Collecting data while sticking a needle in hundreds of arms a day really shouldn’t be a big deal, but as usual, anything pertaining to race in Pennsylvania is a big deal.
From Philly to Pittsburgh, from Erie to York, from Harrisburg to the rural northeast, vaccine providers have done a lousy job of recording the race of those being vaccinated, despite a mandate from the state to collect that info for the sake of public health.
Why is that? One would think it would be the kind of data that would be relatively easy to collect, especially when other personal and medical information is already forthcoming.
At some point before or after the COVID-19 injection has been administered, there can be a very routine chat about the racial identity of the person who has come in to be vaccinated. Collecting this data would put the vaccine provider in compliance with the state’s 2-month-old mandate. It’s information that can be acquired in seconds.
Even the least sophisticated people on both sides of the needle know that racial data exchanged during that conversation won’t ease the pain or possible lingering side effects of the shot. Vaccinations aren’t assigned according to “racial type” or some other essentialist nonsense.
The data is needed to help public health experts and officials know where to shift resources, if necessary, to ensure that people historically discriminated against are able to get the vaccine in sufficient quantities.
Read More
In most cases, it won’t even require much of a conversation, though it wouldn’t be smart to assume someone’s race is obvious just from observing the color of their skin. There are enough light-skinned and dark-skinned variations of a theme to make proceeding with caution advisable, especially in America.
In Sunday’s PG, my colleagues Ashley Murray and Joel Jacobs reported that of the approximately 1 million people who have received vaccinations in Pennsylvania, the racial background of 36% — roughly 300,000 people — is unknown because basic, required data hasn’t been collected despite periodic reminders from the state to include it.
If fairness and equity in the allocation of vaccines is the goal, it is not enough to know the racial background of only 64% of those who were vaccinated, especially when that number doesn’t include those who received a vaccination in Philadelphia County, which has the state’s largest minority population and is its own vaccine jurisdiction.
According to the limited data we do have, Black people, Hispanics, Asians and other minorities trail white folks vaccinated in Pennsylvania dramatically. It isn’t even remotely anywhere near percentage of population for each group.
Of the COVID-19 vaccinations administered so far, 59.2% have been to white people. According to information on hand, Blacks have received 1.8% of the shots, Asians 0.2% and multiple/other 2.8%.
This can’t be explained away by so-called vaccine hesitancy on the part of Blacks and other minorities. Much of this, sadly, is another example of how the pandemic has exposed the criminal inadequacy of health care systems still mired in decades of systemic racism. There is a lot of institutional tolerance for woefully bad planning and execution of medical services when it comes to minority populations.
The lack of adequate medical infrastructure or resources in most non-white communities across this state and the country is predictive of how poorly those communities are faring during this pandemic. It’s particularly obvious in a state like Pennsylvania that boasts several world-class medical systems on both ends of the state.
This is to be expected given historic patterns of systemic racial discrimination in the health care system. Old habits are hard to shake, even during a pandemic.
Pittsburgh-based UPMC has vaccinated 70,000 people across the state so far, but like other health care systems, it has failed to collect the requested racial data even though it did manage to capture the names, genders, ZIP codes, birthdates and, doubtlessly, other precious data of everyone it has vaccinated.
According to the PG’s reporting, UPMC claims it was too busy “reducing barriers” and “maximizing speed” administering the vaccine to bother checking boxes dealing with ethnicity and race. It also claims that it wasn’t even aware of the mandate to collect and report racial data.
It didn’t take long for the the state’s largest health care provider to be embarrassed by such a transparently lame excuse. It quickly reversed itself and promised to collect the data going forward and to retroactively report racial info on those it has already vaccinated. Left unexplained is why UPMC failed to tabulate and forward this vital data in the first place.
But if an enormous health care system like UPMC is delinquent in reporting data that is so vital to the identification of those communities on the short end of the vaccination effort, it might partially explain why Pennsylvania has one of the highest percentages of missing racial data according to the Kaiser Family Foundation.
One doesn’t have to imagine a conspiracy on the part of health care systems and providers during this pandemic to explain racial disparities and lack of attention to details that would eliminate so much suffering and death.
Some of the most unimaginative people in the world rise to positions of power in health care systems. They become locked into accepted ways of doing things because that’s where the money is. Their job is to make a profit and not to exhibit a compassionate imagination unless it makes money. Their preference is always for the status quo and its institutional reputation, which can be an even more insidious way of doing business than blatant racism.
And let’s face it, reports that show a disproportionate number of white people getting vaccinated, even in minority-majority communities is not only unjust, it is embarrassing.
It is also evidence that whole communities don’t have access to the vaccine due to issues of internet access, mobility and unwarranted suspicions about the vaccine itself. The absence of a system of administering vaccines in trusted spaces in every community is scandalous.
A lot of people I know need very little encouragement to distrust what they call the “medical industrial complex.” Past scandals and rumors easily conflate because folks are reluctant to confront their mortality if they already feel constantly under siege.
That’s no excuse, of course. Everyone who is currently eligible for the vaccines, especially in historically discriminated communities, should be taking advantage of every opportunity to do so. The alternative could be death — and most likely a very lonely one at that.
There’s a scandal every day it seems regarding the fair and equitable distribution of the COVID-19 vaccine. These days we hear 20 million doses out of 59 million that can’t be accounted for. How much of that is currently making its way to burgeoning black markets?
In Philly, a startup company run by a 22-year-old scammer who convinced authorities that his group of untrained volunteers could better vaccinate underserved residents better and faster than any team fielded by the city’s hospitals, medical schools or Black physician associations, finally imploded under the weight of COVID-related scandals.
There’s so much corruption and day-to-day grifting going on in the commonwealth, the last thing we should do is encourage more cynicism about vaccinations by failing to do something as easy as tracking the ethnicity of the vaccinated. Meanwhile, we should consider replacing the Hippocratic oath — “Do no harm” — with one with a little more relevance: “Do the right thing.”
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @Tony_NormanPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.