Let’s pretend for a moment that people who would put forth statements highly critical of America during her annual birthday celebration are not acting out of cynical self-interest.

Let’s pretend they’re not just trying to make a media splash and attract “followers.”

Let’s entertain the possibility that some amount of their motivation is sincere and try to address their barbs.

Because they do have a point.

Advertise with us

Their tone may be snarky, their logic stunted and their timing execrable, but critics ranging from NPR’s Twitter feed to The New York Times to Black Lives Matter Utah have made valid points.

Staffers at National Public Radio decided to celebrate the Fourth of July with a series of tweets about the “flaws and deeply ingrained hypocrisies” in the Declaration of Independence: “It says ‘that all men are created equal’ — but women, enslaved people, Indigenous people and many others were not held as equal at the time.”

Well, that’s true, isn’t it?

The Founders were far ahead of their time, but their thinking and behaviors were still profoundly shaped by the prejudices and practices of that era — just as mine and those of NPR staffers are shaped by the prejudices and practices of this one.

The Founders were deeply divided over slavery. John and Abigail Adams loved Thomas Jefferson — “one of the choice ones of the Earth,” as she described him — but they were staunch abolitionists, as were many Northern colonists, and despaired at their friend’s slave-powered plantation.

Advertise with us

Is any adult human being shocked that Thomas Jefferson could put ideals on paper that he could not practice in real life? Doesn’t that describe us all — even the people at NPR?

Black Lives Matter Utah stirred controversy last weekend with a Facebook post stating, ”When we Black Americans see [the American] flag we know the person flying it is not safe to be around. When we see this flag we know the person flying it is a racist.

“It is a symbol of hatred.”

Lex Scott, founder of BLM Utah, expanded on the post in an interview with Fox News, pointing out that white supremacist groups such as the Ku Klux Klan and Proud Boys flamboyantly wave the Stars and Stripes.

“When you allow a hate group to fly that flag in the name of hatred, and you say nothing, and you do nothing,” she said, “you send a message to us that … [y]ou agree with that hate, and you condone it.”

Advertise with us

Though it’s buried in counterproductive condemnation, she makes an important point: Americans of all persuasions need to denounce hate merchants who sully our flag.

We might also need to push back against those who assert the flag is a symbol of hatred. Since the KKK has only about 3,000 members and Proud Boys “likely several hundred,” according to the Anti-Defamation League, there are no doubt many, many millions of people who deplore any association those groups might have with a flag that symbolizes liberty and justice for all.

Wouldn’t the beliefs of tens of millions outweigh a few thousand?

How can the millions speak out, though, short of posting comments incendiary enough — like Ms. Scott’s — to surface in the digital flood? It’s impossible: If all posts are attention-getting, none are.

Ms. Scott cannot know, nor can you or I, the rebukes and righteous witness that happen in real life. Falsely accusing decent people of hatred isn’t likely to make them your allies. Moreover, it adds to the nation’s rising tide of bile.

Advertise with us

Conservatives lashed out at NPR, at Ms. Scott and at an interesting, well-reported piece in The New York Times exploring the loaded meanings our symbolic flag has — for some — acquired.

I get it. People who love our nation and seek greater peace are weary of those who see nothing but flaws, who devote all their energy to criticizing or who spoil moments of joy for cynical self-promotion.

The disrupters may be self-righteous bullies or snarky masters of the obvious — or they may be telling us something we need to hear. A strong nation can listen and weigh their claims.

ruthanndailey@hotmail.com