Which is the bigger scandal — that the deeply religious Samuel Alito believes the nation would be better off if more people were religious, or that the major media think this is news?

It’s the latter, of course — but worse than both of those by far is that their coverage, based on secret recordings, missed the most important discovery — one that many Americans would have found quite reassuring.

Lauren Windsor, described by Wikipedia as “an American left-wing advocacy journalist,” attended a gala hosted by the Supreme Court Historical Society last week and, presenting herself as a conservative Catholic, engaged both Justice Alito and Chief Justice John Roberts in conversations she was secretly recording.

Everyone missed the real news

Over the weekend Ms. Windsor posted the audio files on X, along with her own commentary, and outlets from Rolling Stone to the New York Times covered it pretty much as she prompted.

Advertise with us

But in doing so they missed the real news: Despite anti-court activists’ claims, hidden in Ms. Windsor’s leading questions, both Justices Alito and Roberts made it clear that they will not be used by anyone — not by her, nor by any movement seeking to turn the nation into a Christian theocracy, which Ms. Windsor claims to fear.

That was how she justified her actions to CNN’s Jim Acosta a day or two later, but to the justices, of course, she claimed concern simply about “the polarization in the country.”

After asking Justice Alito “how do we repair the rift,” she opined that no solution was likely: “It’s a matter of, like, winning.”

After saying she was probably right, Mr. Alito observed, “There can be a way of working, a way of living together peacefully, but it’s difficult, you know, because there are differences on fundamental things that really can’t be compromised.”

That seems a fair assessment: Living together peacefully is difficult in the face of profound disagreement. But Ms. Windsor tried again. “I think that the solution really is like winning the moral argument,” she said. “Like, people in this country who believe in God have got to keep fighting for that, to return our country to a place of godliness.”

Advertise with us

“I agree with you, I agree with you,” he responded.

The crucial question here is, in which arena should citizens be “fighting” for a return to godliness — or for any other way of living? In elections and courts of law? Or in churches, synagogues and mosques, or in our homes, over coffee or dinner?

The answer to the crucial question

It was John Adams, the nation’s second president, who said, “Our constitution was made only for a moral and religious people. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other.”

Was he wrong? Is it just a coincidence that as the nation’s religiosity declines, our social cohesion has frayed and our respect for institutions plummeted?

Despite what his words might lead you to think, Adams was a Deist and a staunch opponent of state religion. He appreciated the vast distance between acknowledging the positive social impact of sincere religious faith and promoting any particular creed from the top down.

Advertise with us

But that distinction is what Ms. Windsor tried to get both justices to ignore. She professed to Mr. Alito her “very pro-life” stance and the desire for the court to “bridge the gap” with those who disagree.

“I don’t think it’s something we can do,” he replied. “We have a very defined role. We need to do what we’re supposed to do, but this is a bigger problem. This is way above us.”

The Chief Justice’s response was even stronger. When Ms. Windsor said the court should be leading the country on a more “moral path,” Mr. Roberts replied, “That’s for people we elect. That’s not for lawyers.”

When she insisted that “the founders were godly” and that “we live in a Christian nation, he said, “I don’t know that we live in a Christian nation. I know a lot of Jewish and Muslim friends who would say maybe not, and it’s not our job to do that. … [T]he role for the court is deciding the cases,” Mr. Roberts insisted.

Days later, when she faced professional criticism for her “journalistic” methods, she explained herself thus on CNN: “This country right now is at a crossroads,” she said, “and much of this is being led by the Supreme Court. Are we going to continue our tradition of secular democracy, or are we going to be led to Christian theocracy by this Supreme Court?”

Advertise with us

A great service

The justices’ answers are quite different from how she spun them online. Her post on X: “Justice Alito admits lack of impartiality with the Left, says: ‘One side or the other is going to win.’”

Well, yes, that’s usually how any contest ends. A statement of simple fact is not a lack of impartiality.

Chief Justice Roberts and Justice Alito have just done us all a great service. Invited by a supposed ally to reveal their true thoughts, they did. Their adherence to the separation of church and state is welcome reassurance to those impartial enough to listen fairly.

Ruth Ann Dailey is a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com. Her previous column was “Who's the real threat to democracy?”