Although the Israel-Hamas war grows more morally fraught the longer it goes on, its first day revealed clear and simple truths about American society that need to be examined. We should assess its tragic fallout here on our own soil.
While the Hamas terrorists’ recorded delight in butchering Israeli civilians revealed their depravity to the world, the immediate celebration of this massacre in some American enclaves revealed, if not depravity, a startling dishonesty that should change forever how we see and respond to some in our midst.
They took to the streets
On college campuses and in larger cities, people took to the streets to proclaim solidarity with the Palestinian people.
Some last gasp of liberalism may have shaped their rhetoric — the desire to support the weak against the strong, perhaps — but people with any knowledge of 20th century history and recent Mideast warmongering could easily refute the categorization of the Jews as the “strong” side and the Palestinians as “weak.”
And even if we had accepted those uninformed labels prior to Oct. 7, they should have been discarded the moment Hamas terrorists breached the Israeli border and began murdering innocent children.
Read More
Instead, campus radicals, young and old, blamed these horrifying deaths on the Jews. Ignoring documented facts of the slaughter to blame its victims is a profound betrayal of the justice they claim so often and so loudly to seek. We should remember this.
These same radicals have spent the past few years militating for “safe spaces” on campus, places to go calm themselves after encountering facts and ideas that challenge their beliefs. But when Jewish farmers and their children are gunned down in “safe rooms,” that’s okay? We should remember this gory double-standard.
When American Jews in New York, Florida, California and elsewhere began taping photos of kidnapped Israelis to utility poles, Palestinian sympathizers tore them down and obscenely vilified anyone who recorded their actions. One Brooklyn woman told the New York Times she’d done so because the posters were “anti-Islamic war propaganda.” So the truth is propaganda?
Our university-based radicals, young and old, are very devoted to “diversity” — racial, ethnic and socioeconomic diversity, though not diversity of thought — yet in standing against Israel, they are standing against what is probably the most diverse land in the Middle East.
The immoral madness
From the same political cohort comes the new American trope of beginning business and academic meetings by citing the indigenous tribes who were the last to possess the land (however briefly) before Europeans entered the picture. If those adhering to this principle applied it equitably, they’d have to acknowledge that the Jews possessed all of Palestine millennia before the Palestinians did. Why isn’t philosophical consistency important?
Within hours of the Hamas massacre, some chapters of Black Lives Matter posted an image of a Hamas paraglider like the ones who landed in a music festival to murder hundreds of Jewish young people.
The next day, BLM Chicago responded to criticism by saying that while they weren’t “proud of” the post, they “stand with Palestine & the people who will do what they must to live free.” Is decapitating Jewish babies what Palestinians “must” do to “live free”? Is murder better than supporting a legitimate government?
At first glance the positions espoused by America’s young radicals (and the older university professors who guide them) seem to have no logic or moral consistency. Upon further examination, though, we see there is a method in this immoral madness.
The radicals are on the side of whoever is against Western civilization. They are anti-democracy. They are against the very concept of truth. They oppose diverse liberal societies like the U.S. and Israel where people from anywhere can thrive.
If this means they must “stand with” extremist regimes whose domestic militias beat and kill gays, veil-free women, ethnic minorities, members of illegal home-churches and anyone else who doesn’t fit their rigid worldview, well, then so be it. As long as they stick it to “the patriarchy,” right?
We have reared a generation or two of Americans with so little moral imagination, knowledge or wisdom that they’d destroy the culture whose liberties and abundance they enjoy. This crime gets pinned squarely on us boomers.
The only possible remedy
No amount of coddling will entice radicals to suddenly embrace reason. Unwavering resistance is the only possible remedy. It’s already being tried, as a few brave administrators suspend gleeful pro-murder profs and brave donors take back their gifts.
We should hope such repudiation spreads. Other than divine intervention, it’s our only hope.
Ruth Ann Dailey is a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com. Her previous column was “Against the antisemitism of the left and the young.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.