Pittsburgh’s leaders once again face the same crucial decision they’ve encountered again and again in the years since heavy industry’s demise. Do they want this city to live or die?

With recent headlines touting efforts to convert empty office buildings into affordable housing or to allow denser new home construction, you might think city leaders already answered that question: Yes to renewed life, via new residents and economic growth.

But our leaders are definitely not all on the same page. Some don’t even seem to know where the book is.

An ominous sign

An ominous sign comes courtesy of Pittsburgh Regional Transit. PRT recently launched construction on its first “bus rapid transit service” — the “University Line” — a development which will significantly reduce other forms of beneficial traffic on some of the city’s busiest avenues.

Advertise with us

To accommodate buses coming from Uptown and Oakland, the traffic on Fifth and Sixth Avenues Downtown will soon become one-way and single-lane, with parking allowed on only one side of the street. Again, these are “avenues” — relatively broad corridors — which currently hold four lanes (legally or not). With the University Line, they still could manage three.

But no. On Sixth, limited parking will be allowed on the side where Hotel Monaco, Brooks Brothers, the Duquesne Club and a few eateries stand. On the other side of the street, a red line will signal total prohibition of parking in front of two historic churches, Dollar Bank, the Omni William Penn and many other buildings.

The “deciders” make it awfully easy to see these changes as part of an ongoing campaign against privately-owned vehicles and the very enterprises — whether commercial or faith-based — that provide the vibrancy they say they want.

When the Peduto administration ignored stakeholder protests and pushed forward with the (little-used) bike lane along Penn Avenue, there was enormous economic upheaval, even with parking available on the opposite side of the street.

This new project is much bigger and its likely impact more severe. I attend First Presbyterian Church of Pittsburgh, founded in 1773, the oldest surviving institution of any kind in the city. Next to it on Sixth stands the lovely Trinity Episcopal Cathedral. How will either church hold weddings, funerals, concerts or other events without safe access to their front doors?

Advertise with us

When asked, PRT representatives seemed to think the churches could arrange ad hoc parking in front of the Duquesne Club, with brides holding up their gowns or mourners rolling caskets, dodging the “high-speed” buses on Sixth.

An unachievable goal

As a volunteer, I attended this discussion, but I am speaking only for myself here, not for my church. The thinking seems to be that reduced traffic will allow buses to move “rapidly.” This is absurd on its face. The city blocks are short, and there’s a traffic light at every intersection.

Destroying scores of enterprises’ accessibility in pursuit of an unachievable goal is incomprehensible.

Why are commuters from the East End getting preference over people who live, operate businesses, dine and worship Downtown? What are the numbers of these two different groups — bus riders versus everyone else — and what economic benefit does each group bring?

When church reps put this to PRT and DOMI staffers, their consistent answer was, “It’s already federally funded.”

Advertise with us

The two churches submitted a joint letter with more questions on Aug. 9. PRT replied in November with boilerplate and stonewalling.

Now word is that the project won’t be completed until 2027. Perhaps the slower pace will allow some of the project’s more dire aspects to be revisited.

By fighting for the life of our church, we are fighting for the lives of the city’s most vulnerable citizens. On Tuesday nights we host free dinners attended by upwards of 125 people. Like Trinity, we provide an open pantry and clothes closet one week out of five that serves scores of unhoused or underprivileged citizens.

For three hours on three afternoons every week, as many as 60 teens walk in to find a safe, after-school hangout, “The Cellar,” with food, games, art projects and even indoor basketball.

First Presbyterian is doing what the government cannot. A 2019 study found that the church’s congregation of just under 200 has a positive economic impact of more than $2.3 million annually. Next week we launch a foundation repair project that will cost about $500,000, with a grant of $200,000 from Partners for Sacred Places and administered by the National Trust.

Advertise with us

We are still investing in the city and in her people. And we are just one of the many institutions or businesses facing a near-extinction-level event at the hands of a bizarrely unresponsive local government.

Government advantage

The private sector is always at a disadvantage. Hoteliers, restaurant managers and church volunteers come and go; institutional memory is lost. But a government program is forever, even when it’s misguided and destructive.

It’s not too late for the powers-that-be to soften the blow. They should. Sometimes a bureaucracy’s vaunted improvement is just slow death with a fancy name.

Ruth Ann Dailey is a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com. Her previous column was “We need an independent candidate for president, but not the one in the ad.”

Correction: The original said First Presbyterian’s foundation project received $200,000 from the National Trust for Historic Preservation. It came from Partners for Sacred Places.