Joshua David Shapiro is not Pennsylvania’s first Jewish governor. Milton Shapp (born “Shapiro” in Cleveland, Ohio) preceded him by fifty years, and Ed Rendell was sworn into the same office 20 years ago.

Gov. Shapiro is, however, the first who displays — or feels free to display — a deep, lifelong commitment to his faith. As widely noted, he used a stack of three Hebrew Bibles at his inauguration — one carried on D-Day by a Philadelphia soldier, the second a family Bible and the third from Pittsburgh’s Tree of Life Synagogue.

Named for the heroine of my Baptist father’s favorite Bible story, I found the new governor’s choices quite stirring. While certainly very meaningful, will this gesture provide not just symbol but real substance for all the other citizens of the Commonwealth?

Though Mr. Shapiro is not a “first,” Austin Davis has made history as the state’s first Black lieutenant governor. This office, like the vice presidency, often seems to lack substance — or to have only as much as its occupant and the governor agree to.

Advertise with us

It would be difficult for Lt. Gov. Davis to achieve less than his predecessor, who was known for little besides advocacy of legalized marijuana. Perhaps that is unfair to now-Sen. John Fetterman, though; who (other than party activists) can remember the names of any previous lieutenant governors, much less their pet causes?

As reasonable (if narrow) as Mr. Fetterman’s drug-legalization goal was, citizens might expect more from a new team that makes such a strong statement about Pennsylvania’s diversity. Both Gov. Shapiro and Lt. Gov. Davis sounded encouraging notes on Tuesday, the latter commenting, on his journey from McKeesport to Harrisburg, that “the American dream is alive and well here in Pennsylvania.”

How will these new leaders translate symbolism into substance?

On Gov. Shapiro’s first day in office, he signed an executive order stating that 92% of executive branch jobs will not require four-year college degrees. The hope, symbolically, is to encourage more people who lack such degrees “to seek employment opportunities within state government” and to encourage businesses to follow suit.

In substance, though, only 270 people in the 72,000-person executive branch workforce — or less than 4/​10ths of a percent — currently hold positions that strictly require a bachelor’s degree; so the actual impact within government is minuscule.

Advertise with us

Symbolically, Mr. Shapiro also aspired to engage the private sector: “Find new ways to recruit and train a talented workforce,” he said. “I hope you will join us in this mission.”

Pennsylvania businesses are way ahead of him. Like those all over the nation, they’re desperate for workers. It is routine to see roadside signs and online postings such as “no degree required” and, indeed, “no experience required.”

The worker shortage is one of the greatest challenges Gov. Shapiro faces. His predecessor, Tom Wolf, who destroyed more than a few jobs with his pandemic measures, trumpeted an “all-time low” in unemployment as one of his achievements. The truth is more worrisome.

Unemployment figures do not include people who’ve stopped looking for jobs — who have given up. Pennsylvania’s Independent Fiscal Office reports that the number of people employed or seeking employment has not recovered post-pandemic. It even fell late last year, defying the usual holiday gains.

The IFO also noted the greatest decline is among those 19 to 34. Job opportunities continue to boom, but too many potential workers have opted out.

Advertise with us

The other job-market reality working hand-in-glove with that trend is Pennsylvania’s aging population. As retirees join opt-outs, lower overall employment means lower tax revenues, even as increasing retirements mean increased spending for government services. It’s a recipe for serious trouble.

Back to symbolism: in one of the nation’s Top Ten Oldest States, it’s good to once again have a young governor with children still at home. That’s something Pennsylvanians haven’t seen since Tom Ridge’s tenure.

Leadership is at least as much about “optics” and intangibles as it is about policy. Gov. Shapiro’s vigor, ambition and optimism could do more for the Commonwealth than reams of Harrisburg paper.

Sometimes the symbols are the substance.

ruthanndailey@hotmail.com