Biology is not policy. So, even if we could all agree that life begins at conception, that would not determine what the law of abortion, or other ways of terminating human life, should be. Nevertheless, if we ignore biology altogether, our policies are very likely to be wrong.

This became clear in the aftermath of the February Alabama Supreme Court decision that frozen embryos created through in vitro fertilization are “children” for the purpose of a wrongful death action. The embryos were accidentally destroyed and the court held that a couple could sue the clinic.

Pro-life reversal

There was nothing legally surprising about the decision. The court had held since 2011 that the unborn are children under the statute. All the court added was that human life outside the womb is protected as well.

The pro-choice movement was predictably disdainful of the decision, especially the concurrence of Chief Justice Tom Parker, who used religious language in discussing the “sanctity of unborn life” provision in the Alabama Constitution.

Advertise with us

More surprising was the vote by the Republican-dominated Alabama state legislature a few weeks later granting immunity to IVF clinics in any civil or criminal actions. The concern was not so much the occasional act of negligence, such as that involved in the original Alabama case.

The problem that shut down such clinics in Alabama after the court decision was that IVF treatment typically generates extra embryos that are frozen for future need. Eventually these frozen embryos are destroyed. Nationally, there may be a million such frozen embryos. No one knows for sure. There would have been serious issues of liability.

The pro-life movement had always insisted that human life begins when the process of conception ends. That is why the movement always opposed the morning-after pill and forms of stem cell research.

But once the Alabama court applied that logic to IVF treatment, previously pro-life legislators began to talk about implantation in the womb or a fetal heartbeat as the possible beginning of human life.

These points are arbitrary. Why not self-awareness? Or a college degree? On what grounds did the Republican legislators choose the position they did?

Advertise with us

Selective sympathy

In order to justify destroying developing human life, it has always been felt necessary to create confusion about when a human life begins. The U.S. Supreme Court in Roe v. Wade stated it need “not resolve the difficult question of when life begins.”

But there is no doubt about when human life begins and that conclusion has nothing to do with religion. In basic biology, the sperm has 23 chromosomes and the egg 23 chromosomes. In the process of fertilization, a human being — and occasionally more than one — with 46 chromosomes and a unique combination of gene variations, is created.

Each one of those million frozen embryos is a unique human being whose development has been interrupted. Why, then, did the reliably pro-life Alabama legislature rush to allow IVF clinics to destroy any frozen embryos on hand and create an unlimited number of new ones?

One answer plainly was political pressure. Many couples in Alabama use IVF techniques and they were loud in their demands.

But the more fundamental reason is that these legislators had sympathy for couples trying to conceive a child. This is understandable. But it does not change human biology.

Advertise with us

And it raises the question of why legislative sympathy does not extend to the 13-year-old pregnant girl or the middle-age woman who already has a family and cannot provide for another child. Their need for an abortion is just as sympathetic.

It also suggests that abortion restrictions do not really affect women that these legislators can identify with — their own daughters, perhaps, who can always fly to New York for an abortion.

Only two policy choices

Once you admit that human life begins at conception, you really only have two policy choices. You can say that all forms of human life are sacred and that any time a human life is destroyed, the justification must be similarly absolute — when the life of the mother is threatened, for example.

Or you can conclude that although all human life is morally significant, the weight of that significance is less for the early stages of human life than for a fully formed human being. On that view, although destruction of that life is a serious matter, other interests can outweigh it. That is the implied view of the Alabama legislature, which now should loosen restrictions on abortion.

If you accept that position, however, the clinic in the Alabama case was rightly held potentially liable for its carelessness. IVF should not be prohibited, but should be strictly regulated. There should not be a general immunity.

Advertise with us

Early abortions would often be justified, but late abortions rarely so. It would not be enough to say simply, a woman’s body, a woman’s choice.

If we are going to justify destroying human life, we should admit it. Honesty about biology does not guarantee sound public policy. But dishonesty about biology guarantees the opposite.

Bruce Ledewitz is a professor of law at the Thomas R. Kline School of Law of Duquesne University. His previous article was “Biden must debate Trump, but not until he recants.” The views expressed do not represent those of Duquesne University.