Ten years ago, in the days immediately after the slaughter at Sandy Hook Elementary School, my first reaction — like everyone else’s — was to mourn the incomprehensible loss of life. My second reaction, though, was to urge calm as we considered gun-law reforms, because decisions made when we’re overwhelmed by emotion are rarely wise.
That was many, many murders ago.
Since then, the atrocities committed by American civilians have so multiplied that I can’t remember them all. The names, dates and locations blur together. The latest as I write (what a sad qualifier!) is the slaying of six people, three of them nine-year-old students, at a private parochial school in Nashville.
A former student of The Covenant School, 28-year-old Audrey Hale, had stockpiled weapons and carefully planned the assault. When responding officers shot and killed her, she had an AR-15 rifle, 9-mm pistol, handgun and many bullets.
Hale was reportedly being treated for an “emotional disorder” and had recently begun to identify as a man in social media.
Given the various over-lapping groups — parents, teachers, Christians, transgender people, mental health professionals, gun-owners — touched by this terrible crime, I’ve wondered how representatives of those groups, particularly Christian intellectuals, would respond to our shared sorrow and fear.
Read More
Esau McCaulley, an associate professor at Wheaton College and theologian-in-residence at Chicago’s Progressive Baptist Church, wrote these moving words in his New York Times column: “[E]very single young body riddled with bullets from guns that we could control preaches a sermon. It issues a word of condemnation, a jeremiad.”
As he noted the varied backgrounds of the nation’s mass killers, he asserted, “The one thing that unites [them] is the easy access they had to weapons, owing to the laws that exist in our republic.”
I must add the second thing that unites them — mental illness — because it is crucial to breaking our long, ongoing stalemate over gun control.
A person who commits mass murder is by definition very ill. After Sandy Hook, Uvalde and now Nashville, it’s hard to deny that preventing the mentally ill from owning and using guns is a pressing matter of public safety.
In fact, galvanized by last May’s massacre at Robb Elementary School in Uvalde, Tx., Congress passed a bipartisan bill intended to prevent dangerous people from accessing firearms and to increase spending on the nation’s mental health system.
That bit of progress was clearly too recent to prevent the Nashville tragedy, and it may not be enough as we look ahead, fearfully.
A February essay from another Times writer, Anglican priest Tish Harrison Warren, contemplated what Christians give up for Lent and proposed we reconsider “idolatry” — not some bizarre ancient statue but anything, real or abstract, that we worship in place of God.
“Typically, communities, nations or subcultures have particular idols, which become so normative that they are no longer recognized as idols,” she wrote. “They become the water we swim in.”
Back in 2018, after the mass killings at a Parkland, Fla., high school, Rev. Warren tweeted, “If you want to know who or what a culture worships, look at what people are willing to let kids die for.”
In February’s column, pre-Nashville, she zeroed in on one idol: “The United States has a profound devotion to guns.” Many Americans indeed worship “false idols,” but in the context of regular mass murders, identifying guns as our idol casts too small a net.
I know plenty of people who own guns, myself included. I know hunters, “preppers” and average, upstanding parents intent on protecting their families. I don’t know anyone who idolizes guns.
What we all idolize is self-definition. Americans celebrate the will of the individual, at the expense of the community, carried to an extreme the world has never seen before. We want what we want, and we want it now. We vilify those who condemn our choices or dare get in our way.
When it comes to guns, too many of us resist reasonable public safety measures — waiting periods, background checks, registration databases, and so on — lest these delay our immediate gratification.
We even grant total autonomy to people whose mental illness is obvious, who rave on city street corners, use drugs on the sidewalks and sleep in shop doorways, lying in their own filth. And we pretend this is granting them the dignity of personhood.
Where our extreme definition of liberty disintegrates is in a bloody school hallway.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.