Last week, many Pittsburghers were haunted by the tale of two women, both of whom wrestled with demons of uncommon ferocity. As their despair mounted, both tried to end their lives, but only one succeeded in leaving this world.
The week began with a news story about Kimberly Andrews, 20, a woman diagnosed with bipolar disorder and oppositional defiant disorder, who had been held for more than 70 days in solitary confinement at Allegheny County Jail. Ms. Andrews was arrested on a misdemeanor theft charge, but it didn’t take long for the rules of an inflexible institution to kick in and aggravate her mental illness.
After seizures and other expressions of an illness the jail was not prepared to deal with, Ms. Andrews was put into solitary without basic hygiene products such as toothpaste or soap. She attempted suicide on three occasions, but the jail failed to address her cries for help with either appropriate speed or consideration for her basic humanity, according to a lawsuit filed by the Abolitionist Law Center on her behalf.
The jail alleges that, when Ms. Andrews was briefly integrated back into the general population, she tried to incite a riot and displayed a bad attitude toward authority. Months in solitary was the institution’s mandated way of dealing with a suicidal rebel with mental illness arrested on minor theft charges. There is no concept of proportionality at the Allegheny County Jail, an institution that has repeatedly proven itself a nexus of suicide and bureaucratic indifference.
Devoid of meaningful human contact, Ms. Andrews entered an inevitable downward spiral. She had no access to psychiatric counseling or medicine while in the “hole,” a barbaric, punitive space devoid of any rehabilitative value. It has not evolved in the hundreds of years it has been used as a form of behavior modification.
Even so, jail authorities claim that those sent to solitary confinement are removed from the gen-pop for their own good. Being cast into inhuman isolation is intended to “protect” them from other inmates, the jail’s sublimely callous overlords insist.
Read More
Fortunately, the Abolitionist Law Center has managed to get a judge to approve Ms. Andrews’ move to “an appropriate unit” once a medical and psychiatric evaluation has cleared her to rejoin other inmates.
Ms. Andrews still must remain at the jail pending trial for misdemeanor theft, but a harsh spotlight has been cast on the jail now that its garbage pail of worst practices toward the mentally ill has spilled into public view. At least for a little while, the jail has to pretend not to be one of the nine circles of Dante’s Inferno.
•
On Friday evening, less than 8 miles from the jail, another woman who was experiencing a dark night of the soul drove her SUV to the middle of the Homestead Grays Bridge.
Stanlee Allyn Holbrook, 26, of McKees Rock, left her three kids between the ages of 1 and 9 in the car as she closed the distance between a life of unbearable pain and the sweet oblivion on the other side of the railing.
As horrified drivers looked on, Ms. Holbrook either jumped or fell from the railing into the dark embrace of the Monongahela River. Her body was found a few hours later. Her children were unharmed, but one can only imagine the trauma the 9-year-old and any sibling old enough to understand what was happening were experiencing.
Back in McKees Rocks, Ms. Holbrooks’ neighbors spoke of her in glowing terms as a dedicated mom who only wanted the best for the three children she was raising alone. Her mother helped with the kids when she could and the neighbors believe Ms. Holbrook even sought counseling at one point, but her personal demons finally won the war of attrition.
We can only imagine the last thoughts of a mother who loved her children but felt too overwhelmed by life’s circumstances and her own fragility to be of much use to them. They will be left to think whatever children think when something as terrible as this befalls them.
•
Without knowing anything about the circumstances of either woman beyond what’s been reported, we can’t help but wonder why we refuse to do better than this as a society when it comes to helping the obviously hurting people among us. Why do we allow so many of our fellow citizens to fall between the cracks?
Why do we resort to punitive measures in the criminal justice system instead of resorting to counseling or other more humane responses? Why is it always the lash first? Why is it considered “too costly” to treat those with mental illness like human beings who shouldn’t be assigned to a dungeon just because their illness prevents them from obeying the rules?
And why is a single mother struggling to balance the cost of health care for a child born prematurely against the cost of keeping all of her children fed and clothed and a roof over all of their heads? What should our role be in mitigating the trouble that millions of citizens living lives of quiet desperation experience daily?
At what point does the richest nation that has ever existed realize that the greatest and most practical form of national self-defense includes investing in the downtrodden and most alienated among us — the ones Jesus referred to as “the least of these?”
We’re haunted by these two women because what happened to them is also a story about what’s happening to the rest of us.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.