Two years ago this week, an atrocity took place in Pittsburgh. As a result, Oct. 27 would never again have the luxury of being just another unremarkable day with turning leaves and a slight nip in the air.
Two years ago, President Donald Trump and first lady Melania Trump came to Pittsburgh, ostensibly to show solidarity with a city still reeling from the single deadliest attack on Jews on American soil.
The first couple met with some of those wounded in the attack, but Mr. Trump didn’t make a speech or say anything particularly memorable. Everyone knows that empathy really isn’t his thing and preferred that he not try to fake it at their expense. Empathy, especially at a presidential level, requires self-awareness and vulnerability — two qualities Mr. Trump regards as incompatible with the strongman image he wants to maintain at all costs.
Making speeches in the wake of an anti-Semitic massacre also requires clean hands when it comes to neo-Nazis and their ilk — something Mr. Trump does not have. Consequently, Mr. Trump’s visit to Squirrel Hill during those dark days when the wound to the city’s soul was still fresh was not the respectful photo op he hoped would dominate the news cycle. Protesters were kept blocks away, so it is possible that he made it back to Air Force One without hearing the chants of disapproval or seeing the signs that indicted him as an enabler of the hatred that was released at the Tree of Life synagogue that previous weekend.
Still, all the photo ops in the world wouldn’t have been enough to obscure the fact that Mr. Trump has proved himself worthy of being the avatar for America’s angriest men — many of whom celebrated the massacre in swastika-draped man-caves on social media. Two years later the adoration of Donald Trump by the absolutely worst Americans has only grown. Unless the equivalent of a gun is pressed to the back of his head, Mr. Trump continues to refuse to denounce white supremacy unambiguously. He’ll do so only if he can engage in false equivalencies about antifa and Black Lives Matters.
There’s a reason why Mr. Trump is a hero to militias, secessionists, white supremacists, gun fetishists, anxious suburbanites and those in the rural exurbs who feel emasculated by modernity and “wokeness.” There’s a reason so many racists feel more emboldened now than they did before the election that delivered a man to the White House who wants to enshrine laws that give special protections to Confederate statues and symbols. If Mr. Trump couldn’t find anything uplifting to say to a nation in mourning during his visit to Pittsburgh in 2018, perhaps he’ll prove himself to be equally tongue-tied after the next massacre when it inevitably comes.
Read More
FBI Director Christopher Wray identifies domestic terrorism propagated by heavily armed right-wing militias and white supremacists who occupy Mr. Trump’s base as the biggest threats to American civil order today. They’re even more dangerous than Islamic extremists. Hardly a month goes by in which some conspiracy isn’t disrupted and some lone wolf killer stopped in the early stages of planning yet another massacre.
The days that have come and gone in two years have dulled the pain somewhat, but the sheer magnitude of the event remains. The horror of that day has been eclipsed by other horrible days, of course. We are in the grip of a pandemic that has claimed more than 220,000 American lives — a burgeoning holocaust our current president denies by holding packed rallies that spread the virus in those states he’s most desperate to win.
Meanwhile, Pittsburgh has had two years to grapple with the loss of 11 men and women and the grievous injury to six others who gathered for morning Shabbat at the Tree of Life on Oct. 27, 2018, only to be confronted by the devil himself.
I was honored to be asked to contribute an essay to a stunning collection of writing about that day. “Bound in the Bond of Life: Pittsburgh Writers Reflect on the Tree of Life Tragedy,” edited by Beth Kissileff and Eric Lidji, is a kaleidoscopic journey through first-person takes on an unspeakable act that demanded we produce words to make sense of it.
Besides Ms. Kissileff and Mr. Lidji, who both contribute essays, there are pieces by members of the Post-Gazette’s Pulitzer Prize-winning team on how they soldiered on through shock covering a tragedy in the heart of our community. My colleague Andrew Goldstein gives a tick-tock of what it was like to cover that event as a young reporter who grew up in Squirrel Hill. The horror was personal for him even as he struggled to keep it as professional as he possibly could.
The PG’s religion editor, Peter Smith, former colleague Ann Belser and former executive editor David Shribman also weighed in with important additions to the narrative destined to get richer, but sadder, in the years to come.
There is a pleasant range of pieces from the idiosyncratic to those that are cautious in tone to those that are blazing feats of empathetic derring-do. Some, like Toby Tabachnick’s “The Last Day I Felt Safe as an American Jew” scream out for immediate engagement.
Acclaimed writers Barbara S. Burstin and Jane Bernstein reflect on their experiences with gorgeously rendered essays that plumb their inner thoughts and personal tragedies in contrast to the darkness and tragedy generated on that overcast Saturday morning. Ms. Kissileff’s “Honey From the Carcass” is a remarkable piece about the renewal of faith.
Everyone has different ways of processing and analyzing grief, but the variety and level of insight in the majority of these essays is superb by any standard. There are far too many remarkable writers and essays in this collection for me to list individually here, but reviews by folks who don’t have an essay in the book are bearing out my perception that “Bound in the Bond of Life” is truly something necessary in these dark times — an honest accounting of the struggle between hope and despair in a world awash in hate.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter @Tony_NormanPG.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.