Maybe Margaret Atwood needs to update “The Handmaid’s Tale.”
Her Reagan-era novel imagines a totalitarian theocracy where women must hide their bodies under shapeless robes but also must provide those bodies to bear their religious overlords’ children. Non-fertile women are assigned other tasks, like conducting indoctrination classes.
No such thing has come to pass, nor appears remotely possible. Back in the 1980s, Ms. Atwood’s fearsome inspiration was the emergence of a Christian voting bloc and its perceived threat to legalized abortion and female autonomy.
We still argue over abortion and always will, but the shapeless robe thing was never gonna happen: Evangelical women swapped their skirts and culottes for jeans in the ‘70s and never looked back.
Now the ones wishing for shapeless robes are Billie Eilish fans. The 19-year-old music phenomenon “known for defying gender stereotypes” by adopting a baggy-tracksuit uniform has riled some fans, says the New York Times, by posing for British Vogue in Marilyn Monroe-meets-dominatrix garb. Her black and neon-green hair is now platinum blonde.
Ms. Eilish looks stunning, but not everyone is happy. She anticipated this in the accompanying interview, preemptively proclaiming, “My thing is that I can do whatever I want.”
She incidentally just spoke for most Americans. We might qualify her phrase with encomiums to family, faith and community, but determining “the pursuit of happiness” for ourselves is the strongest strain in our cultural DNA. Our staunch individualism unites us.
When Ms. Eilish was still wearing shapeless “athleisure” clothing, she insisted her choice was not meant to “slut-shame” performers who bare nearly all to sell music. And she won’t be shamed now that’s she’s expanding, or is it shrinking, her wardrobe.
It’s worth noting any time the concerns of religious conservatives and ardent feminists overlap — how the abandonment of modesty, the monetizing of women’s bodies and the degradation of women in pornography have damaged those who consume it all, especially the young and especially females.
Though some upward moral evolution would be welcome, American individualism means baggy tracksuits or robes are optional. But what of the other part of Ms. Atwood’s dystopian tale — the specter of indoctrination into a way of thinking antithetical to the American mindset?
There’s no fear of that from organized religion. Though conservative Christian congregations continue to thrive, their doctrine, like America’s, emphasizes individual choice and commitment. Millennials and Gen-Z kids are choosing “no religious affiliation” in ever higher numbers. No threat here.
Of course there’s the subtle indoctrination we experience every time we open Facebook or our smartphone newsfeed, but again, we choose this.
No, take a good look around the cultural landscape and you’ll find only one area of forced indoctrination. America’s re-education camps unfold in corporate Zoom meetings.
Our “thought leaders” and executive class have embraced the doctrine of antiracism — a shockingly fast acceptance of a shockingly hateful narrative — or they’re eager to appear to embrace it (to allay erosion of their market share, in a good old American shakedown).
They enact the rituals of confession and cleansing for the one sin modern Americans have proven willing to own, coercing employees and students to do likewise and making their secular priests millionaires.
While our surviving media giants publish stories on China’s oppression of its religious minorities, its electronic spying and internment camps, they ignore massive violations of conscience here at home. Instances of abusive antiracist classroom training are apparently not news.
But Americans are throwing off the pandemic fugue and rejecting a dogma that asserts the only answer to racism is more racism. A Texas school district made news last week when an unusually large turnout produced a board that vows to reject the anti-racism curriculum. Court cases challenging the indoctrination are popping up everywhere.
And they should, for the simple truth that no evil is conquered with more evil. “Rather overcome evil with good,” to quote some of that terrifying Bible stuff.
Ms. Atwood’s dystopia, alive on television, needs a rewrite. Evil is a shapeshifter, and threats to liberty are lurking, unrobed and unexamined, in plain sight.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.