From day one, Joe Biden said his presidency was going to seek unity.
Even before “day one,” actually — way back in December 2018, when he still hadn’t decided whether to run, Mr. Biden told Brown University students that the “grievance politics” pursued by both major political parties had “locked us into a divisive debate over the past.”
For our safety and security, he said, we need to recover our “shared narrative of freedom and democracy.”
If his analysis was accurate and his position sincere, what could possibly explain his speech Tuesday at the commemoration of the Tulsa Race Massacre?
This should have been an important moment in national history, one in which America acknowledged a horrific crime from its past and its highest-ranking government official stirred us to seek, well, the very unity he extols.
If the commemoration is remembered at all, it will be as a missed opportunity.
Some commentators have already skewered President Biden for his comments about white supremacy. He referenced it regularly in his speech and, to some extent, for good reason. It was indeed white supremacists who destroyed Tulsa’s large thriving Black business district and murdered at least 300 civilians.
It was indeed a massacre. A massacre demands our most humble and solemn frame of mind.
Why couldn’t Mr. Biden summon that gravitas? Why couldn’t he find the words to unite us against such depravity?
Why did he turn this hugely symbolic moment into a tacky partisan stump speech?
He used the occasion to tout many, many of his own initiatives — infrastructure investment such as street lights and high-speed internet, more federal contracts for minority-owned businesses and preschool for all from age 3, among others. These are ideas worth discussing and possibly pursuing, but they are more about promoting Joe Biden than uniting the rest of us in the journey toward a more just and harmonious nation.
Woven in with Mr. Biden’s justified references to white (and white-robed) domestic terrorism were constant criticisms of current Republican Party members and causes, their “unprecedented assault on democracy,” Democrats who undercut him by voting with Republicans, and so on.
“Terrorism from white supremacy is the most lethal threat to the homeland today,” he stated.
He claimed there was a “throughline” from Tulsa’s 1921 crimes to the protests against Confederate statue removal in Charlottesville, Va., in 2017, to the march-turned-riot at the U.S. Capitol five months ago.
All these words add up to a not-very-veiled and wildly inappropriate effort to tie the Republican Party to the Tulsa massacre.
These words are a betrayal of what Mr. Biden said he would be and do.
If you wanted to play his game, you’d point out that the white supremacists under the robes in Tulsa were Democrats. The KKK was a creation of Southern racists — the “Dixiecrats.”
Mr. Biden marvels now that people used to belong to the KKK openly, without “embarrassment.” He himself served in the U.S. Senate for 35 years with Robert Byrd, who launched his political career by organizing a large chapter of the Ku Klux Klan — in the early 1940s, during World War II, when America was fighting Nazism (white supremacy) in Europe.
But enough. As Mr. Biden deplored at Brown University, such tit-for-tat finger-pointing locks Americans into “a divisive debate over the past.”
Though these events had very different causes and outcomes, the “throughline” Mr. Biden sees from Tulsa to Charlottesville to the U.S. Capitol is human brokenness. Racial strife is inflamed by economic insecurities, envy and fear.
Human nature hasn’t changed in 100 years, but we cannot justify our own sins by pointing to the sins of others. Instead we must confess and make atonement — both individually and collectively. The collective effort can’t continue, though, until the finger-pointing and political smearing stops.
Many of us are eager to move beyond politics to address the profound challenges we face. Mr. Biden had a somber centennial event to prompt us in that direction. He failed.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.