Moment of silence marks two years after Tree of Life shooting

Amy Mallinger picked a brilliant pink rose from the garden of her late grandmother’s Squirrel Hill home on Tuesday and began the short walk with several other family members to nearby Tree of Life / Or L’Simcha synagogue.

There, she placed the rose atop a chain-link fence in front of the synagogue entrance, where memorial Stars of David bore the names of her grandmother, Rose Mallinger, and the other 10 worshippers who were murdered two years ago on this date in the deadliest anti-Semitic attack in U.S. history.

Family members embraced, stood in quiet contemplation, then began to talk with some of the others who arrived at the corner of Shady and Wilkins avenues to pay tribute to the 11.

“That day is still like it was yesterday,” Amy Mallinger said. “You remember exactly what you were doing at every point of the day.” It was comforting, she said, to share the remembrance with family, and she’s grateful that her aunt, Andrea Wedner, who was injured in the attack, could be with them at Tuesday’s informal gathering.

Advertise with us

Throughout the day, people came to the Tree of Life site to pay respects to those remembered as martyrs.

Excerpts from Tree of Life Virtual Community Commemorative Gathering

Tree of Life Rabbi Jeffrey Myers and Mayor Bill Peduto joined a small cluster of people observing a moment of silence at 9:54 a.m., the time of the first call to police reporting the attack on Oct. 27, 2018.

A gunman killed 11 worshippers who had gathered for Shabbat services that Saturday morning. The attack claimed lives of members of each of the three congregations that met at the building: Dor Hadash, New Light and Tree of Life.

“It is the single worst act of anti-Semitism in American history,” Mr. Peduto told reporters after the moment of silence. “There's also another story to it, which is how an entire city, the region, the country and the world pulled around the Jewish community at a time of great need. ... That speaks volumes about who we are as Pittsburghers” and about how anyone can “present light in a time of darkness.”

_____________

Advertise with us

READ MORE: UNBROKEN | A gunman shattered a sacred space, but not a community's spirit

_____________

No official events were held at the site of the synagogue, which is still closed to the public, but many people have been arriving individually to pay respects. Some left flowers. Others laid down small memorial stones, a traditional Jewish practice at gravesites. One couple stood quietly, arm in arm, reciting a traditional Jewish prayer from text they were reading on their phone.

Yet another visitor left an empty bottle of prescription medicine, whose significance became apparent only upon a closer look at the label, with the name of the prescribing physician: Dr. Jerry Rabinowitz, a Dor Hadash member killed in the attack. The traditional Jewish benediction for the deceased, “May his memory be a blessing,” was written on it.

Meanwhile the workday traffic passed by on Shady and Wilkins avenues. Conversations and prayers were sometimes competing with loud truck engines.

Advertise with us

“It’s like any other morning, and that’s what it was that day, too,” said Barb Feige, executive director of Tree Of Life. The worshippers would “be here every week, every Saturday.”

Ms. Feige noted that with social distancing, it is more of a challenge to offer comfort. “There is a need for hugs,” she said.

“Certainly we think about the 11 who were murdered, but we also think of the love and support that happened afterward,” she added. “And I hope that this day comes to mean that. That we never forget the 11, but the response is what we remember, the response is what we commit to.”

Amy Mallinger said the walk brought back memories of the times when she was younger and would walk with her grandmother to Shabbat services, returning to play in her yard while her grandmother was cooking in the kitchen.

Several people gave the family rose bushes in honor of Rose Mallinger after her death, and the family, who still reside in her duplex home, planted them in the garden.

Advertise with us

Alan Mallinger, Rose’s son, said people continue to send messages of support, including Tuesday for the two-year commemoration. “It’s very comforting,” he said, wearing a cap with the image of a rose.

His wife, Lauren, said she appreciated the social service projects accompanying the two-year mark. “We attended the food giveaway in Wilkinsburg with different denominations,” she said. “This is the way it should be under normal circumstances. It’s a shame that it took something like this to get people motivated. But it’s the phoenix. We all have to rise.”

High school girls from the Yeshiva Schools of Pittsburgh walked to the site to recite mincha, or afternoon prayers. They stood on the sidewalk at Shady and Wilkins, opened their prayer books and quietly prayed. “This was their initiative,” said Batsheva Deren, principal of the girls’ school.

It’s a “day of tears,” said Stephen Cohen, New Light co-president. “We lost 11 innocent, beautiful lives for the stupidest reason, driven by a right-wing media that does nothing but create turmoil and disparagement.” He cited “the canard, the lies” of the alleged gunman’s online claims that Jews were bringing in an invasion because of their support for refugees.

_____________

Advertise with us

READ MORE: Remembering the Tree of Life victims

_____________

A sculpture consisting of a set of 11 glass flowers, which had been placed at the scene soon after the shootings in honor of each of the victims, was returned to the site just days ago in time for the commemoration. The sculpture had been repaired and reinforced after incurring some wear and tear.

Tree of Life board member Andrew Exler said that as early as 6 a.m., he saw one man on the sidewalk outside the synagogue, sitting in quiet contemplation.

He said people were commemorating the day both with in-person visits to the synagogue but also through texts and social media.

Advertise with us

“People are just generally understanding how important it is to be present,” he said.

Across the street from the synagogue, The 10.27 Healing Partnership has a tent set up in which people can speak with a counselor. There also is the opportunity to greet gentle “canine advocates” from the Center for Victims for an emotional lift.

Commemorative events — which began with social service projects this past weekend — also included Torah studies and a memorial service, held online due to the pandemic.

Participants in the memorial service appeared in short segments, videotaped in their homes and other settings. Family members of the deceased lit candles in their memory and spoke of attributes that characterized them, citing traits such as humor, compassion, faithfulness and patriotism.

Survivors of the attack recited prayers and a quotation from author and Holocaust survivor Elie Wiesel. Representatives of each congregation spoke of ways they are carrying on the legacy of those they lost in various ways, such as getting more involved in their own congregations and working for social justice causes such as supporting gun reform and care for immigrants.

Advertise with us

Contemporary Jewish singer Elana Arian opened with a guitar-accompanied prayer in Hebrew and English. Classical cellist Yo-Yo Ma recalled the much-cited words of his friend, the late Fred “Mister” Rogers — whose real-life neighborhood was Squirrel Hill — always to “look for the helpers” in a crisis. “Today, I'd like to honor both the people whose lives were lost, but also the ones who have been helping,” Mr. Ma said before playing a solemn piece, “Prayer,” by Jewish composer Ernest Bloch.

Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.