Col­lect­ing data while stick­ing a nee­dle in hun­dreds of arms a day re­ally shouldn’t be a big deal, but as usual, any­thing per­tain­ing to race in Penn­syl­va­nia is a big deal.

From Philly to Pitts­burgh, from Erie to York, from Har­ris­burg to the ru­ral north­east, vac­cine pro­vid­ers have done a lousy job of re­cord­ing the race of those be­ing vac­ci­nated, de­spite a man­date from the state to col­lect that info for the sake of pub­lic health.

Why is that? One would think it would be the kind of data that would be rel­a­tively easy to col­lect, es­pe­cially when other per­sonal and med­i­cal in­for­ma­tion is al­ready forth­com­ing.

At some point be­fore or af­ter the COVID-19 in­jec­tion has been ad­min­is­tered, there can be a very rou­tine chat about the ra­cial iden­tity of the per­son who has come in to be vac­ci­nated. Col­lect­ing this data would put the vac­cine pro­vider in com­pli­ance with the state’s 2-month-old man­date. It’s in­for­ma­tion that can be ac­quired in sec­onds.

Advertise with us

Even the least so­phis­ti­cated peo­ple on both sides of the nee­dle know that ra­cial data ex­changed dur­ing that con­ver­sa­tion won’t ease the pain or pos­si­ble lin­ger­ing side ef­fects of the shot. Vac­ci­na­tions aren’t as­signed ac­cord­ing to “ra­cial type” or some other es­sen­tial­ist non­sense.

The data is needed to help pub­lic health ex­perts and of­fi­cials know where to shift re­sources, if nec­es­sary, to en­sure that peo­ple his­tor­i­cally dis­crim­i­nated against are able to get the vac­cine in suf­fi­cient quan­ti­ties.

In most cases, it won’t even re­quire much of a con­ver­sa­tion, though it wouldn’t be smart to as­sume some­one’s race is ob­vi­ous just from ob­serv­ing the color of their skin. There are enough light-skinned and dark-skinned vari­a­tions of a theme to make pro­ceed­ing with cau­tion ad­vis­able, es­pe­cially in Amer­ica.

In Sun­day’s PG, my col­leagues Ash­ley Mur­ray and Joel Ja­cobs re­ported that of the ap­prox­i­mately 1 mil­lion peo­ple who have re­ceived vac­ci­na­tions in Penn­syl­va­nia, the ra­cial back­ground of 36% — roughly 300,000 peo­ple — is un­known be­cause ba­sic, re­quired data hasn’t been col­lected de­spite pe­ri­odic re­mind­ers from the state to in­clude it.

If fair­ness and eq­uity in the al­lo­ca­tion of vac­cines is the goal, it is not enough to know the ra­cial back­ground of only 64% of those who were vac­ci­nated, es­pe­cially when that num­ber doesn’t in­clude those who re­ceived a vac­ci­na­tion in Phil­a­del­phia County, which has the state’s larg­est mi­nor­ity pop­u­la­tion and is its own vac­cine ju­ris­dic­tion.

Advertise with us

Ac­cord­ing to the lim­ited data we do have, Black peo­ple, His­pan­ics, Asians and other mi­nor­i­ties trail white folks vac­ci­nated in Penn­syl­va­nia dra­mat­i­cally. It isn’t even re­motely any­where near per­cent­age of pop­u­la­tion for each group.

Of the COVID-19 vac­ci­na­tions ad­min­is­tered so far, 59.2% have been to white peo­ple. Ac­cord­ing to in­for­ma­tion on hand, Blacks have re­ceived 1.8% of the shots, Asians 0.2% and mul­ti­ple/​other 2.8%.

This can’t be ex­plained away by so-called vac­cine hes­i­tancy on the part of Blacks and other mi­nor­i­ties. Much of this, sadly, is an­other ex­am­ple of how the pan­demic has ex­posed the crim­i­nal in­ad­e­quacy of health care sys­tems still mired in de­cades of sys­temic rac­ism. There is a lot of in­sti­tu­tional tol­er­ance for woe­fully bad plan­ning and ex­e­cu­tion of med­i­cal ser­vices when it comes to mi­nor­ity pop­u­la­tions.

The lack of ade­quate med­i­cal in­fra­struc­ture or re­sources in most non-white com­mu­ni­ties across this state and the coun­try is pre­dic­tive of how poorly those com­mu­ni­ties are far­ing dur­ing this pan­demic. It’s par­tic­u­larly ob­vi­ous in a state like Penn­syl­va­nia that boasts sev­eral world-class med­i­cal sys­tems on both ends of the state.

This is to be ex­pected given his­toric pat­terns of sys­temic ra­cial dis­crim­i­na­tion in the health care sys­tem. Old hab­its are hard to shake, even dur­ing a pan­demic.

Advertise with us

Pitts­burgh-based UPMC has vac­ci­nated 70,000 peo­ple across the state so far, but like other health care sys­tems, it has failed to col­lect the re­quested ra­cial data even though it did man­age to cap­ture the names, gen­ders, ZIP codes, birth­dates and, doubt­lessly, other pre­cious data of ev­ery­one it has vac­ci­nated.

Ac­cord­ing to the PG’s re­port­ing, UPMC claims it was too busy “re­duc­ing bar­ri­ers” and “max­i­miz­ing speed” ad­min­is­ter­ing the vac­cine to bother check­ing boxes deal­ing with eth­nic­ity and race. It also claims that it wasn’t even aware of the man­date to col­lect and re­port ra­cial data.

It didn’t take long for the the state’s larg­est health care pro­vider to be em­bar­rassed by such a trans­par­ently lame ex­cuse. It quickly re­versed it­self and prom­ised to col­lect the data go­ing for­ward and to ret­ro­ac­tively re­port ra­cial info on those it has al­ready vac­ci­nated. Left un­ex­plained is why UPMC failed to tab­u­late and for­ward this vi­tal data in the first place.

But if an enor­mous health care sys­tem like UPMC is de­lin­quent in re­port­ing data that is so vi­tal to the iden­ti­fi­ca­tion of those com­mu­ni­ties on the short end of the vac­ci­na­tion ef­fort, it might par­tially ex­plain why Penn­syl­va­nia has one of the high­est per­cent­ages of miss­ing ra­cial data ac­cord­ing to the Kaiser Fam­ily Foun­da­tion.

One doesn’t have to imag­ine a con­spir­acy on the part of health care sys­tems and pro­vid­ers dur­ing this pan­demic to ex­plain ra­cial dis­par­i­ties and lack of at­ten­tion to de­tails that would elim­i­nate so much suf­fer­ing and death.

Advertise with us

Some of the most un­imag­i­na­tive peo­ple in the world rise to po­si­tions of power in health care sys­tems. They be­come locked into ac­cepted ways of do­ing things be­cause that’s where the money is. Their job is to make a profit and not to ex­hibit a com­pas­sion­ate imag­i­na­tion un­less it makes money. Their pref­er­ence is al­ways for the sta­tus quo and its in­sti­tu­tional rep­u­ta­tion, which can be an even more in­sid­i­ous way of do­ing busi­ness than bla­tant rac­ism.

And let’s face it, re­ports that show a dis­pro­por­tion­ate num­ber of white peo­ple get­ting vac­ci­nated, even in mi­nor­ity-ma­jor­ity com­mu­ni­ties is not only un­just, it is em­bar­rass­ing.

It is also ev­i­dence that whole com­mu­ni­ties don’t have ac­cess to the vac­cine due to is­sues of in­ter­net ac­cess, mo­bil­ity and un­war­ranted sus­pi­cions about the vac­cine it­self. The ab­sence of a sys­tem of ad­min­is­ter­ing vac­cines in trusted spaces in ev­ery com­mu­nity is scan­dal­ous.

A lot of peo­ple I know need very lit­tle en­cour­age­ment to dis­trust what they call the “med­i­cal in­dus­trial com­plex.” Past scan­dals and ru­mors eas­ily con­flate be­cause folks are re­luc­tant to con­front their mor­tal­ity if they al­ready feel con­stantly un­der siege.

That’s no ex­cuse, of course. Ev­ery­one who is cur­rently el­i­gi­ble for the vac­cines, es­pe­cially in his­tor­i­cally dis­crim­i­nated com­mu­ni­ties, should be tak­ing ad­van­tage of ev­ery op­por­tu­nity to do so. The al­ter­na­tive could be death — and most likely a very lonely one at that.

Advertise with us

There’s a scan­dal ev­ery day it seems re­gard­ing the fair and eq­ui­ta­ble dis­tri­bu­tion of the COVID-19 vac­cine. These days we hear 20 mil­lion doses out of 59 mil­lion that can’t be ac­counted for. How much of that is cur­rently mak­ing its way to bur­geon­ing black mar­kets?

In Philly, a startup com­pany run by a 22-year-old scam­mer who convinced au­thor­i­ties that his group of un­trained vol­un­teers could bet­ter vac­ci­nate un­der­served res­i­dents bet­ter and faster than any team fielded by the city’s hos­pi­tals, med­i­cal schools or Black phy­si­cian as­so­ci­a­tions, fi­nally im­ploded un­der the weight of COVID-re­lated scan­dals.

There’s so much cor­rup­tion and day-to-day grift­ing go­ing on in the com­mon­wealth, the last thing we should do is en­cour­age more cyn­i­cism about vac­ci­na­tions by fail­ing to do some­thing as easy as track­ing the eth­nic­ity of the vac­ci­nated. Mean­while, we should con­sider re­plac­ing the Hip­po­cratic oath — “Do no harm” — with one with a lit­tle more rel­e­vance: “Do the right thing.”

Tony Nor­man: tnor­man@post-ga­zette.com or 412-263-1631. Twit­ter @Tony_Nor­manPG.