How appropriate that a Pittsburgh police union official invoked a biblical miracle to address the bureau’s deepening crisis.

One unlikely miracle would be, as Robert Swartzwelder noted, for the next police chief to be a Messiah who can “break police fish in half and get 10,000 more [officers].”

Another unlikely miracle is finding a way to reconcile the very different and impassioned views on exactly how much and what kind of policing is needed to make Downtown safe.

This latter “miracle” cannot be left to divine intervention (though plenty of that is needed and would be welcome). It is, rather, the responsibility of the citizens who share this community and those who lead it. It will require an authoritative “yes, and” approach.

Advertise with us

Before anything else, it should be said that our police are not responsible for the level of crime and unease Downtown. Period.

Various tragic forces have created the unsettling situations we all face on city streets, including — but not limited to — rampant substance abuse, homelessness, the economic downturn, decades-long neglect of mental health care and unsocialized, unsupervised young people roaming the streets.

Intensify all that with the pervasive anxiety and depression lingering from the pandemic, and you’ve got an explosive situation.

The police are not to blame for these crises, but we count on them to manage the mess for us, and we hang them out to dry when they fail.

Just a guess, but maybe this accounts for their “abysmal” staffing levels and beleaguered morale.

Advertise with us

Who would want to do this often thankless job? Few of us would (obviously) but judging from the mail I receive, most of us know we desperately need a healthy police force. Most of my correspondents also have strong opinions about what to change.

The Tuesday meeting at which Jesus’ loaves-and-fishes miracle was invoked brought together representatives from the mayor’s office, city council, the police union and the police force.

An article on the meeting appeared on page A-7 of Wednesday’s Post-Gazette. On A-4 was a report on how the horrifying beating death of Tyre Nichols in Memphis, like George Floyd’s murder in Minneapolis, illustrates failure to obey “duty to intervene” policies.

Tuesday’s front page featured the county’s offer to bolster city forces. The article right below it covered the advocacy of the Black Political Empowerment Project to make changes to local stop-and-frisk and traffic stop policies, thereby reducing the number of interactions between citizens and the police.

Each day’s news, then, featured calls for increased staffing and changes in conduct.

Advertise with us

These are not irreconcilable needs, though people who ardently support the police and those like B-PEP demanding change often seem to be talking, or shouting, past each other.

All citizens need to feel confident that officers are not opportunistic and menacing but are looking out for all of us. Granular, good-faith discussions amongst all interested parties — like Tuesday’s meeting achieved — could do much to reassure everyone, but particularly people of color, that tragic lessons from cities like Memphis are being learned.

At the same time, we simply need more uniformed officers putting shoe-leather to pavement. Or bicycle tires to pavement.

Or horses’ hooves.

On my most recent drive past Katz Plaza, site of much recent harassment, drug dealing and panhandling, I saw three officers on horseback paused along Penn Avenue. Traffic was heavy; I had time to observe the reactions of passersby.

Advertise with us

They were intrigued. They stopped to watch the majestic horses and the uniformed men who were chatting and absent-mindedly stroking the big beasts. The animals’ presence made it, strangely, a more human moment. Peaceful but vivid.

We need more moments like that — cheerful, reassuring interactions — to build confidence, both ours and our officers’.

As officer Jason Lloyd said at Tuesday’s meeting, “[T]he younger [officers], they need to see something happen that gives them a reason to stay.”

This is the moment for Mayor Ed Gainey, the city’s first Black leader, to express support for the department and demonstrate the ability to bring all these disparate voices together for the city’s good. That would be the miracle of leadership.

ruthanndailey@hotmail.com