You’ve got to hand it to Joe Biden. He’s no quitter. Since the Supreme Court struck down his first massive student loan forgiveness plan in June 2023, he has come up with another. The president announced it Monday, as an ABC News headline noted, “in battleground Wisconsin.”
Under the 2023 plan, the president would have forgiven student debt for over 40 million Americans, at a cost of $400 billion. State attorneys general and various individuals sued, and when they won, Biden went to the Supreme Court. The justices ruled against him.
In response, the president has dialed down his latest unilateral effort, aiming to cancel some debt for about 30 million borrowers, at a cost ranging, various experts say, from $138 to $475 billion.
What’s being saved?
The new iteration is called “the SAVE plan.” But who or what is this plan saving? Some debtors, Joe Biden’s second term, or both?
And at what cost? A cynic could have fun with the numbers. Assuming every grateful borrower will vote for Mr. Biden, and choosing a mid-range cost of, say, $300 billion, that’s $10,000 per vote, courtesy of the U.S. Treasury. The per-vote cost rises to $15,000 if the program ends up costing $450 billion. It falls, however, if more than one voter is swayed with each loan forgiven. (A relieved parent or spouse, say.)
But anything that costs the “U.S. Treasury” actually costs the taxpayers — all of us, including those who did not go to college, those who worked their way through or those who have been chipping away at a loan. Moreover, the skyrocketing national debt impacts the entire economy, constraining economic growth and making us vulnerable to future financial crises.
Read More
The activists who’ve worked for over a decade to achieve federal government loan forgiveness argue that the massive student debt is itself a financial crisis. Their movement sprang from the Occupy Wall Street movement of 2011, and senators Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren supported loan forgiveness in their 2016 campaigns for the presidency.
Some say the movement’s ever-growing strength has forced President Biden down this policy path, but that may not be what’s really driving him.
Consider these facts: Total student debt is rising. It’s now more than $1.75 trillion owed by 40 million former students. But that figure is actually falling as a percentage of Gross Domestic Product, from a high of 7.94% of GDP in 2020 to 6.31% in 2023. The 2023 level is about what it was in 2011, when the “cancel our debt” movement started.
Individual borrowing is falling too — likely because interest raises have risen sharply during the Biden presidency.
And that’s the heart of the matter, really. People with variable-rate loans for their education, cars, credit cards and homes are getting pummeled by this economy.
When student loan payments resumed last fall after the long pandemic pause, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau warned that one in five borrowers might struggle. Higher education expert Mark Kantrowitz told CNBC that those with student loans “might be behind on other debt because they got overextended due to higher inflation and higher interest rates.”
It’s politics
But should the federal government erase some citizens’ debt at the expense of others? Is that fair to those who did not “overextend” themselves?
Some workers need cars, not college degrees. Should they get debt relief? Should an hourly worker at a big-box store be paying off the loans of married college grads who can, per Mr. Biden’s plan, earn up to $125,000 per year?
If this administration truly deplores income inequality, it will find a way to fine-tune its approach to student loan defaults, as it did with victims of for-profit college scams.
Maybe Mr. Biden could work with Congress on this, but initiatives of the past nine months suggest a president determined to get his way even if the legislative and judicial branches of government tell him no. Doesn’t this threaten our democracy?
At the end of the day — or, rather, at the end of this election cycle — it may not matter to Joe Biden whether his latest debt-cancellation plan becomes reality. It works as a political tactic. Attorneys general in red states have already sued to protect their state’s loan programs. Republicans will be the bad guys.
Mr. Biden wasn’t going to win committed Trump voters, so he can afford to make them angry. He must win independents and mollify disgruntled young progressives.
The less-bad option
We are again heading for an election in which we choose the less-bad option. People who preferred Donald Trump’s economy have to accept his daily, amplified, personal chaos. Biden voters have to brace for even more financial chaos.
Both candidates indulge unilateral, autocratic impulses (as have past presidents). Whatever our individual philosophies, it’s sad how quickly we accept government by fiat so long as it scratches our itch.
Ruth Ann Dailey is a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com. Her previous column was “What does acknowledging our ancestors' sins do?”.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.