Anyone concerned over America’s sorry state in the Age of Twitter should read Anne Applebaum’s essay on what she regretfully calls — for lack of a better term — “cancel culture.”
Just published in The Atlantic magazine, her article tells of people “who have lost everything — jobs, money, friends, colleagues — after violating no laws and sometimes no workplace rules either.
“Instead,” she writes, “they have broken (or are accused of having broken) social codes having to do with race, sex, personal behavior, or even acceptable humor, which may not have existed five years ago or maybe five months ago.”
Under the headline “The New Puritans,” Ms. Applebaum opens hauntingly with a passage from “The Scarlet Letter,” connecting the Puritans’ shaming rituals to those of the modern workplace and classroom.
By contrast, the browser tab uses this title: “Mob Justice Is Trampling Democratic Discourse.”
Neither title quite hits the mark, but the second comes closer. After several readings of the essay, I think this really matters, because correctly labeling the phenomenon is key to battling it.
And it must be battled. As Ms. Applebaum demonstrates, people are losing “jobs, money, friends, colleagues” and, in one instance, life itself to the digital scourge. Harsh punishments inflicted without anything resembling due process threaten not just “democratic discourse” but our entire culture.
I understand evoking the Puritans to frame this issue. Nathaniel Hawthorne’s widely read story of Hester Prynne and her scarlet “A” mirrors the mercilessness and hypocrisy of today’s madness.
As in modern social media, Puritan peer pressure was a powerful force; the whole community shunned the outcast. But as harsh as they were — all law and no grace — the Puritans had a well-established legal/moral code, courts and judges.
The speed, anonymity and brutality of today’s punishment-without-trial cycle finds a better match, I think, in the bygone practice of tarring and feathering. American Colonists sometimes tarred and feathered British Loyalists. Pittsburgh-area distillers tarred and feathered a tax collector during the Whiskey Rebellion.
Neither Loyalists nor tax collector had committed any crime. They said or did or simply were something that a different group didn’t like. The group morphed into a mob, and outsiders were horribly punished — scarred for life, if they survived.
“Mob justice” is a contradiction in terms but entirely apt for the Twitter-verse and for the corporations, universities and political entities that now bow to its whims.
And these are whims — the arbitrary, cruel actions of social media’s mini-monarchs, crowned by their thousands of like-minded followers (who, statistically, skew young).
Ms. Applebaum marvels at how many victims of mob justice are in academia — without pointing out, as I will, how many of the unsubstantiated accusations come from college students.
Please overlook my blunt generalization: Many of today’s young adults — the generation that won soccer trophies just for showing up — are too psychologically delicate for the questioning and arguing of higher education. They are 19 going on 12.
They need affirmation, and if it doesn’t come from the professor/parent figure, it might come from taking down the professor/parent figure. Accusations — of an inappropriate word or look, “triggers” of “harassment” — are then cynically or fearfully pursued by jealous or self-protective administrators.
“Despite the right-wing rhetoric that says otherwise,” Ms. Applebaum asserts, “these procedures are not being driven by a ‘unified left’ … or by a unified movement of any kind.”
She discounts the fact that early “cancel” victims were conservative speakers invited to left-wing campuses or celebrities who violated the new gender politics. The newer victims she interviewed are self-described liberals or progressives.
If there is indeed no longer any unified force — if it’s just the mob’s addictive thrill in exercising its destructive power — no adult should cower in fear.
Instead, the overwhelming majority of us who deplore this folly should feel emboldened. We can and should speak up for those deprived of due process.
We should call out the lies and help fund lawsuits against the defamers.
If we don’t want to live under tyranny, we have to say “no” to the tyrants among us.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.