It is common understanding that the pandemic has exposed some startling vulnerabilities in our society.
We learned that domestic manufacturing capabilities are inadequate. That keeping small inventories of emergency supplies is shortsighted. That trusting rival, even hostile nations to produce critical items for us quickly, competently and fairly priced is foolish.
(Remember the two Chinese companies that sold 2 million unworkable coronavirus tests to the British government for $20 million?)
And we learned that many people are just a paycheck away from serious need. From the pain of this last realization, I believe, springs much (but not all) of the desire to address this vulnerability in a decisive, large-scale way.
Thus the current proposal to double the federal minimum wage.
As a freelance writer well-acquainted with minimum-wage work, I know the “invisible hand” of the marketplace can really slap people around.
That “hand” can also be wielded by the dishonest and shortsighted, which is why we’ve chosen to build some safeguards into the marketplace. But how much?
And is compassion the only thing driving the issue now?
If we want to address society’s vulnerabilities, we have to face how and why those vulnerabilities came to exist. “Fair wages” are not an exception to this principle.
Briefly consider the inadequate inventories of health care equipment needed to battle COVID-19. In recent decades, many businesses adopted a low-inventory strategy to cut costs (for storage and inventory management) and to free up cash to use elsewhere.
But as we’ve learned, painfully, some products needed in crisis must be stockpiled, regardless of short-term costs, because the long-term costs — in illnesses and deaths — are devastating.
The dearth of critical items was an unforeseen and unintended consequence of many companies’ seemingly smart approach to allocating resources.
Will there be “unintended consequences” from raising the minimum wage? Of course, but since we already know what some of them will be, we cannot rightly call these consequences “unintended.”
There will be fewer jobs available to young and less-skilled workers — the very people we say we want to help, the people already bearing the brunt of the COVID-19 economic contraction.
When you raise the price of anything, people buy less of it. This happens at both ends of the supply chain, and all along it, of course. It’s Economics 101, but it’s worth recapping:
Employers buy labor from workers. If a product or service doesn’t sell for enough to cover a big increase in the cost of labor, then employers will buy less labor. Result: fewer jobs.
Or the business will raise the price of its product to cover increased labor costs. Consumers either pay more for it, eroding those wage gains, or they buy less of it, causing the business to contract. Result: fewer jobs.
When wages rise organically, it’s a different story. That’s what we were seeing just before the pandemic: full employment, with people re-entering the job market after years of non-participation.
We even saw employers competing for scarce workers, which means rising wages.
Economists already see signs of growth again, but our political leaders have been artificially managing the economy for a year now and don’t seem inclined to let go. They felt compelled to do so in response to the pandemic, or so they said, but many of their actions have been unpredictable, illogical and arbitrary, and have wrought devastation.
The greatest devastation has been to the restaurant industry, where minimum and sub-minimum wages are the norm. With this sector and small businesses of all kinds struggling to hang on, why would we further undercut them by doubling their labor costs?
Are we really trying to help workers? Or are some activists actually eager to see, for reasons of political power, more economic upheaval than we’ve already weathered?
Maryland, Montana and Mississippi don’t have identical economies. Neither do Pittsburgh and Punxsutawney.
The federal government, incapable of fine-tuning, should act modestly, if at all, and leave the high-impact decisions to us, state by state, city by city and worker by worker.
ruthanndailey@hotmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.