Part of being an empathetic citizen is the capacity to understand if not necessarily agree with the perspective of those who subscribe to a different set of politics or governing ideas.

Sometimes, merely being open minded yields a bounty of mutual understanding and previously unimagined good will. What at first glance looks like moral and intellectual incoherence could be far more sensible upon closer inspection.

Think about all of those conservatives who used to denounce Martin Luther King Jr. as a trouble-making race baiter and rabble rouser when he was alive.

Times change along with opinions, eh? These days, no one quotes MLK more than right-wingers who try to use his March on Washington speech as a cudgel to denounce Black Lives Matter while conveniently forgetting that conservatives consistently lambasted the civil rights movement that MLK helped lead for allegedly being a bastion of ungodly communism.

Advertise with us

Conservatives not only changed their mind about MLK being bad for America, they’ve made attempts to recast him as a mainstream Black Republican in an attempt to make the GOP more appealing to Black folks disenchanted with equivocating Democratic politicians.

It’s easy to see all such pandering as the cynical revisionism that it is, but what if there’s an iota of integrity buried under all the [expletive]? What if Republicans, after years of soul-searching and a judicious study of history, have simply seen the light and now sincerely embrace the legacy of the civil rights movement?

What if the unanimous Republican vote in the U.S. Senate in favor of making Juneteenth a federal holiday is “proof” of the GOP’s willingness to back away from the abyss of bigotry it routinely wallows in for electoral success?

Doesn’t such open-mindedness by a party that has been wrong about race for decades deserve an equal measure of open-mindedness from the rest of us when it comes to framing its greatest narrative folly — the insurrection of Jan. 6 when thousands of pro-Trump radicals, seditionists and insurrectionists overran the U.S. Capitol in an orgy of violence and mayhem? Is the GOP entitled to open-mindedness when it comes to the Big Lie of what happened on Jan. 6?

Let’s give this thought experiment a Sen. Joe Manchin-sized shot of credulity to find out. I will now list what I believe to be some of the main arguments/ideas advanced by those who insist Jan. 6 wasn’t at all what the “lamestream media” said it was.

Advertise with us

Despite what sounds like snickering in the background, I truly am trying to be open-minded about this.

Many of my Republican friends insist that the bulk of the men and women who entered the Capitol were invited in by the Capitol police who allegedly sympathized with their concern that the election had been stolen by the Democrats. While acknowledging that there was some rowdiness and property damage, they cast the blame on members of BLM and antifa who infiltrated the ranks of ordinary patriots to make them look bad.

In recent days, Fox News personality Tucker Carlson has advanced the theory that Jan. 6 was masterminded by Deep State operators and executed by the FBI in a Cointelpro-style propaganda campaign similar to what it did against the civil rights and anti-war movements of the 1960s and ‘70s.

Even though the majority of Republicans now believe that the Capitol was stormed by left-wingers “disguised” as MAGA supporters, the GOP does not want bipartisan hearings on what happened on Jan. 6 because it will make ordinary Republicans look and feel bad about something they had nothing to do with. Any investigation would be counterproductive because it will rehash unfounded rumors of Republican complicity in treason.

Republican elected officials say that despite the looting, smeared feces on the walls and threats to hang Vice President Mike Pence, what happened on Jan. 6 was not an insurrection. The most they will concede is that it was a day in which overly exuberant Trump supporters made an unauthorized entry into the Capitol to express their disappointment with elected political officials who insisted on following the vague language of the U.S. Constitution.

Advertise with us

It turns out that even though the bulk of these “tourists” were probably actually liberals in disguise, many conservatives still don’t think they deserve to be hunted down by the government and prosecuted so harshly in ways that display a bias against patriots whose pro-freedom philosophy is being maligned in the process.

The dozens of off-duty and retired cops arrested across the country for participating in an uprising that injured so many officers protecting the Capitol on Jan. 6 presents an awkward messaging challenge, for sure, but there’s no reason to believe that gouging out eyes or beating uniformed officers with flag poles or nearly crushing them to death in doors invalidates their principled critique of “anti-cop movements” like BLM.

There’s a new rumor going around in QAnon-friendly Republican circles that Officer Brian Sicknick, who was severely beaten by protesters on Jan. 6 and died from a stroke the next day, is still alive.

One fervent Trump supporter who is also an elected official told CNN that he believes it is quite possible that Ashli Babbitt, the Trump supporter who was shot and killed that day by guards protecting Senate and House members may still be alive as well. No theory is being advanced as to why these two are putting their family through hell by pretending to be dead.

Meanwhile, the Deep State and the FBI in league with Black Lives Matter, antifa, Big Tech, Bill Gates and George Soros conspire with Vice President Kamala Harris, who is the actual president of the United States except when the enfeebled Joe Biden is in front of news cameras, to hide the true events of Jan. 6 from the American people.

Advertise with us

No one who reads my column regularly would assume I would take any of these ideas seriously enough to engage them earnestly in the public square. They are, frankly, ridiculous. So how can any of us to be truly open-minded when engaged in dialogue with Republicans about Jan. 6 when so much of what they say they believe is nonsense?

Is our only responsibility to listen politely and without judgment as friends, neighbors and relatives prattle on about the inevitability of Trump being installed as president in August? Is the best way to save our democracy from civil war to look the other way without engaging these ideas?

Is a tolerant view of undemocratic political impulses in Republican circles simply part of the baggage of democracy? Even though more than half of Republicans believe Jan. 6 was no big deal, is it rational to treat people who hold such views like they are rational actors?

The lack of intellectual, moral and spiritual coherence on the conservative side of the political spectrum these days is terrifying, especially given the divided nature of American government. We are one or two election cycles and an associate Supreme Court justice away from folks who hold passionately to these views ascending to power by purely democratic means. Jan. 6 has taught us that American democracy is fragile and that a very large segment of our citizenry is delusional. Being too open-minded means kissing any semblance of rational political discourse in this country goodbye.

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @Tony_NormanPG.