There are a few possible reasons — some more admirable than others — why a non-binding vote cast by fewer than 11,000 attendees at a religious convention would make national headlines.
Although those voting attendees (“messengers”) represented about 13 million Southern Baptists — only 5.3% of the American population — the topic they were weighing at their convention last week was in vitro fertilization, part of an area that some call “reproductive freedom.” Many voters of all religious persuasions (and none) are on the lookout for trends that could eventually impact state laws — especially in big election years.
Adding to its newsworthiness, the story touches our raw nerves on cultural division. The people attending religious conventions are, like those at political conventions, the most ardent believers, the most personally invested and thus likely to hold more stringent positions than others do — even than members of their own denomination or party. Any new stance automatically creates a divide.
Shaming and self-justifying
And so it was at the Southern Baptist Convention, where numerous attendees spoke passionately about their experiences with and gratitude for IVF treatments. But I think there’s another dynamic at work here. From religious conflicts to disinvestment protests to “cancellations,” we’re drawn to stories that raise our “holier than thou” hackles.
We seemingly can’t resist going through the shaming and self-justifying cycle that someone else’s public moral stand incites in us. Or we’re drawn to taking such a stand and exulting, however privately, in our excellent judgment. Maybe it’s a necessary and regular part of leading the examined life, but if we’re not truly examining our hearts, things sure can get sad and ugly.
The Southern Baptists’ resolution was not without nuance. It didn’t condemn IVF but rather lamented that unused embryos created in the process are often destroyed. Given their belief that life begins at conception, this means that “frozen embryonic human beings” are being destroyed.
What if their resolution sets a standard higher than God’s?
With or without God, the same impulse can be seen in places far from the floor of the Southern Baptist Convention.
When activists take over college campuses and demand that the administration disinvest from any company that offers any products that may have been used in any way whatsoever by a government they don’t like, is what they are seeking a rational level of moral purity?
In the religious realm, we called this tendency “legalism.” There are Christian sects, for example, which do not allow the use of musical instruments in worship, and others do not sing anything but psalms — this despite Bible verses that command people to worship with cymbals, lyres, etc., and to sing “psalms, hymns and spiritual songs.” Their restrictions are more stringent than those set forth in what they believe to be God’s word.
There are sects that prohibit men from shaving or women from wearing makeup; that prohibit dancing, drinking, going to the movies or playing cards. Jewish and Islamic sects have their own varieties of this.
Aspirations and rules
There are often noble aspirations behind such constraints, but when they are imposed as rules rather than matters of conscience, the negative fallout begins. (I know — I survived it.)
And when adherents seek to impose their rules on others, the results are usually disastrous. However well-intentioned, they may end up harming blameless people, as could happen with the Southern Baptist Convention’s IVF resolution.
It denounced “dehumanizing methods for determining suitability for life and genetic sorting, based on notions of genetic fitness and parental preferences.” Without medical intervention, the human body does not honor “parental preferences,” but scientists estimate that 40 to 60% of all embryos are lost in the natural human reproductive process. That is, the womb itself conducts “genetic sorting.”
For the same reason, multiple eggs are fertilized during IVF. Some fail to develop into viable embryos, and it is normal practice to implant multiple viable embryos in a woman’s body in the hope that at least one will “take.”
The SBC resolution calls for members “to advocate for the government to restrain actions inconsistent with the dignity and value of every human being.” But the assertion by Southern Baptists, Catholics and many other devout people that a fertilized embryo is a human being will be the impediment to political consensus on IVF practices — as it is now to the use of “morning after” pills.
This is too restrictive a standard, and needlessly divisive. It is legalism that would punish those actually seeking to “be fruitful and multiply.”
Clear logic
The logic is clear: The successful implantation of the embryo into the womb is absolutely essential to the existence of a human being. Many fertilized eggs don’t form embryos; many embryos fail to thrive. That is the system that many of us believe to be ordained by God.
For those who consider this situation without reference to any god, I hope you’ll at least agree that it illustrates the impossibility of being pure in this world.
It’s almost as if humanity is under some kind of curse.
Ruth Ann Dailey is a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com. Her previous column was “The true Justice Samuel Alito scandal.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.