The race between Sara Innamorato and Joe Rockey for Allegheny County Executive brings to mind a classic bit from “Saturday Night Live.” The skit spoofs the 1988 presidential debates, with Dana Carvey impersonating George H. W. Bush and Jon Lovitz playing his Democratic opponent, Massachusetts Gov. George Dukakis.
“Vice Pres. Bush,” a tad entitled and increasingly evasive, sums up his arguments with a mishmash of campaign jargon — “we’re on track — we can do more — but we’re getting the job done, so let’s stay on course, a thousand points of light.”
When the moderator asks “Gov. Dukakis” for a rebuttal, he deadpans, “I can’t believe I’m losing to this guy.”
Rockey = Dukakis, Innamorato = Bush
Fast-forward 35 years, home in on Southwestern PA, and you’ll find the mismatch similar but the parties reversed.
Locally it is the Republican, not the Democrat, who is the milder, more articulate and cerebral candidate. Mr. Rockey is clearly more qualified for our highest local executive office than Ms. Innamorato and brings greater experience, knowledge and insight to the issues challenging our region.
Read More
The comparison ends there, though. Making any equivalency between the late Mr. Bush and Ms. Innamorato does him a disservice. However inarticulate he could be, he was, by the time he ran for president, an accomplished statesman with an impressive record. Ms. Innamorato, by contrast, is an inexperienced politician in a hurry.
Much as I like to see women leading and contributing anywhere, she simply isn’t ready for the county’s top job. As a progressive firebrand, moreover, she seems both ideologically and temperamentally unsuited to this position’s managerial demands.
Some might wonder, like Dukakis versus Bush, how Mr. Rockey could be losing to her. He may not be, actually.
A mid-October poll conducted by a pro-Rockey outfit shows likely voters favoring Ms. Innamorato by only one percentage point, 45 to 44, with 11% undecided and a 4.9% margin of error. That’s a lot of wiggle room, but it’s a tighter race than the Democrats’ two-to-one registration advantage would indicate.
Perhaps the tightening race explains Ms. Innamorato’s decision to double-down on the irrelevant issue of abortion rights. There are few issues likelier to get her foot-soldiers to the polls but, as many have pointed out, it has virtually nothing to do with the work of a county executive.
On this issue, as Mr. Rockey noted in their debates, the job of a county executive is to uphold and enforce the law.
Disrespecting the law
Speaking of respecting the law, it is troubling that Ms. Innamorato has apparently and repeatedly failed to do so in her own campaign ads. In mid-October she was pressured to pull and amend an ad featuring debate footage that the contract she signed prohibited her from using. (The uncorrected ad is, however, still readily viewable online.)
According to a spokeswoman for the “furious” League of Women Voters, Ms. Innamorato blamed her media team, saying they “hadn’t seen the contract.” But presumably she saw the ad before releasing it? If not, we should worry about her lack of attention to such an important matter.
If she did see the contract-violating ad before its release, should we worry more that she lied and threw her media team under the bus, or that she knowingly violated the contract until forced to retreat?
Now the county’s Republican Committee is going after her for using video footage from the floor of the state House of Representatives, which committee chairman Sam DeMarco called “a violation of House rules that explicitly forbid the use of taxpayer-funded video for political purposes.”
Does it bode well for Allegheny County to be led by someone who seems to think any contract or rule can be ignored in order to advance her agenda? That Ms. Innamorato’s ambition repeatedly outweighs her respect for the law indicates she doesn’t take this office very seriously.
Political tribalism may hold sway and propel a not-ready-for-prime-time candidate onward and upward. So may this region’s lingering — and unjustified — sense of needing to catch up with any other part of the country. Are other cities sweeping progressives into power? Oh dear, then we should too!
Souring on progressives
But from New York to Philadelphia to California, voters are souring on progressives and recalling them — especially those in local offices — as the accumulating evidence demonstrates their ideology brings chaos and decay.
Allegheny County voters should leap ahead of the curve, skip the learning-through-disaster stuff and put a sensible, experienced, law-abiding adult at the wheel.
Ruth Ann Dailey is a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com. Her previous column was “Summer Lee (fortunately) faces a challenger.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.