“Yesterday,” a British rom-com starring Himesh Patel as a British street musician who remembers The Beatles in a world that has inexplicably forgotten them, opened last week to decent reviews and enthusiastic audience response.

I saw it at an early screening and was thoroughly charmed. As a Boomer, I’m just as susceptible to schmaltz that does homage to the icons of that generation as anyone else. As a work of pop ephemera, “Yesterday” has everything going for it, including relatable characters and songs we’ve known for half a century.

The premise is universal enough to have been daydreamed by a lot of writers already. Imagine you’re the only musician in the world with any memory of The Beatles’ culturally priceless catalogue.

The question isn’t whether an obscure British working-class musician would claim its glories for himself — but how he would rationalize such a monstrous theft of musical artistry. To quote John Lennon from another context: “How do you sleep?”

Advertise with us

In the film, Jack Malik tosses the ethical questions of authorship aside in a rush to recall (and record) as many Beatles songs as possible before he forgets them. There’s an inspired scene where he plays a sad and plaintive “Let It Be” to his parents on a living room piano, but they’re barely attentive despite the obvious loveliness of the song.

Jack’s parents simply aren’t attuned to pop music. They’re immigrants from South Asia who are bourgeois in a very British way, so they’re not remotely hip. I wish the film had more scenes like this because it would’ve identified that world as one that had somehow resisted seduction by The Beatles while also raising the stakes against Jack’s eventual success.

Instead, “Yesterday” traces Jack’s inevitable conquest of the pop music world with singles from every Beatles’ era culminating in the debut of his first album marketed by cynical Svengalis. Even pop star Ed Sheeran puts in an appearance as himself. He advises Jack to change the lyrics of “Hey, Jude” to “Hey, Dude” to be more contemporary.

After struggling with his conscience and the loss of his manager / romantic crush, Jack makes a fateful decision while performing live in front of the entire world. He wants to be true to his heart — and art —without depriving the world of glorious music. It is a contrived ending, but enjoyable the less you think about it.

After the initial charm wears off, you realize that “Yesterday” dodges a lot of important questions about the mysterious nature of creativity and musical collaboration. It would’ve been a much more interesting film if director Danny Boyle and screenwriter Richard Curtis had ditched the rom-com elements and settled on a story about intergroup conflict in the production of pop masterpieces. Even with a treasure map in hand, it wouldn’t be easy.

Advertise with us

Instead of the movie being about one musician who remembers The Beatles, what if it had been about two — and they belonged to the same failed garage band? In my version of a post-Beatles world, the two songwriters fight over the ethics of appropriating the Lennon/McCartney catalogue, even though The Beatles technically “never existed.”

Facing eviction from the only space they could afford in modern London, the musicians recruit a Bangladeshi-born guitar whiz to enhance their sound. They teach her the “George Harrison” songs before dropping a DYI version of the entire “Revolver” album on YouTube and other social media. They call themselves The Rubber Soul Band.

The public response is one of overwhelming indifference, with the exception of a Japanese performance artist/shipping heiress who offers to both underwrite and produce them.

Without a George Martin-level producer mediating between their conflicting ideas — i.e, interpretations, the songwriters suspect they’re doomed if they don’t take “Yoko Ono’s” deal. Even with the entire Beatles catalogue at their fingertips, they still lack the creative spark — the frisson of The Beatles they love and remember.

The first thing their new patron does is fire their loyal, longtime drummer and hire a session player who has been knocking around London for decades — an old hand named Richard Starkey.

Advertise with us

As soon as “Ringo” joins the band, the music comes roaring to life. In a relatively short time, they become the biggest rivals to Korean pop on the planet. Still, the “songwriters” are rattled by Ringo’s presence — and guilt-ridden, because he works for them and not the other way around.

They’re further spooked when they learn that Ringo was in a band in the early ‘60s called Silver Beetles with “three lads with mad talent and ambition” who fired him and hired a drummer named “Pete Best” before disappearing into obscurity. Ringo offers to teach his new bandmates the “failed songs” they played (the original songs of the first five Beatles albums in our reality).

Before going to the studio, Rubber Soul seeks out Paul McCartney, John Lennon and George Harrison to secure permission to record their early songs, but none of the elderly men wants anything to do with “Ringo’s daft get-rich-quick schemes.” Still, the old men are promised song credits, even if they never cash their royalty checks.

Finally, Rubber Soul believes The Beatles catalogue is legitimately theirs now because the music only exists because of them. Still, they agree not to record anything beyond “Let It Be” out of respect. Meanwhile, Rubber Soul is sued by every pop band on the planet for plagiarism and musical theft. Even Lennon and McCartney sue them. Because The Beatles never “existed,” the bands they influenced have developed their sounds organically. Rubber Soul has to pay hundreds of millions in damages and cease recording. They’re left destitute and disgraced (except Ringo).

Terrible movie you say? Well, it’s a cool “Black Mirror” episode, if nothing else.

Advertise with us

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.