Here’s a handful of firecrackers for our Independence Day thoughts:

I criticized justices Sonia Sotomayor and Stephen Breyer last week for some surprising errors of historical fact in their dissents in Carson v. Makin, the decision that restored Maine families’ ability to use state subsidies at any private school, regardless of whether it is religious or secular.

Now the Supreme Court has ruled in Kennedy v. Bremerton School District, and this time it is Justice Sotomayor castigating the conservative majority for “misreading the record.”

The case concerns a Washington state high school coach who was fired after praying on the football field after games ended. The case is convoluted and the details really matter in this decision, so it was startling to read the justices’ very different accounts.

Advertise with us

Was the prayer “quiet” and “personal” as the conservatives claim? Was the prayer really “a severe disruption to school events,” per Ms. Sotomayor?

When did a solitary action become a group prayer? When did the coach invite opposing teams to kneel with him post-game? When is a teacher’s speech private and when is it rightly constrained by his public employment?

If you want an accurate understanding of the facts of the case, you should read the majority opinion, Sotomayor’s dissent and as much early news coverage of this years-long conflict as available online.

I did, and the whole thing strikes me as an avoidable, regrettable mess. I remain conflicted. The law aside, what bothers me is this: Was Coach Kennedy’s public praying wise?

God might actually not be a big fan of a sport where men bash their skulls into one another. But if you believe the New Testament, as Coach Kennedy obviously does, you know for sure that God is no fan of public displays of piety.

Advertise with us

Perhaps Coach Kennedy could have set a quieter example. Perhaps the school district could have acted more judiciously. Perhaps everyone was a little too eager for conflict.

I prefer to come down on the side of free speech, but this one leaves a bad aftertaste.

——————

Only in the aftermath of the Dobbs decision did I see John Fetterman’s early May tweet that read: “Let’s be clear: The right to an abortion is sacred.”

Sacred? A very strange adjective to choose, and likely to be off-putting to plenty of Pennsylvania voters weighing the current Senate race.

Advertise with us

The hard left’s thinking has only gotten worse post-Dobbs. Some articles in national media outlets have actually referred to the decision as a “ban” on abortion.

An email blast from The Atlantic acknowledges that Roe v. Wade was “the product of an activist Court” and claims “so was Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization.” No, that reached the court because of a state-level activism. Roe was subject to constant challenge because of its egregious overreach and because modern medicine makes it barbaric.

The Economist/​YouGov poll of June 25-28 contains about 15 excellent, nuanced questions on abortion policy, very much worth pondering.

———————

If you intend to tackle today’s Pittsburgh Puzzler, please stop reading now. Spoiler alert: The following paragraphs give away the theme and some hidden details. That’s because they’re too delightful to keep from Post-Gazette readers who are not crossword fans.

Advertise with us

Here goes. The only U.S. president born on July 4 was Calvin Coolidge — in 1872 — 150 years ago tomorrow.

He served during the “Roaring Twenties;” indeed, his administration’s policies helped to create those boom times. But Coolidge himself did not roar. It seems he barely peeped. His nickname was “Silent Cal.”

When informed that Coolidge had died, the literary wit Dorothy Parker asked, “How can they tell?”

I love that. Here’s another thing I love, discovered as I researched this puzzle: Coolidge, as Republican governor of Massachusetts and then U.S. president, actively supported women’s right to vote, racial equality and full citizenship for Native Americans. (How was that still an issue?)

Coolidge’s advocacy demonstrates that many years and many diverse leaders are usually needed for consensus and change — something to remember as we celebrate our fractured nation’s shared birthday.

ruthanndailey@hotmail.com