If Giant Eagle wants to win me back, it should decide to once again carry the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette on its shelves and advertise in its pages.
Its new leader should announce this as loudly as the former leader hypocritically banished the PG back in 2020.
Despite that ban, this newspaper cheerfully and professionally reported a few days ago that interim CEO Bill Artman is determined to woo former customers back and regain the historic chain’s regional dominance, recently ceded to Walmart.
“Our customers are telling us that they want to shop with us,” Mr. Artman said. “Our customers are telling us that they’re looking for a better value.”
As he implied, “looking for a better value” often sends budget-minded shoppers to other retailers. In my experience, pretty much any store except Whole Foods is less expensive than “the Big Bird.”
The savvy shopper plays a running game of grocery math. You keep track of prices. You stock up on sale items and quickly calculate whether going somewhere else for a lower price is worth the time and gas. You build up and strategically use reward points.
I’ve appreciated and used Giant Eagle’s perks program in each of its iterations, but my patronage of other grocers escalated dramatically in June 2020. That’s when Giant Eagle responded to an alleged racial conflict at the PG by severing the decades-long business ties between the two companies.
No more ads, no more shelf space.
It was big news.
Much less well-known is the lawsuit filed three months later by a group of Black truck drivers against Giant Eagle claiming racial discrimination in their termination. Their lawsuit alleged ugly racial incidents dating back several years that went undisciplined and therefore escalated, and for which Black employees were fired, while white employees were not.
Because they keep their self-serving distance from this excellent newspaper, Giant Eagle leaders may not know that Alexis Johnson, the former PG reporter who alleged racial discrimination, withdrew her complaint more than a year ago.
Ms. Johnson had claimed she’d been unfairly removed from covering the George Floyd protests; the paper said she had not been covering them and thus could not have been removed. The court filing for voluntary dismissal acknowledged months’ worth of texts missing from her phone — texts between her and leaders of the Newspaper Guild, which the newspaper saw as a coordinated campaign.
The Giant Eagle situation seems similarly messy. The company has reportedly settled with some of the Black former employees, and in March a judge granted the company’s request for a summary judgement, dismissing the case.
But on April 27, two of the Black drivers filed a notice of appeal. Days later Mr. Artman granted his first interview since becoming interim CEO way back in March. That’s interesting timing.
He said, they said. The company said, the union said. Clarity and certainty are rare.
Mixed feelings? I have them. Despite my distaste for the self-serving harm Giant Eagle has done to this newspaper — and therefore to civic health — I still shop there.
I go for one hard-to-find item (my husband’s favorite yogurt) and usually end up with a few other things in my cart. I also buy an awful lot of gift cards for other brands I patronize more enthusiastically — like Target and Home Depot. Buying those cards is a quick way to rack up what used to be called “fuel perks.”
In other words, I use Giant Eagle as cynically as it used the Post-Gazette. They trashed the PG in a self-righteous and hypocritical dis-play, and I use them for free gas. It’s a draw.
The world would be a better place, though, if people and corporations alike stopped smearing each other in order to claim what they perceive to be the moral high ground.
The better way to occupy high ground is to behave nobly and to disagree without doing damage.
Mr. Artman seems like a good guy. His first job was as a Giant Eagle bagger. He admits Giant Eagle needs to “get better.” It’ll be interesting to see if his humility spreads through the C-suite.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.