of HBO’s su­per­hero drama “Watch­men” last year. Most Amer­i­cans have never heard of the mas­sa­cres that pre­ceded and fol­lowed it across the coun­try dur­ing a par­tic­u­larly bloody 40-year span.

If we’re hon­est, we know that ex­pos­ing young minds to the re­al­i­ties of Amer­i­can his­tory in­ev­i­ta­bly dredges up what is least flat­ter­ing about our na­tional nar­ra­tive. This, in turn, forces those who deny our bro­ken­ness the most to re­cast the past in a mythic, gauzy light.

White­wash­ing the past is how Re­pub­li­can leg­is­la­tors in Penn­syl­va­nia pre­fer to deal with the in­con­ve­niences of our bru­tal his­tory. How can Amer­ica be the “shin­ing city on the hill” if the streets of that city are slick with blood?

Advertise with us

Iron­i­cally, those who op­pose the re­moval of Con­fed­er­ate mon­u­ments and stat­ues on the grounds they are part of some sa­cred mem­ory are the same peo­ple who op­pose crit­i­cal race the­ory as “di­vi­sive.”

They’re all for the ven­er­a­tion of trai­tor­ous gen­er­als who ini­ti­ated the blood­i­est war in our his­tory, but they don’t want to have to also ex­plain to young peo­ple why stat­ues of those in­sur­rec­tion­ists dot the Amer­i­can land­scape in the North and the South.

Imag­ine that Gov. Tom Wolf, who will veto HB 1532 if it ever reaches his desk, was a Re­pub­li­can bent on his­tor­i­cal re­vi­sion­ism with his party and not a Dem­o­crat.

If Mr. Wolf were to sign that leg­is­la­tion into law, how would teach­ers in the state ex­plain to their stu­dents what hap­pened in Tulsa, Okla., with­out touch­ing upon the leg­acy of sys­temic rac­ism and the forces of ha­tred and ex­clu­sion? How would they ex­plain the de­struc­tion of a pros­per­ous Black neigh­bor­hood and the mas­sa­cre of hun­dreds of or­di­nary Black peo­ple by mobs of white Okla­ho­mans two de­cades into the 20th cen­tury?

How would the teach­ers ex­plain why no white peo­ple were ar­rested or tried for mur­der while hun­dreds of Blacks were ar­rested and de­tained for de­fend­ing them­selves?

Advertise with us

How would teach­ers ex­plain the Trail of Tears or Re­con­struc­tion or Jim Crow or the civil rights move­ment or women’s suf­frage or the gay lib­er­a­tion move­ment or anti-war pro­tests with­out the ben­e­fit of a crit­i­cal lens that takes into ac­count sys­temic justice?

Lest we for­get, this in­tel­lec­tu­ally dra­co­nian piece of leg­is­la­tion called HB 1532 is be­ing pushed by the same pol­i­ti­cians and the same po­lit­i­cal party that voted to throw out the bal­lots of mil­lions of Penn­syl­va­nians dur­ing the elec­tion dis­pute last year.

Let that sink in. Here, in Penn­syl­va­nia, a po­lit­i­cal party that can’t bring it­self to ac­knowl­edge the in­teg­rity of the last elec­tion or the bit­ter re­al­ity of the Jan. 6 in­sur­rec­tion wants to be the ar­bi­ter of what is and isn’t his­tory for teach­ers across the com­mon­wealth.

If we can’t trust these goo­bers to give a cor­rect ac­count of events that hap­pened be­tween six and eight months ago, how could we pos­si­bly trust them to be hon­est bro­kers of our com­pli­cated and vex­ing his­tory?

We learned all the wrong les­sons from the sin­gle di­sas­trous term of for­mer Pres­i­dent Don­ald Trump. From that mis­er­a­ble, se­di­tious man, we learned that ac­knowl­edg­ing one’s mis­takes or say­ing “I’m sorry” was a sign of weak­ness and an in­vi­ta­tion to be branded “a loser.”

Advertise with us

Pol­i­ti­cians fell in line and aped his de­nial of re­spon­si­bil­ity for things that hap­pened on his watch, tak­ing it to even more ab­surd lengths when they could.

Pols like the de­plor­able crew we have here in Penn­syl­va­nia backed Mr. Trump’s big elec­tion lies, re­sult­ing in dis­rup­tive state re­counts and doz­ens of nui­sance law­suits across the coun­try. The fact that such in­tel­lec­tu­ally me­di­o­cre men have anointed them­selves ed­u­ca­tion re­form­ers is not a good thing for our de­moc­racy.

These men like to gaze nos­tal­gi­cally across time in the gen­eral di­rec­tion of Tho­mas Jef­fer­son’s Mon­ti­cello. They imag­ine they are de­fend­ing the fin­est in­tel­lects this coun­try has ever pro­duced when they ex­co­ri­ate crit­i­cal race the­ory. It was bad enough God was taken out of the schools. Now the lib­er­als want to take their “white gods,” the Found­ing Fathers, from them, too.

Be­cause they aren’t his­tor­i­cally lit­er­ate or par­tic­u­larly so­phis­ti­cated, they are alarmed that pro­tests to re­move Con­fed­er­ate stat­ues from pub­lic spaces will even­tu­ally claim the slave-own­ing found­ers. When they look to­ward Mon­ti­cello, they see a beau­ti­ful plan­ta­tion es­tate that re­flects the beau­ti­ful mind that drafted the Dec­la­ra­tion of Inde­pen­dence. They don’t see Mon­ti­cello’s slave quar­ters or any of this coun­try’s con­tra­dic­tions.

As far as they’re con­cerned, there is no his­tory in those slave quar­ters that they or mil­lions of stu­dents should be con­cerned about. Slaves are an un­for­tu­nate fac­toid. The deeper his­tory is em­bod­ied in the white man whose no­ble vis­age was sculpted in fine al­a­bas­ter to mark his time on Earth.

Advertise with us

Re­mem­ber when schol­ars be­gan openly dis­cuss­ing Jef­fer­son’s sex­ual li­ai­sons with Sally Hem­ming, his slave, and whether that reve­la­tion, if proven true, would “be­smirch” his leg­acy? Schol­ars have come a long way since those days, but pol­i­ti­cians and many in the pub­lic keep daw­dling be­cause truth in any form ex­cept tiny bite-sized por­tions is ter­ri­fy­ing and dis­pir­it­ing.

An Amer­ica that re­fuses to ac­knowl­edge its past is a coun­try fac­ing the most haunted of fu­tures bound, gagged and blind­folded. An Amer­ica with­out tears and hon­est re­flec­tion is an Amer­ica with­out justice.

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @Tony_NormanPG.