From the first day of his second impeachment trial in the U.S. Senate in as many years, the evidence against Donald J. Trump has been overwhelming.
Without taking anything away from the superb prosecution by the most media-savvy impeachment managers ever, the former president’s guilt is so self-evident, to call it axiomatic would be an understatement.
No one can seriously argue that any other figure in American life or politics could’ve inspired the cult-like frontal assault on the Capitol that Mr. Trump did on Jan. 6. Such chaos is inconceivable without the disgraced ex-president’s specific grievances and complaints as its rationale.
Even so, it is unlikely that truth, logic or an appeal to the integrity of American law will result in Mr. Trump’s conviction, even for committing high crimes and misdemeanors against the United States.
Mr. Trump’s acquittal, which will probably come next week, is baked into the structural makeup of the modern U.S. Senate — partisan, truculent and, thanks to the complicity of those in his party who refuse to hold him accountable for anything, amoral.
Earlier this week, it was reported that Mr. Trump was furious about the inability of his cut-rate legal counsel to present a version of Jan. 6 as compelling and morally coherent as what the Democrats put together on the first day.
Read More
Why Mr. Trump was angry at lawyers Bruce Castor and David Schoen is mystifying; after all, their clowning at least distracted from his own criminally seditious behavior for the few hours they ran their mouths. The incompetence of Mr. Trump’s lawyers had become as much a part of the story as his treason.
While listening to Mr. Castor’s rambling discourse on Eric Holder’s presidential prospects, vinyl records and how “likable” U.S. senators were in the 1970s, I became convinced he was doing his folksiest imitation of Al Pacino’s cantankerous, blind Army officer character in “Scent of a Woman.”
Mr. Pacino may have chewed up the scenery in that exasperating 1992 film, but he still managed to beat Denzel Washington’s brilliant performance in “Malcolm X” for the Oscar that year, so what do I know?
If Mr. Trump’s first impeachment was too much like an art film with subtitles and a granular subtext the public couldn’t follow, the sequel is an explosion-heavy blockbuster full of incriminating social media, cultish idiocy, indelible images, a body count and an easy-to-follow storyline.
Even so, the sequel is doomed to have the same unsatisfactory ending as its 2020 predecessor — an acquittal based not on legal merits, but on politics.
By now, most folks recognize the futility of thinking of impeachment as a strictly legal exercise walled off from partisan politics. American politicians are now incapable of rendering a nonpartisan judgment to what was once the most severe sanction against their tribe imaginable.
The Republican half of the U.S. Senate is already on record with its intention to find its one-term standard-bearer Donald Trump “not guilty” of inciting an uprising against the United States even though it is obvious to everyone, including Republican senators, that he did.
In doing so, they are continuing an ugly tradition of jury nullification that has warped our politics and the cause of justice for centuries.
For those who are having a hard time wrapping their heads around this simple truth, it helps to imagine the situation in terms of archetypal good guys and bad guys.
In this case, let’s stipulate that the Democratic impeachment managers are Eliot Ness and Jimmy Malone. These two Prohibition-era crime fighters are trying their best to get a conviction against Chicago’s top gangster and bootlegger Al Capone.
Now imagine Eliot Ness and Jimmy Malone have hauled Al Capone in front of a jury of his peers — in this case the U.S. Senate. Capone beat a similar rap the previous year, but the “G-Men” are better organized this time and have collected evidence that can’t be ignored as “too hard to understand.”
To add to the compelling nature of the case, it just so happens that Capone’s last caper directly threatened the lives of the entire jury, who were witnesses to their own near demise. Arguing the case before those jurors would normally be a prosecutor’s dream.
Not so fast! It turns out that half the jury consists of known “public enemies” Frank Nitti, Vito Genovese, Joe Masseria, Nucky Johnson, Bugs Moran, Bugsy Siegel and, to add to the absurdity — Bugs Bunny.
Now, Al Capone has certainly had his problems with some of these jurors. He even shares a “Valentine’s Day Massacre” with one of them. He’s had feuds or misunderstandings with all of them. But in the end, they’re all gangster Republicans with a higher loyalty to that tribe than any other.
It won’t matter how compelling Eliot Ness’ evidence is against Al Capone because half the jury is complicit in the crimes the defendant has committed over the years. While the “G-Men” lay out the case against Capone in meticulous, gory detail, half of the jury will be napping, doing crossword puzzles or staring at the floor. They won’t engage in the case with anything approaching moral seriousness because Capone is one of them.
These avowedly pro-Capone jurors will even admit in open court that they’re not interested in hearing about all the killing, gambling, boozing, maiming and mob violence that goes on in Chicago. They’re much more interested in hearing evidence of some obscure violation of the tax law that affects only farmers in Maine. They’ll concede that Capone is “rude,” “uncouth” and a killer, but has he cheated on dairy subsidies in the past five years?
In the end, impeaching Donald Trump as many times as it takes is well worth the effort whether he’s ever convicted by the Senate or not. It is important that a rogue politician who once occupied our nation’s highest office be held accountable. Impeaching Mr. Trump doesn’t mean he won’t be held accountable by civil and criminal law now that he’s a private citizen. Georgia has begun investigating whether he violated state election laws by strong-arming its secretary of state for enough votes to overthrow the election.
Given the clarity of the evidence presented against Mr. Trump during the trial so far, why hasn’t he been arrested on charges that he initiated a violent insurrection against the United States? Why waste time with political theater when criminal law can be applied? Politics, obviously. American law doesn’t exist in a political vacuum. Getting someone, especially a former president who has gamed the system successfully for decades, will take time. He may be a scoundrel, but he’s still shielded by the dignity of the office he occupied for four years.
But as the eventual arrest and conviction of Al Capone proved in the 1930s, no one is ever in a position to thwart the law forever. Mr. Trump may very well avoid conviction in the Senate a second time, but who’s to say that a prosecutor in Georgia or New York won’t finally nail him on tax evasion, election skulduggery or for shooting our democracy in the middle of Fifth Avenue just to watch it die?
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @Tony_NormanPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.