Mustafa Mousab Alowemer, the suspected 21-year-old mastermind of a plot to bomb a North Side church in the name of the Islamic State, will have a lot of time on his hands in the coming years to ruminate on what went wrong.
The Northview Heights resident, who is also a resettled Syrian refugee, was arrested by the FBI last week by an undercover agent he believed to be a co-conspirator in a plot to plant a bomb that would kill worshippers at the Legacy International Worship Center on Wilson Avenue.
Mr. Alowemer allegedly wanted a second bomb on a timer to go off once police and other first responders arrived on the scene of carnage at the North Side church in the Perry South neighborhood.
All the while, Mr. Alowemer would be establishing an alibi by being seen worshipping at a local mosque at the very moment a shrapnel bomb hidden in a backpack was eviscerating a church he believed to be comprised predominantly of Nigerian Christians. The bombing was planned for sometime in July.
It was an audacious conspiracy that would’ve been difficult to pull off under the most ideal circumstances from a terrorist’s perspective because Islamic State-inspired discussion boards are monitored. From the beginning of the alleged plot to its end, Mustafa Alowemer was a textbook case of terrorist aspiration and real-world incompetence.
This is not to diminish the outstanding work of the federal and local authorities who caught him. Even incompetents can get lucky if the folks charged with keeping us safe are asleep at the wheel.
Read More
Still, what Mustafa Mousab Alowemer didn’t know about masterminding a deadly conspiracy is shocking. First, he didn’t know or suspect that engaging in conversations on an online discussion board sympathetic to the Islamic State would trigger an automatic “follow” by the FBI and other federal and local authorities whose job it is to foil the terror attacks.
Mr. Alowemer didn’t seem to know the most elementary things about his neighbors in Northview Heights or his target, the Legacy International Worship Center. He assumed from the name of the church that it was an international congregation.
When Mr. Alowemer would see Rev. Hatungimani Pacifique in the neighborhood and nod respectfully in his direction, he believed he was slyly sizing up the pastor of a Nigerian church. Because he was angry at Nigerians for setbacks against the Islamic State in that country, he wanted to punish them.
Because Mr. Alowemer didn’t know his neighbor, he incorrectly assumed that the Victory of God Methodist Church that Rev. Pacifique oversees is ethnically Nigerian and that the man he exchanged pleasantries with in passing was of Nigerian origin.
Little did he know that Rev. Pacifique’s congregation is primarily drawn from a community of expats from the Republic of Burundi and the Democratic Republic of Congo. Mr. Alowemer didn’t know that the particular congregation he planned to attack moved from that Wilson Avenue sanctuary more than two years ago.
Mr. Alowemer didn’t know or understand the ethnic composition of the community he was allegedly conspiring against. He didn’t know that the Nigerian church of his vengeful imagination simply didn’t exist and that a vibrant, native-born congregation of African Americans worship in the building now.
For a young man who has been in the United States for enough years to know better, Mr. Alowemer didn’t know that would-be bombers like himself almost always get caught. They never seem to realize until it’s too late that they’re corresponding online with undercover federal agents who are masters at pretending to be fellow low-information terrorist wannabes. He didn’t know the person he was corresponding with.
Mr. Alowemer didn’t think through what would potentially happen to his family if his plot was uncovered. Because of the allegations against him, his family now faces eviction from Northview Heights. The assumption that will hover over them as they try to relocate is that they knew of his alleged terror plot and did nothing to stop it. Whether this is true or not, only the Alowemer family knows for sure. Still, they will pay a steep price for even being associated with him.
Mr. Alowemer didn’t seem to know much about Pittsburgh and how it was likely to react to yet another attack on a house of worship. He didn’t know how battle-tested and ecumenically supportive the religious community has become since the slaughter at the Tree of Life raised Pittsburgh’s national profile in the most tragic way imaginable.
He didn’t know that pastors, imams, rabbis and civic leaders would lock arms in solidarity against whatever cause a would-be bomber would advocate. He didn’t know that with the exception of white supremacists and other online trolls calling for the expulsion of refugees from the area, that his message wouldn’t resonate.
He didn’t know that Rev. Michael Anthony Day, the pastor of the church he was planning to bomb, would offer him something truly radical: A message of “Love thy neighbor, and forgive him even if he is an enemy.” That’s quite a contrast to the Islamic State’s central message: “Blessed be the terrorists.”
Mr. Alowemer has never known the kind of gratuitous love offered by the pastor and congregation he allegedly tried to destroy. In all likelihood, the thought of such “obnoxious forgiveness” probably repulses him. He doesn’t know his neighbors and certainly never felt obliged to love them. Somewhere along the line, Mustafa Alowemer figured that it’s probably easier and more efficient to kill those you don’t really know.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.