Each day’s shifting news on the omicron variant makes it tough to guess what the prevailing powers’ next power moves will be, but here’s one prediction I think it’s safe to make:
Public school systems will not shut down during the omicron surge. They’d be crazy to do so.
For starters, as far as we know now, omicron is a much milder version of COVID-19. Then there’s the fact that almost two-thirds of us are vaccinated; none were, obviously, when schools were shut down in early 2020.
The public education industry is already struggling with a once-in-a-century exodus of students — and therefore money — in direct response to the way leaders in many districts handled the first year of the pandemic.
This self-inflicted damage may have caused permanent change in how American parents and taxpayers view our entire educational system. Before the pandemic, plenty of people favored structural overhaul solely on intellectual grounds, but by mid-pandemic their ranks appear to have swelled with those driven by deep emotion.
For almost two years now, we’ve watched an entire cohort of kids fall behind intellectually and suffer emotionally due to policies crafted by the sometimes irrational fears of adults.
Well, we haven’t just “watched.” As children suffered, we’ve protested, opined and voted some numbskulls out of office.
The pandemic is what business mavens call an “industry disruptor.” Here are some long-term and possibly permanent changes:
First, the pandemic has further loosened the education industry’s credentialism.
Pennsylvania began experiencing a teacher shortage before the pandemic, as college students increasingly chose other careers. The state had launched a “guest substitute teacher” program to entice uncertified but capable people to its classrooms.
The pandemic made the shortage worse, as worried, worn-out teachers retired or resigned. On Dec. 17, Gov. Tom Wolf signed a bipartisan bill that further expands eligibility for the guest-substitute workforce.
“During the COVID-19 pandemic,” he said, “we have learned how critical in-classroom education is for our K-12 students.”
Well, yeah, but some learned it the hard way and far too slowly. It was Gov. Wolf who shut the schools in the spring of 2020 but was unable to make them reopen in the fall.
Driving the destructively long closures were teachers and staff, not parents and kids. It was well known, before the Pittsburgh school board’s July 2020 vote to stay shut, that while COVID-19 was very seldom dangerous to children, they could carry and pass it to more vulnerable adults.
I don’t blame any at-risk teacher for opting to leave the classroom, but the entire Pittsburgh school district remained closed until April 2021, long past the point that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention approved re-opening.
Here and elsewhere, parents cannot be faulted for concluding that school districts prioritize teachers over students. Dubious measures such as forcing kids to eat lunch outside and socially distanced, or to wear masks at all times regardless of setting, only underscore the skepticism.
That’s the second major disruption of the pandemic — a decrease in parents’ trust — something that might matter a lot as districts like Pittsburgh seek tax increases despite enrollment declines.
Since the start of the 2021-22 school year, K-12 enrollment has dropped 3% nationwide. Pre-K enrollment has fallen a stunning 22%.
Half of New York City’s districts have lost over 10% of their students, with some as high as 24%, and most of the loss, leaders say, is due to the pandemic.
As COVID-19 closures have sent parents scrambling to meet their children’s needs, quite a few are clearly deciding to consider new options, from homeschooling to education pods to charter and parochial schools.
The big exit is the third disruption — for those who can afford it.
The less privileged are simply falling behind, as school leaders knew they would many, many months ago. Who holds them accountable?
While one sad fact is that COVID-19 is far more deadly for the elderly, it will be sadder still if adults unable to sort fact from fear continue making decisions that ensure the greatest victims are our young.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.