There has to be a better way. There has to be alternative legal reasoning that achieves restitution for devastated parents-to-be whose embryos have been destroyed. A way to soften their loss without defying science and, once again, needlessly holding the pro-life position up to ridicule.

The Alabama Supreme Court did not find that way.

A weird and shocking case

To be sure, by insisting in LePage v. Center for Reproductive Medicine that fertilized eggs in cryogenic storage are “children,” the court was narrowly observing the letter of Alabama law (while throwing in God and the Bible as a bonus).

The irony is that this ardent pro-life position now jeopardizes the ability of other time-haunted people to pursue parenthood — to create life — while they still can.

Advertise with us

The incident at the heart of the Alabama case is weird and shocking. In 2020, a patient at a Mobile hospital wandered into its fertility clinic, entered the “cryogenic nursery,” picked up a container and dropped it, burned by its sub-zero temperatures. The embryos were destroyed.

The couples hoping to have children from those embryos brought various lawsuits against the clinic and the hospital — for breach of contract, negligence and wantonness — but the claim at the heart of the relevant case is for violating Alabama’s “Wrongful Death of a Minor” statute.

Here is a crucial passage from the court’s decision: “All parties to these cases agree that … an unborn child is a genetically unique human being whose life begins at fertilization … that an unborn child usually qualifies as a ‘human life,’ ‘human being,’ or ‘person,’ as those words are used in ordinary conversation and in the text of Alabama's wrongful-death statutes.”

However, “The question on which the parties disagree is whether there exists an unwritten exception to that rule for unborn children who are not physically located ‘in utero’ … at the time they are killed.”

Because the court ruled there is no such exception, it therefore found that the clinic was responsible for the “wrongful death of a minor.”

Advertise with us

But “all parties” to this case are wrong. Their shared position defies both common sense and science. In fact, it flies in the face of the medicine that the clinic practices and that the couples themselves sought.

An embryo is a potential life. It will not become a human being without successful implantation in a woman’s womb. Yes, it is genetically unique, but implantation is an absolutely necessary step for a living human being to result. Therefore, what is biologically alive in the lab is not a “child.” Not yet.

How disrespectful of the unique role of a woman’s womb to insist otherwise.

No one wanted nuance

The Court actually had an “out” in its own interpretation of state law, as it acknowledged by writing that “an unborn child usually” — usually — “qualifies as a ‘human life’ … in the text of Alabama's wrongful-death statutes.” But the Court and the suing appellants rejected nuance.

It’s surprising that the clinic agreed upfront that all the embryos it produces are in fact “children.” After all, in the IVF process many more embryos are created than are used. “Developmentally impaired embryos” are discarded. Some that are used don’t achieve implantation and are shed by the body. Some implant but later fail and are miscarried.

Advertise with us

Are these all deaths to be mourned? Are some wrongful? Should unsuccessful test-tube embryos be ceremonially handled?

What do clinics risk being sued for — now that the LePage decision allows would-be parents to seek additional financial damages for “wrongful death”?

Given this suddenly precarious position, Alabama fertility clinics suspended operations, and state lawmakers on both sides of the aisle are rushing to reexamine what they accidentally wrought.

It will be too late for some would-be parents. BBC News reported on an Alabama resident and devout Christian named Margaret Boyce who had been on fertility drugs for 10 months and was days away from implantation when her clinic stopped all procedures, post-LePage. Who will compensate her for her heartbreak and loss from this heavy-handed decision?

And what about the losses caused (or allowed) by the most pro-life being of all — God? Scientists studying IVF embryos have noted, almost as an aside, that the overall pregnancy success rate from both natural and in vitro fertilization is only about 50%.

Advertise with us

Neither scientists nor the Court know whether those destroyed embryos would have produced living babies. Only God does, and He seems okay with that 50% figure.

Better idealist than ideologue

I’m not suggesting the Alabama appellants should have just accepted such a blow. The clinic failed them. But claiming “wrongful death” strains and damages our common understanding of life’s complexity.

The difference between an idealist and an ideologue is that the idealist adapts, however sadly, when cherished precepts encounter the realities of this broken world. And this world desperately needs fewer ideologues and more sad but loving realists.

Ruth Ann Dailey is a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com. Her previous column was “Why is the city hurting the downtown?”