Botham Shem Jean left this world wondering what all of his scrupulous attention to the rules of middle-class propriety had gotten him.
As he stared down the business end of a white officer’s gun in his own apartment, the fact that he was a God-fearing, workaholic accountant for Pricewaterhouse Coopers LLP didn’t earn him the benefit of the doubt.
A willingness to take accounting work home on weekdays while denying himself the distractions that most young bachelors in Dallas are expected to pursue turned out to be an empty sacrifice.
Allison Jean, his grieving mother, was proud of her son’s work ethic yet concerned that he didn’t carve out nearly enough time for himself.
The fact that his weekends were tithed to the Dallas West Church of Christ, where he sang hymns with a voice many described as a gift, didn’t save him. It didn’t earn him the benefit of the doubt. Eternity came knocking on a Thursday night.
As Botham Jean stared at Officer Amber Guyger, he must have wondered why this strange uniformed police officer was prepared to kill him in his own home. What could he have possibly have done to deserve this, he must have thought to himself.
Read More
What did gainful employment and regular church attendance matter if it was all going to boil down to a moment of supreme absurdity like this? What did a degree from Harding University, a Christian college in Arkansas where he sang hymns and spirituals in an a-cappella group, matter in the scheme of things?
Botham Jean was considered a campus leader at Harding. He was a friendly face to all and an inspiration to those who championed a mythical post-racial identity in the name of Christ. Later, his mother would insist through tears as she tried to make sense of why her son was dead that he “didn’t see color.”
I must respectfully disagree. Botham Jean was a black man who had to navigate the streets of Dallas like all black men do just about everywhere in America — with a sense of wariness that comes with always being assumed to be dangerous.
Even if he was blessed with the most minuscule amount of paranoia possible, he was still aware he was a black man. He wasn’t privileged enough to not see color.
But it’s not even about whether people “see color.” It’s about whether they see what they believe to be danger embodied by the color of black men and boys who get too close. Swathes of society see “guilty until proven innocent,” whether a black male is wearing a suit or sagging jeans. They don’t see color — they see an exaggerated threat to their existence until proven otherwise.
But, like a lot of people, Botham Jean probably assumed that all of the choices he’d made — to go to school, to live a life of piety, to work hard, to keep busy and sing in the choir — would insulate him from the randomness of being shot either by a scared white cop or a black gang-banger.
That’s why all the respectability he’d cultivated in his life up to that point must have felt like an illusion. Having two bullets from Officer Guyger’s gun enter his chest — in his own home — was an act of savage unfairness.
Botham Jean was an accountant. His mind was attuned to details, hard numbers, percentages and possibilities. Even as gravity took over and his body tumbled to the floor, he knew the odds were against him and that he would never get a satisfactory explanation on this side of the grave for what had brought the wrath of this police officer down on him.
He already could see in her terrified expressions that she wasn’t capable of making much sense of that moment, either.
As the body temperature of a person who has been shot oscillates between the hot pain of the entry wound and the chill of plunging blood pressure, I’d like to think there’s space to take a calm accounting of things.
Botham Jean probably regretted leaving his family behind under such terrible circumstances, but he wasn’t afraid. He was dying, which was absurd, but he’d lived his life with integrity. Life had been good. He had a clear conscience and couldn’t find anything in the memories flashing before his eyes to indict him. He was ready for his Lord and his God.
Why did Botham Jean have to die? Why wasn’t he given the benefit of the doubt for one second during that encounter with Officer Guyger? We don’t know. All we know for sure is that, for all of his respectability, he was just another black man staring into the smoky abyss of an officer’s gun.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.