What Joe Manchin really needed was a shocking Super Bowl ad. Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s ad — rather, the one about him — is so heretical that three days and several apologies later, noses are still out of joint in some of America’s poshest homes and smokiest back rooms. Since those noses are very special noses, the ad’s handling is still making news.
What is more news-worthy is these legacy-keepers’ distortion of the legacy RFK Jr. is allegedly violating.
And despite his apologies, he must be loving it. That’s a lot of attention on someone else’s dime — and a lot of attention for any independent. (Poor Joe Manchin!)
No longer 1960
The ad in question is a remake of a historic television commercial from John F. Kennedy’s 1960 campaign. Back then, its catchy graphics and jingle injected a fresh, young style into the staid world of political advertising.
Fast-forward 64 years — 64! — and the American Values Super PAC has taken this historic ad, superimposed Robert’s face on his uncle’s and paid $7 million to debut it at the Super Bowl. They did all this without asking permission or seeking his input, the candidate says. In fact, he noted, it would violate Federal Election Commission rules for the political action committee to have coordinated anything with his campaign.
If it was a brilliant ad for a 43-year-old in 1960 — “old enough to understand and young enough to try something new” — it’s brilliant for the 70-year-old RFK Jr. It reminds voters of his storied family, but the retro look and music are hip and attention-getting all over again.
Read More
That’s yet another reason for members of the clan and the Democratic establishment to cry foul. Various prominent Kennedys have publicly criticized RFK Jr.’s anti-vaxxing position and his penchant for all kinds of conspiracy theories, and they’ve endorsed Joe Biden for reelection.
While Mr. Kennedy has posted a blanket apology and sent individual mea culpas to various family members, the ad was still pinned near the top of his X page on Wednesday morning. Having it both ways at once — that’s how we know he’s serious about the presidency.
The controversy itself is much ado about — well, not nothing, but truly the wrong thing. How many people not named Kennedy are offended? You have to be at least 70 years old to remember the original ad. How many of the nation’s elders are peeved on the Kennedys’ behalf?
What the family fracas really illustrates is how vastly policies and labels have changed since the brief Kennedy era.
No more middle
The family’s biggest grievance against the 70-year-old son of former Attorney General Bobby Kennedy is that he’s exploiting the family legacy to find success as an independent — not as a Democrat. If, however, John F. Kennedy were running today, his own party would reject him.
Many of Kennedy’s policies were pretty conservative. He pursued rearmament (unlike his Republican predecessor Dwight Eisenhower, the World War II hero who warned about the “military-industrial complex”). But even as Kennedy increased military outlays, he worked to restrain other federal spending.
He also pushed to slash income taxes for both individuals and corporations, in order to stimulate growth. He argued the tax cuts would pay for themselves as a growing economy brought in more tax revenue. That’s Supply-side Economics 101.
In truth Kennedy’s policies — and those of most of his contemporaries — were much more mixed than the nation’s polarization allows today. In that regard, RFK Jr.’s mishmash is closer to his uncle’s world.
Apart from his “baseless conspiracy theories,” that is. But if Democrats were really concerned about those, they wouldn’t have spent years promoting “Russia-gate.”
The polarization that gives us Donald Trump (again), forces Joe Biden ever further to the left and makes Mr. Kennedy unwelcome in his longtime party feeds on itself and grows. How do we break the vicious cycle of mutual mistrust?
When Mr. Kennedy posted the PAC’s remade ad on X, he added these words: “It’s time for an Independent President to heal the divide in our country.”
I think he’s right. Only someone who has demonstrated courageous independence from whichever of the two parties he or she comes from will be able to “heal the divide.” It’s just not this Kennedy.
Manchin the healer?
Healing the divide also requires possession of all one’s marbles. There’s no room for undisciplined spouting. The nation cannot endure more wacky medical theories, calls to bomb our allies over unpaid bills or foreign entities giving lucrative ghost jobs to presidential relatives.
With Nikki Haley reeling from her Nevada loss to “None of these candidates,” we turn to West Virginia’s similarly independent Joe Manchin. Too bad his supporters didn’t think of a Super Bowl ad, too.
March Madness is right around the corner, though. Its name and endless slog seem appropriate for these times.
Ruth Ann Dailey is a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com. Her previous column was “Dementia, diabetes, failing hearts and trips to Kansas City: Living the long goodbye with your parents.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.