My mom is an unusually generous person. Although she and Dad lived on his modest minister’s salary for decades, she has always given with an open hand — to the church, the food pantry, neighbors in need, favored charities and to us.

When her government checks started arriving two decades ago, she began randomly sending her three kids greeting cards with checks for $100 or $200 tucked inside and the suggestion that we treat ourselves or her grandchildren to “something nice.”

And when we protest, she always says — always — “Well, Social Security isn’t going to be there when it’s time for you to get it, so I’m giving it to you now.”

She was 6 years old in 1935, when Social Security was created. I hope she isn’t right, but things are looking a little dicey. How incoherent can our economic policies get before the federal edifice collapses?

Advertise with us

In this new century, the government has not been run by the Greatest Generation — those who, like my mom, weathered the deprivations of the Depression and the sacrifices of World War II.

Their grown children are now in charge, the boomers they raised in postwar abundance. Boomers encountered nothing but blue skies until well into adulthood. Most of them — of “us,” I should say — believe comfort and stability are our birthright. Should those seem threatened, why, government can and must protect us, whatever the cost.

It’s been a long time since any sizable contingent of legislators from either major party voted reliably as if there were any such thing as a bill coming due.

That’s how we end up with the latest coronavirus aid package, at a cost of $1.9 trillion. That’s borrowed money — borrowed from our kids and grandkids.

Was it necessary? At the depths of the Great Depression, unemployment reached 25%. It was catastrophic. Families were larger then (my mom had eight siblings), and one-quarter of the workforce idled meant many more humans going hungry.

Advertise with us

When our nation responded to the coronavirus pandemic last year by shuttering industries that couldn’t operate on a remote basis and were deemed “nonessential,” the unemployment rate spiked to an all-time post-Depression high of 14.7%.

That number represents serious pain, and Congress responded with a $2.2 trillion relief bill, the CARES Act, in late March 2020. By July, as America tentatively reopened for business, unemployment had fallen to 10.2%. From October to now, it has fallen from 6.9% to 6.2%.

Compare that to the economy’s performance after the housing bubble burst in 2008. Unemployment hit 10% in February 2009 and was still at 8% in January 2013. That is, through the first five years of the Obama administration — and after the massive stimulus package of 2009 — unemployment was higher than it was for all but six months of 2020.

In 2015 the Joint Economic Committee of Congress studied the eight most-recent recessions and concluded “the Obama recovery ranks dead last.” But here we are in 2021, doubling down on the same approach.

Republicans opposed the Biden stimulus bill, asserting that only 10% of its largesse was pandemic-related and that a quickly improving economy and vaccine rollouts make massive government spending unnecessary.

Advertise with us

What’s different from 2008, though, is the scope and stealth of today’s crisis. The housing bubble wasn’t nationwide; its destructive collapse left some states unscathed.

But COVID-19 has touched every corner of America. It thundered in, brought death and suffering, and upended almost every aspect of life. The fear and psychological pain are greater, for a much greater number of people.

And so a strong majority of the population supports another injection of “government money” to protect us from the virus’s toll — even though just a few carefully targeted programs would have sufficed, and even though someone, someday, will have to pay for this solace.

My parents just shake their heads at the news. They can’t comprehend borrowing from their children, rather than giving to them. I hope our kids won’t be shaking their heads at us someday too.

ruthanndailey@hotmail.com