Wednesday will be the 50th anniversary of a Pittsburgh Pirates baseball game that made history.
The story wasn’t a big deal at the time. That fact should be a big deal today. It should give us pause as we assess — and possibly miss — how far we’ve come.
On Sept. 1, 1971, Pirates manager Danny Murtaugh put together a starting lineup that was all Black. It was a first in Major League Baseball, but few realized it at the time.
One of the men who played that day is remembered all over the world: Roberto Clemente, a great athlete and great humanitarian. Batting third, the right fielder drove in two runs that night, helping the Pirates beat Philadelphia 10-7.
Two other names in the history-making lineup — Willie Stargell and Manny Sanguillén — are familiar even to a lackadaisical sports fan like me. They batted fourth and fifth, respectively.
The other six were: second baseman Rennie Stennett (batting first); center fielder Gene Clines (second); third baseman Dave Cash (sixth); first baseman Al Oliver (seventh); shortstop Jackie Hernandez (eighth); and batting ninth, pitcher Dock Ellis.
Decades later, Oliver recalled, in an interview with MLB.com, that at some point, as he and Cash chatted in the dugout, “one of us said, ‘You know, we got all brothers out there, man’, and we kind of chuckled because it was no big deal to us.”
No one celebrated, but no one was upset, either. It was just another day at the ballpark.
The Pittsburgh newspapers were on strike at the time, but a Philadelphia paper noted the historic first and quoted Murtaugh: “When it comes to making out the lineup, I’m colorblind, and my athletes know it.”
I’d like to think the collective non-reaction also speaks well of Pittsburgh. Thanks to the Negro League teams’ dominance and vibrant history here, the city was used to Black athletic achievement equal or superior to what white players and teams accomplished.
It had been 24 years, though, since Jackie Robinson broke Major League Baseball’s color barrier. By 1971, African-American and Latin-American men made up nearly half of the Pirates roster.
But consider this lineup in the context beyond sports. Only a decade had passed since violent mobs attacked the Freedom Riders’ bus. Only eight years had passed since the March on Washington and Martin Luther King Jr.’s “I Have a Dream” speech. Only seven years had gone by since Congress passed the Civil Rights Act.
And just three years earlier, in April 1968, King had been assassinated.
On Sept. 1, 1971, however, reasonable people did something historic and good, shrugged and moved on.
In a 40th anniversary story in the Baseball Research Journal, pitcher Steve Blass remembered Murtaugh saying, “The best nine I put out tonight happen to be Black. No big deal. Next question.”
The non-story is the story. Treating this kind of milestone as a no-brainer increases the likelihood of it spreading and becoming, in retrospect, inevitable. It helps marginalize the haters.
Would we be so chill today?
Until very recently, the lineup was deemed “all Black.” Newer stories break down the color chart more carefully, as “African-American and Latin-American.” But the men in the dugout said, “We got all brothers out there.” It was enough to them to note their non-whiteness and get on with what mattered: playing their best.
Or consider Murtaugh’s claim to be “colorblind.” He’d be crucified for using that word now, but today’s anti-racist mob is wrong. He prioritized ability and ignored color, and he was right to do so.
Sports have a peculiar clarity, since success can be so easily measured. An athlete either delivers or doesn’t. Achievement doesn’t depend on the spectator’s tastes or bias. It makes sense, then, that race could be set aside in this industry before it was elsewhere.
We should be grateful to those who generated these changes. As we get used to it in one arena it tends to spill into others. And it has. We’ve made immense progress in just 50 years. Let’s not undo it.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.