Oh, Canada! What does it say about our level of patriotism when many of us feel infinitely more betrayed by revelations that Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau gallivanted in public wearing blackface in his youth than reports that President Donald Trump may have made an inappropriate promise to a foreign leader that undermined American interests?
We’re genuinely shocked and surprised by Mr. Trudeau’s choice of racist “othering” on at least three different occasions in high school and at university. Canadians have a well-earned reputation as a good and racially tolerant people. Mr. Trudeau has always come across as among the most decent of world leaders. We think of him as the best of an unfailingly polite nation of sincere white people with minimal hangups about black people.
Were we wrong? Were we simply naive about the level of darkness that lurks in every Canadian’s heart after they’ve thrown back a few Molsons? Contrast this disappointment with Mr. Trudeau’s minstrelsy with news that Mr. Trump may be anything from a “useful idiot” who passively serves a foreign power to an active asset blackmailed into betraying his country to further his own economic ambitions.
Instead of feeling politically fatal, Mr. Trump’s latest scandal feels like just another news story one tweet away from falling from the news cycle entirely. Breaking news that the sitting president of the United States was the subject of an intelligence officer’s whistleblowing complaint? Meh, just another Wednesday in America.
Meanwhile, news that Mr. Trudeau put on a wig, darkened his skin and sang Harry Belafonte’s classic “Banana Boat Song (Day O)” is a much more compelling sign of the apocalypse than accusations of Mr. Trump’s possible treason.
Why is this the case? Because we all remember those classic photos of Mr. Trudeau and President Barack Obama having their “bromance” over beers and exchanges of mutual admiration that two men confident of their handsomeness are capable of expressing during good times. Was that all phony? Does Mr. Trudeau secretly harbor contempt for people of Mr. Obama’s racial background?
Read More
The blackface scandal in Canada is probably much more consequential to Canadians and Americans than “Trump the traitor” because of the tyranny of high expectations. We simply expect more of the Canadian prime minister than we do of the American president, a man who exudes vulgarity and opportunism at every level.
We expect the prime minister, even in reckless youth, to be good. We assume he wouldn’t have needed it explained to him why blackface was wrong. Putting on brownface for an Arabian Nights themed party is unacceptable on every level given the tradition of minstrel shows in both countries over the centuries.
Even though it likely wasn’t funny, his fellow Canadians probably applauded politely because that’s what Canadians do whether they’re appalled or not.
“I shouldn’t have done it,” Mr. Trudeau said exhibiting a show of contrition no one south of Ontario could possibly imagine our president doing. “I should’ve known better, but I didn’t. And I’m really sorry.”
Mr. Trudeau is in the midst of a tough re-election bid with conservative Andrew Scheer that may result in his ouster, but there’s little doubt about the sincerity of his apology.
He hasn’t tried to cover anything up or to excuse it simply as a youthful indiscretion. He conceded that wearing blackface was racist whether he understood the historical implications or not at the time. He was not an innocent bystander to his own racism.
As sad as Mr. Trudeau’s current predicament is, there’s something refreshing about the dignity an embattled world leader can muster even when being haunted and humiliated by an act caught on camera two decades earlier.
On Thursday, yet a third video has surfaced showing Mr. Trudeau in blackface, this time in more traditionally burlesque Sambo garb and wearing what looks like white gloves and an Afro wig. It’s that raw minstrelsy that makes no pretense of being merely concerned with fun.
The image is blurry, but Mr. Trudeau’s allies in the liberal party have already conceded that it is, indeed, their guy in an undated “performance” as a black entertainer. There is no audible sound or music, but chances are he wasn’t warbling and channeling Alanis Morrisette at the time.
I wish someone would explain to me the attraction of “dressing up black” that seems to compel so many otherwise ethical white bros into acts of racial insensitivity in their college years. Why do they post the evidence in yearbooks and online where it is easily discoverable? Do they simply not understand the concept of posterity?
Meanwhile, here in America, a high-placed whistleblower reported to his superiors that our president had an inappropriate exchange with a foreign leader that may compromise the safety and security of the United States.
Mr. Trump, the subject of that complaint, is already crying “fake news” while claiming that it can’t be true because he “always does the right thing.” This has only increased suspicions that he’s probably guilty given his submissive body language vis-a-vis Vladimir Putin during the Helsinki conference. Even so, there will likely be no remedy outside the election booth in 2020.
Wouldn’t it be great to have a presidential scandal that wasn’t rooted in psychopathy, narcissism, corruption and rampant self-dealing? Wouldn’t it be great to have a leader who could apologize for things he did 20 years ago and not worry about what he or she does in 20-minute intervals every day?
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.