During the famines and relief campaigns of the late 1980s, a comedian named Sam Kinison had an unsettling but funny routine proposing that if we really wanted to help starving people, we’d stop sending them food.
Instead — his voice would crescendo dangerously — we’d send them U-Hauls and boxes.
“Move to where the food is!,” he’d scream. “You live in a desert! Nothing grows here! Nothing’s ever gonna grow here!”
And that’s true — unless you live in an American desert.
Exploring the vast American Southwest for the first time last month was both eye-opening and confusing. In almost three weeks spent hiking through national parks and visiting towns of varying sizes and purposes, we saw humans doing their best to protect and appreciate nature, and we saw others ignoring it so completely as to defy reason and, perhaps, spell doom.
Why can’t more of us get on the same page?
Our first two weeks were encouraging. During one week in Moab, Utah, we made five excursions into Arches National Park and two into Canyonlands and took two epic motorcycle rides along the Colorado River. We found the government’s preservation of Earth’s wonders and careful integration of human activity admirable and satisfying.
On cliffs towering over the Colorado as it flowed away from Moab, we spotted a series of metal bolts placed high above the roadway, with just enough space below for a car to pull over and climbers to ascend. Every spot was taken. Mere yards farther west we and dozens of others stopped to view amazing petroglyphs — art carved into the red-rock walls by Indigenous peoples over thousands of years.
It was the ancient and modern co-existing side-by-side. That juxtaposition was constantly before us in the national parks, where detailed signs at every landmark explained to 21st-century English speakers how these timeless wonders came to be.
This was half of the big, sobering “take-away” from our trip. Over many millions of years, seas rose and fell, deposited sand and carved it away, with help from wind and rivers and meteors. Climate did nothing but change. Animals and plant life came and went.
That’s the other half of our most lasting observation: the flailing human response to Earth’s constant evolution and majestic indifference.
Humans are the last to arrive on this scene. We carve our brief history into rocks or proclaim our latest understanding of Earth’s history on laminated signs at national parks.
We’re compelled to do this — “I was here!” — but the most important and appropriate response to the planet’s vast forces is respectful caution. That stance is not evident at either extreme of modern environmental debates.
On the one hand you have ecological alarmists who insist, despite millions of years of evidence, that humans can do much to mitigate forces infinitely more powerful than we are. Their crisis alerts reach us from their threatened oceanfront high-rises and snow-deprived Alpine resorts.
And on the other hand you have everyday people, modern pioneers, who shrug at current prevailing forces and decide to live and farm in inhospitable places.
“You live in a desert!” Move to where the food, or water, or cooler air is.
We encountered a rueful 40-something man in Jerome, Ariz., who’d driven up from his Phoenix home. He bought his house almost 20 years ago, he told us, but with Phoenix’s population explosion (11% growth from 2010 to 2020) and the accompanying spike in water use, his downtown home is literally sinking.
Ancient underground aquifers are being quickly depleted, and the water table is dropping. So, unevenly, is his house. He’s had to put many thousands of dollars into jacking it up.
The problem is that we are no longer nomads. In this little blip in Earth’s history, we’ve built cities — entire civilizations — in spots idyllic or challenging, conquering Mother Nature with our wits and pluck, expecting her never to change.
With nature, as in life, though, the only constant is change. We will have to adapt, more quickly than we ever imagined.
Ruth Ann Dailey: ruthanndailey@hotmail.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.