What started out as a sly attempt at job shaming by Fox News on its website last month has had the opposite effect. The headline on the Aug. 31 news item gave away the game immediately: “‘Cosby Show’ actor Geoffrey Owens spotted bagging groceries at NJ Trader Joe’s.”
It was far less clever than the headline used by a trashy British tabloid earlier in the week: “From learning lines to serving the long line!”
The piece featured an unglamorous photo of Mr. Owens taken by a shopper at a Clifton, N.J., store who was startled to see him there, but not startled enough to resist invading his privacy. After all, Mr. Owens was once known to millions of viewers as Elvin Tibideaux, the son-in-law of Bill Cosby’s Cliff Huxtable character on “The Cosby Show.”
The photo of Mr. Owens, who looks either startled or resigned at having his picture being taken by a stranger during his shift, is juxtaposed in the Fox News piece with a mid-80s glamor shot of the actor with Sabrina Le Beauf, who played his wife Sondra on the hit series that ran from 1984 to 1992.
You can almost hear the snickers that went into composing both the stories and headlines. The Fox News story didn’t even make an attempt at explaining why Mr. Owens’ retail gig “bagging groceries” was remotely newsworthy, though the unspoken subtext is unmistakable: “See how far the mighty (re: minor) celebrity who used to be somewhat famous on a show about black middle class excellence has fallen.”
It was the kind of trolling that usually pays big dividends in America by artfully disguising the economic class warfare at its heart with race-based gloating and Horatio Alger mythologizing.
Read More
These stories about celebrities “forced” to rub shoulders with the masses to make a living reflect the unapologetic Social Darwinism of the billionaires and millionaires who own the media platforms doing the shaming. They drip with disdain for both working class and middle class people who often take on side hustles to make ends meet.
Running an unflattering news story about a working stiff “celebrity” is also supposed to act as a cautionary tale to those tempted to moan too much about the peanuts they’re currently being paid: “Shut your mouth or you’ll end up like Elvin” is the message.
While most working Americans realize that they’re two missed paychecks away from joining Geoffrey Owens at Trader Joe’s, they remain in denial about it. Any job that prevents that from happening is a good job.
For his part, Mr. Owens, who only played a doctor on “The Cosby Show,” but didn’t really go to medical school, is refreshingly pragmatic about it. “There is no job that is better than another job,” Mr. Owens told “Good Morning America” when he was interviewed recently. “It might pay better, it might have better benefits, it might look better on a resume and on paper. But, actually, it’s not better. Every job is worthwhile and valuable.”
Most actors, like most Americans, are working hard to stretch their dollars to cover the rising cost of living in a nation where extremes of fortune, ranging from an unexpected ambulance ride and hospitalization to graduating from a top university with no immediate job prospects, can leave someone in unsustainable debt for decades.
Admittedly, Mr. Owens’ case has an added titillation factor because of his past association with Bill Cosby. When the convicted sex-offender’s top-rated show was pulled from syndication, it also shut down the residual income that every “Cosby Show” actor had once relied on between gigs. They needed the cash it provided far more than Cosby did.
So what is an actor whose last steady paycheck from a weekly TV gig was 26 years ago supposed to do? If he or she has any self-respect, they do what Geoffrey Owens did. Or, they could turn their “celebrity” into an opportunity for right-wing punditry on Fox once their fame cools completely — (I’m looking at you, Kanye).
The upside to Fox’s failed attempt at job shaming is that it raised Mr. Owens’ profile and generated enough audition opportunities and acting job offers to get him through the next couple of years as he approaches 60.
It also generated an enormous social media response from fellow actors and celebrities who admitted that they’ve been where he is today and would gladly do “ordinary jobs” again if warranted. It was also a reminder that the actors whose names we know are an exception and that most people in entertainment are anonymous working stiffs who cobble together any number of daily hustles to get by.
When Geoffrey Owens talked about “the dignity of work” on “Good Morning America,” the nation applauded. Even the woman who took the picture that alerted the tabloids that a once-famous celebrity was making an honest living in New Jersey regrets it. It turns out that the only truly “undignified” jobs in America belong to the hacks who write headlines and stories mocking hard-working people like Geoffrey Owens.
Tony Norman can be reached at: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.