Outsiders often say of Pittsburgh that though it’s a Democratic town, it’s “little-c conservative.” It’s not philosophically conservative — the big-C conservatism — but little-c: just cautious and careful enough to always be a bit behind the times.
That might explain how progressive Matt Dugan upset incumbent Stephen Zappala in May to become the Democratic candidate for Allegheny County district attorney. While the rest of the nation’s big cities are reeling from seven or eight years of progressive “reformers” at the helm of their criminal justice offices, Democrats here have decided to follow that now-tired fad and foist already failed ideas on this vulnerable city.
Or so it may seem. The citizenry’s little-c conservatism may yet prevail. Voters face the same choice in November that they had in May — Dugan versus Zappala — but this time with a partisan swap-aroo and no party-affiliation barrier on their vote.
When about 9,700 Republican primary voters wrote in Mr. Zappala’s name, he became eligible to run as a Republican against the man who that same day defeated him for the Democratic nomination. And after holding the office for 25 years as a Democrat, Mr. Zappala accepted the GOP nod last Monday. Thus the rematch.
Two weeks earlier, when Mr. Dugan resigned as the county’s chief public defender to focus on campaigning, he publicly acknowledged that his victory was due to a massive ad buy funded by George Soros. Before that, “I had no name recognition,” Mr. Dugan said. “No one knew who I was.”
Four days before the May 16 primary the Post-Gazette had reported the $734,000 from a Soros PAC donated to Mr. Dugan in March and April. The same article identified Mr. Soros as a “target of anti-Semitic attacks and a bogeyman for the right.” Anti-semitism is always loathsome; so is accusing people of anti-Semitism simply because they disagree with a political figure who happens to be Jewish.
Read More
Mr. Soros is a 92-year-old Holocaust survivor and Hungarian-American billionaire who has given away most of his wealth (at least $32 billion) to fund charitable causes and left-wing politics. Way back in August 2016, a Politico article detailed how he was putting enormous sums into “reshaping the American justice system.” In the years since — especially following the murder of George Floyd — Soros-backed candidates have had great success at the polls.
They have not had great success in office. From San Francisco to Chicago, to St. Louis and Philadelphia, Mr. Soros’s chosen reformers have struggled or failed. They’ve faced staff mutinies, critical investigations, ethics violations, resignations and even recall votes.
Things got so bad last year that Mr. Soros wrote a defensive Wall Street Journal editorial stating: “The idea that we need to choose between justice and safety is false. They reinforce each other: If people trust the justice system, it will work. And if the system works, public safety will improve.”
This is true on its face, but success depends on a DA’s definition of justice, the policies that spring from that definition and how well, or poorly, those policies are implemented. Ask a store owner in downtown San Francisco or Chicago whether it is “just” to shrug off shoplifting cases of less than $1,000. As those cities’ retailers flee, ask residents how they feel about having no convenience store or pharmacy nearby.
The problem isn’t Mr. Soros (or, on the other side of the aisle, the wealthy and highly political Koch family). The problem is what any candidate stands for — the ideas that attract donors’ money.
In a pre-primary interview with WESA-FM, Mr. Dugan mused that Philadelphia DA Larry Krasner was embattled because he has no like-minded progressive peers with whom to pursue reform. By comparison, Mr. Dugan said he would be able to “work and collaborate and partner” with Mayor Ed Gainey and Congresswoman Summer Lee.
Reforms are certainly needed. Some, such as doing away with cash bail for misdemeanors or ending charges for marijuana possession, make sense. But ending bail for nonviolent felonies? Seeking reduced sentences as a rule?
We need to give proposed reforms as much discussion as we’ll be giving the complaint against Mr. Zappala — conveniently filed just one week before the primary — accusing him of making prosecutorial decisions based on personal or political motives.
Mr. Zappala has a 25-year track record and personal history, some of it pretty distasteful to local Republicans. Mr. Dugan is a relative unknown whose political ideas and affiliations give plenty of voters pause.
How will Pittsburgh’s little-c conservatism play out in November?
Ruth Ann Dailey is a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com. Her previous column was “Unalterable decisions in fraught realms of life.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.