A recent Associated Press article, posted from Harrisburg, carried a thought-provoking headline: “Prison guard vaccinations increase after governor’s mandate.”
Those words prompt the mind in several directions, don’t they?
My first response is “Well, duh.” If you threaten people with the loss of employment — “Jab or Job,” as the protest placards put it — many will fall in line.
My second response, almost simultaneously, is to question whether a governor should have this power. Gov. Tom Wolf, in particular, has acted so imperiously throughout the COVID-19 pandemic that, had this been his first term, he likely would have failed to win a second.
(Ordering restaurants to close again last December, with only a few days’ notice, after they’d placed large holiday orders, was capricious and economically devastating.)
But when should anyone or anything — president, governor, court, legislature, employer — have the power to issue and enforce an ultimatum?
It depends on the circumstances, of course, but we should err on the side of individual liberty. We need to choose liberty whenever and however we can because, judging from history, humankind’s default setting is tyranny. We shouldn’t feed that beast.
Reading past the prison guard headline brought welcome news of reasonable work-arounds. This is important because when people in power make poor decisions for the rest of us (e.g. Mr. Wolf’s abrupt December 2020 restaurant shutdown) it impacts many, many people (wiping out the budgets of fragile restaurants and their employees, for instance).
When an individual makes a poor decision — which might be how you view vaccine decliners — who is impacted? With COVID-19, the greatest risk is borne by the person refusing the vaccine, who remains much more susceptible to the virus and to suffering and death. Those the unvaccinated person encounters bear far less risk if they themselves are vaccinated.
As a society, we are trying to thwart the spread of the coronavirus and lessen its impact on those infected. At what point will we have succeeded? When there are zero cases? Zero deaths? Or 100% vaccination rates everywhere?
No, those are all ridiculous standards, either because they are unattainable (zero cases and zero deaths) or unnecessary (100% vaccinations). We accept lower standards with virtually every other virus or disease that afflicts humanity. Why would we treat COVID-19 differently?
Why, then, should any government or employer be enforcing a 100% vaccination rate on employees and visitors?
The UNESCO Universal Statement on Bioethics and Human Rights states the following:
“Any preventive, diagnostic and therapeutic medical intervention is only to be carried out with the prior, free and informed consent of the person concerned, based on adequate information.”
And: “In no case should a collective community agreement or the consent of a community leader or other authority substitute for an individual’s informed consent.”
It’s mind-boggling that the United Nations asserts a higher standard of individual liberty than many Americans, from the White House down, currently embrace.
The words above I trip over are “free and informed consent … based on adequate information.” How “free” are you if non-compliance costs you your job? What constitutes “adequate information?” Who decides?
Give and take helps. Pennsylvania’s prison-employee mandate has an important work-around — weekly testing in lieu of vaccination.
The Oct. 8 AP article reported that in the mandate’s first two months, the number of vaccinated prison personnel had nearly doubled, to 43% of the system’s approximately 16,000 employees, and no one had been terminated due to refusal. The rate of resignations and retirements “has not been significantly different from … previous years,” a spokesperson said, and “thousands of tests” have been administered.
I weighed the vaccine’s risks (for about seven seconds) and got it months ago. Some intelligent, well-informed friends have chosen not to. A few of them are therefore being barred from their workplaces — non-health-related workplaces with 96% vaccination rates! Such policies are anti-scientific and anti-democratic.
Sometimes tyrannical practice springs from lust for power. Sometimes it springs from fear — of disease or litigation. Either way, it is wrong and should be opposed.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.