Here’s something that gets recycled more reliably than plastics: News stories on why recycling plastics is a “myth.”

As a writer, I’ve been working from home for over a decade now, which means that, with no regular commute, the time I spend driving — and drinking in the loveliness of billboards — is erratic.

On a recent errand I spotted a sign stating something like, “Plastic recycling is a myth,” but I couldn’t remember when or where it was. In my memory it overlapped vaguely with news that Pittsburgh City Council was considering a ban on single-use plastic bags in local businesses. The coincidence seemed odd, but when I looked online, it got even odder.

Various versions of this slogan have been bouncing around for at least three years now, from Greenpeace to Forbes to Time to … oh, Pittsburgh City Council.

Advertise with us

Last Monday it popped up in an email blast from The Atlantic, where the headline announced, “Plastic recycling doesn’t work and will never work.”

That, like almost everything else on the internet, is an exaggeration designed to catch our attention. The article itself undermined the headline’s claim; however, “Some plastics can be recycled, although far less than we assume” is a boring come-on indeed.

But if we sort facts from mere assertions the way we — as responsible adults — pick through our household waste, we will almost certainly reach the conclusion that America’s current recycling system doesn’t do enough.

That’s why the Pittsburgh bill — which passed after a not-till-2023 amendment — is a reasonable start.

The Post-Gazette’s article announcing its passage, however, drew an unusually high number of comments, many of them skeptical. Some folks claimed this would drive commerce to the laxer, plastics-embracing suburbs. (I doubt it; the East End, in particular, has been designed so no one ever has to leave it, and the constant gridlock guarantees they can’t.)

Advertise with us

Some complained they need those plastic bags to carry their lunch to work and to line trash cans at home. But this misses the bigger point: Some types of plastic do too much harm and therefore shouldn’t be manufactured at all. We may find a second purpose for flimsy grocery bags, but they will still eventually end up in our oceans, rivers and blood streams.

Not every one of humankind’s inventions has been a 100% success. There are certainly industries where plastics have been positive and transformative — the medical world, for instance. But as convenience-addicted consumers, let’s pretend for a moment that single-use plastics did not exist. How would daily life change?

When kids get their new sports jerseys each season, they could be issued a water bottle. Better yet, it could be a required part of their school supplies. Playgrounds and ball fields are always located near schools or roads and are therefore near water lines: They should all have public water fountains.

In fact, cities in the U.S., as in forward-thinking European cities, should have ubiquitous public fountains. Those wasteful “disposable” water bottles could become a thing of the past.

Speaking of bottles, Pittsburghers produce and drink an enormous amount of beer. Why should those bottles go to a recycling bin when they could go back to the brewery down the street?

Advertise with us

One of my favorite memories from many years ago in Erie, Pa., was how people lined up at a little Italian restaurant famous for its sauce. Customers brought their own pots to fill up. I saw then-Rep. Tom Ridge waiting in line once.

All of these instances bespeak a different approach to life — a slightly slower, more intentional way of moving through the day and in our communities. A broader way of looking at the places we live, of seeing beyond our immediate convenience.

In our epic consumerism and constant hurry, we produce an enormous amount of waste, much of it in pursuit of choice and convenience. Sorting our recyclables? Giving up toxic plastics? We can’t be bothered.

But we will be bothered, one way or another, now or later.

ruthanndailey@hotmail.com